I told my wife in New England, pizzerias are like Tex-Mex joints in Texas - they are plentiful and mostly excellent.
Thus, after a small and mediocre meal, we found ourselves still hungry and based upon what the staff at our hotel said, "people in Strasburg get their pizza there," we went.
Inside, we found exactly what we were expecting - a no-frills, family run establishment which appeared to have been in operation forever.
There was the requisite pizza maker focusing on his craft while everyone else cooked around him in an open kitchen.
The owner came from the rear of our restaurant to take our order for pepperoni pizza and it was ready in about 15 minutes.
When we took it back to our hotel room, we opened the box and proceeded to enjoy Italian-American excellence.
The crust is soft, thin, New York style.
The sauce was delicious...if a bit too sweet.
The cheese and pepperoni was also excellent.
All in all, my wife and I enjoyed this establishment, and if we lived in the area, we would definitely frequent.
Skip the apps and get a stramboli....yum! Apps are typical freezer things but pizza and Stromboli are made in ovens in front of you.
My family and I went here after seeing a show at Sight & Sound since it is close by. Great pizza! Friendly staff and very well-lit, clean environment! I was worried we might have to wait long since the show had just gotten out, but we didn't. Definitely would recommend here if you're seeing a show there. Right down the road and plenty of parking.
I'd never had a "Sicilian Pizza" before I went to this place and honestly they've set a pretty high bar, because the pizza is fantastic! My only issue is that the past couple of times we've ordered from here, we would order through Slice and I don't know if a new person started, but we wouldn't get notifications that our food was ready for pickup. This only happened in the last 2 months. We've ordered from here for the past 2 years and this only recently started happening. Other than that, the food is fantastic and priced very fairly for how much of it you get! A Sicilian Pizza for a couple can last you 3-4 days with how large they are. You'll get sick of pizza before you finish it.
We stood out in Peach Bottom for a week vacation away from California. Came down to the Strasburg railroad for the train ride. We stopped in before the ride and came back again a few days later for some more 😂. Thank you for the great pizza and hospitality.
The pizza here was sooo good! It was well made and worth the price. It has a great environment, and the Phillies game was on. They said about twenty five minutes, and it came out exactly at 25 minutes. Thanks to the guys at Strasburg Pizza for keeping small businesses thriving! We will be back soon!
After several days touring Lancaster County, we had more than our fill of Amish food.
Stopped in here for Cheesesteaks &. Fries, Fried Mushrooms, Onions Rings, etc..
Food is delicious, and the staff was friendly.
From Morgantown New Holland Gap parkesburg.
This is hands down the best Pizza
I've eaten n this good of a pizza in a long time. Maybe we got lucky but it was Perfection nonetheless
Great service
Cozy, brighter then most atmosphere.
After a long day of sightseeing and walking, we picked up a medium plain pizza from Strasburg Pizza to bring back to our room for dinner.
It's our second meal for the day and was delicious.
Had them crisp it up with no burn.
Crust was crunchy, minimal to no flop, cheese and sauce was tasty.
They meet the requirements to be called good 🍕 Pizza!!!
Long time customer we love this place. Excellent food and super clean and friendly. Folks that work here do a great job, all worked here a long time. Good people too. Always happy to support our favorite pizza place<3
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes