The gluten free vegan pizza I got here was hands down the best I've had! Thank you so much for keeping the prices for something I can actually eat reasonable. The cauliflower puree was genius! Also our server was incredible and very knowledgeable. I'll definitely be back.
We really enjoy the creative pairings of meat and veggies on the pies. They are always well executed - great crusts! And we should know as my step-son does great pizza from his food trucks in Eugene, OR. He’s opening his first brick-and-mortar place in March- Bartolotti’s. Wish him luck and if his place is as good as Salvatore’s, he will be successful.
OMG we had the most fantastic NYE meal here. From the moment we walked in and
were greeted with a warm hello to the wonderful appetizer recommendation by our fabulous waitress! It just got better and better. We regularly order their pizza
to enjoy at home but coming here was a treat and may become our annual
NYE hot spot! If you haven’t been to the restaurant GO! If you are lucky enough to have Renee wait on you it will be a great dining experience!
We always have a good experience but tonight the staff went above and beyond for one of our kids. The food from pizzas to the burger are always good. Love that the food is locally sourced and such high quality. Fantastic building and that it is in Sun Prairie is perfect. They do get busy at times but it is so easy to make a reservation on-line.
I really can't believe there is not more one star reviews. MY assumption of the world is that there's a lot of people that hate everything ...(the service, the food, the decor, the wait, the ambience...) If you want to have the best tomato pie and or appetizer and or entree...just give Salvatore's a try.
if you do not live in sun prairie do not eat their pizza. I now have to live my life being disappointed with all the other pizza places in my hometown. the mcslayer burger could turn a vegan straight again.
Robert Gadgetguy Warren
+5
Had dinner at an awesome little pizza place called Salvatore's tonight and the Tomato Pie was delicious!! Our waitress was equally awesome, she was very friendly and did a fantastic job of serving us. Great place to eat!
I love the new Sun Prairie location! I was expecting only pizza but was pleasantly surprised with the other menu items like tacos, burgers and salads! We had great service and I like the open kitchen concept in the back!! Will definitely be back!
The food was outstanding and the service was excellent! If you’re looking for a wonderful selection of pizza, this is the place.
Amanda Stretch Koch Roberts
+5
We love it here! Awesome food with great flavor combinations. You must try the grilled corn, Trenton mule and (of course) the pizza!
This place is amazing! They put lots of care, lots of flavor, lots of fresh ingredients, and A touch of class in every item on the menu!Well...not a fan of the cheese bread. But aside from that we have thoroughly enjoyed every item that we have ordered. The specials are amazing! KUDOS to Salvatore's!!
Get here! Great antipasti with pickled veggies, salami, pruschutto, goat cheese and Wisconsin cheddar. Signature pies are really good and gluten free crust was cooked perfectly.
Amazing calamari and pizza. We will return! Our waiter was wonderful.
We had to wait a really long time for our pizza. Not sure what happened. But our waiter was great and kept checking on us. He even gave us a 25% discount. The wait was SO WORTH IT! It was probably the best pizza we have had! We also loved the burrata bruschetta appetizer. Can't wait to go back!
Great pizza and our waitress was very friendly! It's a trendy, hip place.... SP needed this!
The best pizza I've had in a very long time. The crust was done just right, not hard but soft and the toppings were fresh and delicious. Would go there again and again.
Excellent service. I've read others say it can be quite loud but I did not find that to be the case on the busy Saturday night I was in. The only mistake you can make here is to only order pizza because absolutely everything on the menu is curated with the utmost care and attention to detail. Great GF crust as well, and that's not easy!
Salvatore’s has the best pizza ever! Hands down! The fat uncle Tony is an absolute must. Even their vegan pizza is delicious! The staff is always friendly and attentive. I’ve been here multiple times and not once have had a bad experience or an order messed up. You will not be disappointment if you choose this place for an evening out. It’s also decorated real cool inside.
Really good pizza, I really like the figgy piggy. My only complaint would be the delivery. It's a huge issue and ALWAYS late. The time they give you is NEVER the time it's delivered. Last weekend I called for delivery and the person taking my order marked it as pickup...after calling as to where the food is took an extra 45min to get dinner. Currently waiting for pizza that was supposed to be here 45min ago...
My family has never been disappointed at Salvatore’s. The food is stellar and the service is great. The pizza is just one of the culinary masterpieces that Salvatore’s serves up.
My wife and I recently fell in love with an amazing corned beef special (pictured). My son (6yrs old) always orders off the appetizer menu preferring the street corn or the sea scallops.
Thank you for having some vegan, gluten free, egg, dairy free options!! Some of us cannot have these things due to medical reasons and it's so RARE and NICE to have GOOD food that you can actually eat!! Would highly recommend
Stopped into Salvatore's on my way back from Chicago. The menu has a few things that sound interesting but when I go back I'll probably stick to pizza. The Figgy Piggy was almost too unique for me but was still great. Great prices as well.
Absolutely fantastic place! The Herb and cheese bread is “FIRE” add the bacon. Their specialty drinks are absolutely delicious. Very friendly staff. In my top 3 pizza places and they have so much more then just pizza
Just had the Tikka Masala pasta.....one of the best things I have eaten. Chef Brian did an amazing job. I cannot wait to eat this dish again. I also love the East Coast Rocker pizza. So grateful for this awesome restaurant
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes