Thank you so much, Dylan for the amazing cake for my daughter. Not only did it look beautiful but it tasted great. Everyone loved it. We also love the breakfast sandwiches and pastries. Love the atmosphere and staff. They are so helpful and sweet. Thank you!
Cute cafe. Came here after dinner for some dessert and coffee and tea. They had a wide selection of sandwiches, pastries, cakes, and candy. Hit the spot for our sweet tooth fix
Delicious cake, amazing staff - who dealt with my craziness on such short notice. Beautifully decorated and brought such a smile to my 16-year-old daughter's face (which isn't easy😉) Even the restaurant staff was impressed by the taste and texture of the cake. Can't wait to stop in again for a treat
One of the most gorgeous cakes - ever created - Dylan, cake designer, exceeded our expectations!!!! We are so grateful. The cake looked almost too good to eat, thankfully it tasted incredible, as we of course, we ate it ! Price was more reasonable than any other place around ! we were thrilled - c
Our wedding cake came from Stellina‘s. Custom made. Not only a beautiful look, but also the best taste ever for a wedding cake. Perfect balance of cream/custard, light dough, fresh fruits. A delight. All our guests loved it and asked where it was coming from. THANK YOU Stellina’s team.
Strawberry shortcake 8” $38 - 6.5/10
Strawberry filling 10/10, fresh and just right amount of sweetness. Flawless.
Frosting 10/10. Fresh, light, right amount of sweetness.
Cake layers itself - 6/10. Moderately dry / stale cake. And you can see in the picture, the layers aren’t fluffy, it’s a bit
I had the rainbow donut and it was insanely good. It was like having an elite rainbow cookie in donut form. The service was fantastic. The person who helped me was extremely helpful and friendly
We visited Cardinali Bakery for their Croissant but most pastries ran out at about 2pm on a Sunday afternoon. We were kind of disappointed but we might plan to come earlier next time.
The options of their dessert were various and we had difficulties making up our decisions. The staff was friendly a
Stellina or the old Cardinali Bakery is our “go to” b/c of how careful and kind they were to us when I asked about nut allergies. I called about which cakes were safe for our son. They asked the baker and since then Strawberry shortcake has been our staple for friends and family.
Super fresh and ab
If you want a specialty cake for a special occasion, then this is your place! Dylan made us the most beautiful black and white graduation cake for our daughter! Everyone was so impressed. It was delicious as well!!!
Regarding the wonderful staff. One that stands out from all is Rosa. I am a long time customer of Cardinalis and she is so nice and helpful every time I come in. Her experience is beyond amazing. She knows all the products and she knows all of the customers. She makes you feel welcome and appreciate
One of our favorite bakeries on Long Island. Fresh baked, flavorful, decadent, non-greasy finishes. Particularly love the chocolate cakes!
I ordered a carrot cake for a friend through UberEats and the cake was delivered within the hour :-D. The birthday boy loved it and was soo happy with it, he asked for the bakery's address. His words "Delicious, moist and creamy". The bakery called as well for a Happy Birthday message. Thank You Ca
Great atmosphere, great food, great people, and ownership!
Great bakery! Pasties are fresh and gorgeous. The burger was tender, juicy and full of flavor.
I ordered my wedding cake from cardinali syosset through their baker Luigi. It was so nice meeting him! He made me a cappuccino while we talked details, and he offered to make me a sample… The next day I get an email that it’s ready for me and boy was it delicious and HUGE! I am so thrilled with my
this place is incredible i adore the guy who was working there, he recommended the oatmeal cookies AND THEY WERE LIFE ALTERING they were soso good i literally walked back in and asked for 4 more. mr. oatmeal cookie man thank you i love you
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes