TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in United States - Updated October 2024

Sugar Island Bakery

95/100 (414 ratings)

Dessert

Bakeries

Cafe

American

Breakfast

Key lime pie

Cupcakes

Macarons

Macaroons

Cakes

Sit down

Café

American

Takeout

Breakfast

Cheap Eats

"The first time I walked into Sugar Island Bakery I felt like family. This amazing group of people have created a cozy atmosphere of heaven here on..."

Taylor Maready

"By far the best place in the Wilmington and surrounding area for baked goods and coffee. The homemade jam bars have to be my favorite snack item..."

Ryan Fonz Fonville

"This is a wonderful place for a dessert, coffee, and just relaxing. A very unique place with tables to set and read or eat. A great selection of..."

Brenda Norman Foss

"We are in town for a week at the beach & were looking for a coffee shop - and were luckily enough to stop in Sugar Island. The place made us feel..."

Michelle Christine Fawcett

"Bakery goods are irresistible! They even make gluten-free options! The GF Raspberry Oatmeal Bar is out of this world and leaves me wanting..."

Zay Zen Kelley

"Great bakery run by great people! Everything in here looks, smells, and taste amazing! And they even..."

Donnie Stone

"Just tried the lemon blueberry pie from Sugar Island Bakery ...it was delivered to us still warm. It made me so happy!!! It was absolutely..."

Eva LuAnne Sciscoe

"Excellent place to grab a great cup of coffee. Wonderful charming customer service. Very tasty goodies. I will be returning to this charming..."

Camilla Lambert

"Hands down the best bakery I've ever been to. Books galore, and so much yumminess to eat and drink while you're there. You're treated like family. We..."

Ellyette Elise Kleppen

"I love this bakery! The food is superb and the customer service is one of the highest on the island! I recommend any of the squares, the granola is..."

Kele Rose Bradshaw

"Everything here is delicious! The coffee drinks are fantastic and the bookstore upstairs is so..."

Punita Koustubhan

"One of my favorite spots! It is worth the adventure to try Sam's creative treats of the day! The cheddar pigs are amazing by themselves or in soup!..."

Sheri Minnich Mcdermott

"Best little bakery and bookstore around! The genius mocha is amazing! And ginger cookies and apple kuchen! Soooooo good! Can't wait for my next beach..."

Katy Johnson

"We spent a few hours here looking at the books, antiques and then had their amazing coffee and scrumptious chocolate chip cookies!! I'd travel back..."

Michelle Larson

"I'm so in love with this little bakery! Everything is made fresh that day by the owner. The sweets, the fresh local coffee (currently filling my car..."

Jenn Keane

"One of my all time favorite places to visit. Last time we were in, my son said he wanted to live there. Not only do they have delicious drinks and..."

Diana Yntema

"Loved this cute shop. Coffee, books, and old things. Heaven for this reader. Blind date with a book was fun. It ended up being a book I never would..."

Jen

"My all time favorite bakery! I've kept up with this bakery since they were located in Old Books in downtown Wilmington. The owners are friendly and..."

Ashton Fonville

"My family and I have been coming to Topsail Island for our yearly vacation for the past 5 or 6 years. Sugar Island is one of the places we have to..."

Tina Henry

"This place is absolutely wonderfull, my cousin and I came while on vacation and we wish we never had to leave. The aesthetic here is absolutely..."

Kate Sanders

"Lots of books, owners of shop very sweet. Lots of pastries, freezer items, and coffee selections. This is our second year returning and they..."

Cassandra Smith

"Great store that has secondhand items and used books for sale. Local art, baked goods, fresh eggs, coffee, and similar all of high quality. We go..."

Cian Robinson

"Little coffee and book shop with neat things to look through. Make sure you go upstairs, too! Staff was friendly and thankful that we stopped..."

Jennifer Martin

"Really cute bakery. Surprised by the books available and other knick knacks. Lended to a very relaxed vibe. Chocolate cake was very good,..."

1mangoldrush

"Incredible lattes, great service and conversation, lots of fun and interesting books (especially in the kid's section upstairs) that brought back..."

Francesca Pabon

"This is probably my favorite place in Surf City. The local treats are amazing (particularly the key lime pie) and their butter beer drink is..."

Meghan Pauley

"Our first visit while vacationing. Best banana bread I've ever eaten, great coffee! Quaint shop with books, art, jewelry and other gifts to choose..."

Betsy Hobbs

"Amazing local find! Terrific coffee, delicious snacks, and lots of other goodies for sale (e.g., jams, ground coffee, toys). Be sure to check out the..."

Doug Rupert

"What a lovely surprise! I stopped here on a whim for a coffee and ended up leaving with some baked goods too. Everyone was very kind, the treats are..."

Natalie Ryland

"Very unique store! They no longer serve alcohol which is fine because they baked goods are so amazing it makes up for it! We got the snicker doodle..."

D Peterson

"Absolutely adorable place with a warm welcome atmosphere! Awesome latte and selection of interesting and amazing..."

eel eek

"They have the most fantastic scones and jam bars I’ve ever eaten. So tasty! Cookies and other baked goods are great too. I haven’t tried the..."

Kaye Bowman

"Great little shop. Very very interesting shop, actually. I feel like describing it would ruin the magic of just visiting and experiencing the store..."

Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Cupcakes in Surf City

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters