Great family owned business!! Support Local!
I am a native New Yorker and finding NY style pizza in Syracuse is tough. From the moment you walk in the door at Nick's you're taken back to a traditional style pizza with the scents of crispy pizza dough and simmering tangy sauce and lots of melted moz
I like the food overall.
To Owner:
If the owner would seal the calzone edges (both sizes) shut, I'd order a couple each month as the food is good quality.
What do I mean by sealed ?
Calzones usually have 1 opening, a hole at the top to vent the excess steam pressure from cooking. Folding dough on it
My husband and I discovered Nick's when we moved to East Syracuse a little over 1yr ago. Their pizza is so good, our go to spot. Plus their oatmeal raisin cookies are delicious. The gentleman who cashed me out saw I had my baby with me and carried my pizzas to my car. Very thankful for the service!
I have been touring the Finger lakes for 2 weeks and today I ordered a plain cheese pizza and was fabulous. Great crust, cheese and sauce. Delivery was quick and the driver was very polite and courteous. A big thanks to Nick's you saved my day.
If you want awesome pizza, look no further. Nicks is THE place for pizza. They have an assortment of slices each day to choose from. If you want a ridiculously delicious sub sandwich, try the Philly Steak and cheese. Loaded and definitely worth a try.
This is by far the best pizza I have had in a LONG time! Definitely quality ingredients! Super fresh! Friendly staff and super quick delevery! Don't miss out on the garlic Knotts!
This might not be a typical scenario for most pizza customers, but we needed a special order, to feed 40 people, on 24 hour notice.
The owner and staff did an amazing job of preparing and packaging the food for our special event! Whenever we are in Syracuse looking for good food, Nick's Pizza 🍕 wil
Delicious New York style pizza. Wish I had found this place sooner. Skip the chains and buy local and you won’t regret it.
Went here for the first time today. Me and my fiance went to just grab a slice because he has told me several times how delicious this place is, and it didn't disappoint! I had one slice of garlic and it was one of the best garlic slices I've ever had! I will definitely be back to grab more than jus
First time stopping in and couldn't be happier with our meal. The customer service was top notch, those dudes are working their tails off and the food is bomb. Perfect cheese ratio on the pizza. Onion rings were crispy and delicious. We'll definitely be back.
First time trying this pizza, I'm typically displeased with Syracuse pizza and coming from Brooklyn I have a high standard with pizza. However, I will say, this is my 2nd favorite in the Syracuse area. The cheese was perfect, the crust was almost perfect, very minor flaws that I only noticed literal
Stopped in at Nick's heading back to Ohio from a trip to Vermont....and I am sad that Nick's isn't closer to us....hands down the best pizza I have had in a long time!! Nick and his staff were super friendly and made lunch very enjoyable....the polls that vote Nick's the #1 pizza in Syracuse don't l
We were traveling from Illinois to Maine and we always stop overnight in E Syracuse. We wanted something that would fill up the family and was good. Tried Nick's Pizza and this place came through. The restaurant has the best thin crust pizza - the only downside is that they are so far from home - ot
Simple is best. This place is not gonna wow you with decor, but that's just fine with me with pizza that's very well made with a good balance of ingredients not to mention how fresh everything was. I treated myself to some of their char-grilled wings and I HIGHLY recommend them to wing enthusiast. G
Love this place. Very good pizza 🍕. Great staff..
Really solid pizza. They have a variety of refrigerator sides, and they always have slices available. The pizza is one of my favorites, and is always really tasty and with a variety of topping. The owners are great people and are happy to stay open a little later if you come in off the late shift.
We were driving from Toronto to Gore Mountain and nicks was amazing. Best calzone I ever had. It's right off the highway, we will stop everytime!
I was in Syracuse for a visit to the zoo. We stopped in at Nicks at 8:45 pm and the entire staff was so nice. They made us a fresh pizza & garlic knots even though they were getting ready to close. The food was FANTASTIC….I had read all the reviews and this is the reason we decided on Nicks! Highl
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes