The food was delicious and the service was great. The people that worked here were very polite and patient. Cesar salad had a little kick a bit too much pepper but none the less was a great. The pizza was piping hot and the dessert was very good. The cookie “pie” wasn’t overy sweet and the cheesecake calzone was delicious. If I’m ever back in town definelty will be back.
I mean who doesn't love Pizza? Lol. I like the different options they have here for toppings. I've only been here for lunch times but have a bar so I feel that they have a night life as well. Atmosphere here a casual. What you would expect for a pizza hangout spot to grab a quick bite to eat and sit and chat.
This has become my favorite pizza spot bc the flavor is just sooo good and I love this style of pizza. Ive tried a few other local places but they dont compare. I usually get pepperoni, but yesterday I decided to try their italian sausage and it had really good flavor, but it was kinda crunchy which I thought was odd. I’m in love with their garlic knots, but be careful, they put marinara dipping sauce in there and it spills sometimes and can get all over the place. I would really just suggest they work on consistency because usually my pizza is perfectly cooked and the knots are huge and the same size, but this last time it seemed like some of my pizza was burnt and the garlic knots were different sizes.
Also, the customer service is really good. The girl at the host stand the past couple times I went was so sweet, I wish I got her name so I could mention her directly, but I got my pizza Sunday (4/2) around 3:30.
Food and service is 5 star , ambience is 4 1/2 and music is about a three maybe even a two . Oh.
Pizza is great. Staff very welcoming. Builing could use some TLC, but if I were a college kid it'd be 5✨️
So delicious. I ordered from the app since I needed to pick up groceries from the Publix Greenwise up the block. Everything was ready on time and the employees were super sweet. The Cookies and Cream 🍪 dessert pie was so much better than I could have imagined. I am not sure how one created something so tasty. The dessert pie was so flavorful; littered with Oreo cookie magic…and some type of sauce that is surely the nectar of the gods. I also got a 10” half and half 🍕 pizza pie (pineapple and capicola//bell peppers and feta). I had a 30 minute drive home so the pictures don’t even do them justice. Honestly, it was just perfect. Thanks Gaines Street Pies, for the best meal I’ve had in months ❤️.
Despite the simplicity of its menu and the fact that you first order and pay at the register, then the food comes to you, I found Gaines Street Pies to be a great experience.
From the surprisingly interesting quick conversation with the cashier (FSU Student) to the great tasting pizza, everything was 5 Stars!
While in Tallahassee, and craving for good pizza....Gaines Street will be my place to go.
Pretty good pizza place. The place is decorated with a comic theme, and it's definitely an interesting place to eat for tourists or locals. The food is okay, but the experience makes up for it.
The staff was helpful and friendly. The food was amazing. Pizza had a nice crust , very flavorful. Wasn’t saturated with grease. We had a slice of pizza and both of their desserts which was awesome as well. Not too sweet just perfect. The family and I had a great memorable time here. Enjoyed the food. Highly recommend this place . If I ever come back to Tallahassee this would definitely be one of my go to places.
Great college town pizza! Close to the Convention Center too.
Great college pizza here. Pricing wasn't bad. We fed half a football team here and we didn't over crowd the location. Servers were great. The pizzas came quickly and we truly enjoyed ourselves.
Everytime I go here the food is always perfect. The staff are always so kind, even in the late night rush.
I recommend the Bruno Sammartino, it's my favorite, with one of the Ceasar salads on the side.
Loved this place! It was epic and the food was amazing. Pizza Rules!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes