Sluurpy > Restaurants in Sturgeon Bay > Nightingale Supper Club
Nightingale Supper Club - Sturgeon Bay - Photo album
This is an old school supper club, decorated in classic nautical style, complete with rope chandeliers. It’s popular and gets busy on weekends, so when we wanted to do a girls night but couldn’t get reservations until late, we decided to order prime rib for carryout, open a bottle of wine and have a
My son and I had a fabulous dinner here last night. The potato skin appetizer was like no other I have ever had, sliced skins covered with cheese and bacon, delicious. The chicken vegetable soup, fresh bread and side salad were perfect, full of flavor and fresh. The fried shrimp were large and gentl
The food was amazing, the creamy crab and asparagus soup was the best soup ive ever had, however we got sat in the corner and I think our server forgot about us. Took him quite a while to come over and acknowledge us. Maybe he was new or just having an off night. So we will definitely be back to try
We had reservations for 730. Upon arrival, we were given a pager while they got our table ready. We took a seat at the bar and I ordered a Cherry Cosmo. We barely got our drinks and our pager went off. We were seated in the beautiful dining room and our server greeted us almost immediately. She made
The food is fantastic, the atmosphere is perfect. Service was top-notch. They have a lounge area with a bar and plenty of seating for while you wait for a table. Though it says club, no membership is required. Come with a date, a big group of friends, or treat the family.
Was in Sturgeon Bay, WI for an event last week and had the pleasure of dining at this lovely establishment our first night in - we were a 50+ party and both at the bar area ahead of dinner, as well as at our tables, all were served as if the staff were merely waiting on a couple or two.
Very fast, v
Went for prime rib night and it didn't disappoint. Good service. Did not like the prime rib nachos. Beef would have been better. Also salsa and sour cream should be on the nachos not a small container used for side dressing. Drinks were good.
Great food, Great Atmosphere all in all I highly recommend! Be aware when we went there, the wait was 1.5 hours on a Tuesday. It was not the restaurants fault. We did have a group of 8 people and were told by a local to not worry about making a reservation as it was a Tuesday. Just be mindful a
WOW. We are on a mission to hit ever supper club in Wisconsin, and this one blew us away. Exceptionally clean, beautiful updated decor, and the food was superior. Just look at the pictures. There wasn’t a single crumb on the ground. The furniture and paint looked new and clean. Beautiful wall art of
Slight wait even with reservations. Bar atmosphere was nice though and helped pass the time. Stuffed mushrooms were AMAZING! Definitely would order again. Prime rib had great flavor and was cooked perfectly. My husband ordered the chicken sandwich and was blown away by how good it was. Grasshopper t
The drinks were amazing. Highly recommend the door county Cosmo and the espresso martini.
Food is also great.
Highly recommend the bacon wrapped scallops for an app and prime rib for dinner
Staff was friendly especially the bartenders.
Will be returning anytime I'm in the area.
Firstly I would like to say the customer service was over the top, From the bar to the table every employee made sure we had our drinks , made sure our food was exactly what we ordered ( delicious may i
Add ), absolutely the best experience yet this year at an establishment, we will definitely be
Salena provided friendly service. The pork chop and Caesar salad were delish. Old fashioneds at the bar prior were tasty.
Super busy place, but service was quick and attentive. Excellent prime rib and white fish, crisp salad with blue cheese crumbles and garlic mashed potatoes. Highly recommend this place. Make reservations!
Sad that I’m not able to experience such tasty food more often, lol.. If I lived in the area this would probably be my go-to. We had a 6pm reservation and we were sat promptly. Within 15 minutes of sitting we’d already had our drinks and our appetizer (the stuffed mushrooms 😍), I got a salad with my
I was very impressed by the Nightingale Supper Club. We did not have a reservation so we enjoyed the potato skin appetizer and drinks before dinner. The bar area is very impressive with quite a few chairs and tables and large to accommodate lots of people. I liked the atmosphere - very relaxing and
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes