Food was fine, if a little high. I've gotten used to the quantity of the Michaelangelo's in Greenville over the years and all those locations are comparable in quality and menu. This pizza is fundamentally different than the other chain locations (I'm assuming it's a franchise) and as such they don't have the extra large new York style slices I'm accustomed to, nor do they have deals for specialty pizzas, so if you want something with a decent amount of toppings, expect to pay through the nose. Overall the pizza was good just not the Michaelangelo's I was expecting.
The servings size was great! The food was very tasty! Felt that you got good value for your food. Called in the order and it was ready in 20 minutes.
We stopped in here for lunch while visiting from out of town and enjoyed ourselves! It was during a dead period and there was only 1 server (Payton) and we received great service. She was very friendly and talked to our kids (8 and 6) about their orders. My daughters ordered the half roast beef sub and spaghetti with meatballs and garlic knots. The garlic knots weren't great, but they loved the rest of their meals. My husband and I ordered the stromboli and ham & cheese sub. Both were delicious. We ordered cannolis for dessert and they were very rich & yummy!
The pizza was great. We ordered a large pizza and the slices are more then expected.
It was a great fast dinner for our first night here on vacation. Our vrbo owner left a flyer on the fridge.
What a hidden gem this place is 👏 excellent pizza cooked perfectly crispy and the garlic knots were great. Service was great and food was fresh!
We ordered 3 takeout pizzas (all with different toppings), and we were very pleased with all of them. Parking is tight in this very busy shopping center, but judging by our food, worth it!
Fantastic pizza if you're into the floppy, cheesy, crispy-crust style like myself. Steak & cheese sub was delicious & service was fast & super friendly. Definitely coming back w/ every trip to the coast!!
By far the best NY style pizza I have found yet in the Topsail Sail Surf City area. The surf city location was really cool old school pizza shop. Lots of seating to eat in.
The pizza was perfect, and frankly worth the price!
Great crust with just the right snap, yet still soft. You can pick up a slice fold it just like you are supposed to!
Service was great, and friendly as well! Cool little pizza shop!
Pizza is great, wings are huge and cooked to the perfect crisp. Their drivers can only accept cash tips so make sure you have some handy to tip the drivers!
Pizza was fresh and delicious!
Order at the counter, fill your own soft drinks. Pizza was very good.
We stopped by Michaelangelo's after playing putt putt while on vacation. This place was great!!! They have some of the best pizza we have ever eaten, and trust me, we've had a lot of pizza from a lot of places. It was so delicious that we stopped by again on our way out and ordered two large pizzas to take home (4 hours away). We will definitely be back next year!!!
We got takeout there. The reviews made me cautious, but like with everything these days, things are hit and miss. We got pizza with half/half toppings, a gluten free pizza and a calzone we asked for extra sauce with. They got the order right, so that was great. The pizza was pretty good. They have a mild, marinara sauce (not sweet) and a non-sweet crust that was also very good. I thought their gluten free pizza was one of the better ones I’ve had. The sausage was super spicy, and good if you like the heat. The people who ordered the calzone said it was really good as well.
We have ordered sub sandwiches from. Michaelangelo's, Meat Balls sub. An Chicken Parmesan.
Both subs were great.
Just make sure you have them repeat your request.
Or you may not get what you order.
It is some times hit an miss.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes