TOP 10 BEST Restaurants in United States - Updated November 2024

GERGENATER

christopher leon

Lauren Hamilton

Northside Pies

Wheelchair Accessible

"I would still go for the Momo's across the street, but this is a solid choice for fancier pizza. I tried the Sherwood and the toppings, cheese, and..."

GardenCat

"Everything from this place is amazing: apps, salads, calzones, pizzas! And all with their unique, tasty spin - LOVE IT! I recommend the feta..."

Colleen McClure

"I finally got to this place and BOY was it worth it! For those who don't know, these guys are also the owners for Gaines Street Pies and Midtown..."

BayouGator

"Pizza was delicious, I tried the White Sword but with artichokes instead of pineapple (I don't like pineapple on pizza LOL), and our server was happy..."

Jbr09

"Good pizza, nice weekend drink specials, free slice with purchase of a drink on weekend eves. Love the garlic knots and cheese bread too! Nice..."

Vonk.casey

"Brought to you by the Gaines Street Pies guys, this is a very nice place. The pizzas are always fresh and have really great ingredients If you really..."

Tim Smith

"There are a couple of food items I could eat on a daily basis, and still never become bored or tired of them. One of those items is pizza, and when..."

Sweet Tea & Bourbon ~ Mike Bonfanti

"Been there twice now...pizza incredibly good. Better than Momo's and a bit quieter...at least you can talk to your dining partner! The pizza with..."

Lisa Smith

"Excellent service, affordable and the pizza was delicious. I have to say better than Momo's as far as the pizza. Will definitely going..."

Raylan Givens

"Bartender and manager, as well as servers, know what customer service means. What a fabulous addition to NE Tallahassee! Thank you for bringing us..."

Nanette Schimpf

"Tried out the new location tonight-and it's our new favorite of the 3! Unlike the other two it is a sit down restaurant and also has a full liquor..."

Kathryn Miles

"Excellent pizza and a very nice selection of beer. Some have mentioned price in their reviews. The price is very fair and commensurate with (and..."

Malcolm Mason (Auctioneer)

"Their cheese pizza is New York style and tastes great. They offer a gluten free option as well and it tastes wonderful. We received really good..."

HK

"Great Pizza and local craft beers, easy access from the..."

Timothy Rach

"A casual laid back place. I agree that it was a little pricey. A couple of the folks we were with had coupons so that helped a little I guess. No..."

Mandy Simmons

"One of the best pizza places in Tallahassee. In combination, they have one of the best beer selections in a pizza joint. Great staff. It is always..."

David Arendt

"Good! If you're looking for classic thin crust, but crispy, quality topped, New York style pizza, then go here. 4 stars because it was a bit..."

STAN Jones

"Meet there every 2 weeks with a business group & the meeting space they give us is workable but the food is reason enough to stop by. Excellent lunch..."

Richard Yood

"Best pizza in town! Love the metal Mike! I'm addicted! Great happy hour specials and service is..."

Kiana Parham

"Best Pizza in town. Great atmosphere and great service. Go see Victor and thank me..."

Alexander Falls

"Quick bite whole passing through, this place hit the spot with large pies that are easy to consume, a laid back atmosphere with quick service. Can't..."

Preethum Prithviraj

"Good lunch special (two slices, one topping, and a soda for $6), great pizza, and classic rock playing in the background; what more could you ask..."

Steven Rehrig

"The best garlic knots you'll ever have. Plus unique pizza topping..."

Jasmine James

"By far the best pizza pie I have ever had.I would highly recommend..."

Bruce Shelfer

"An okay pizza place with a full bar. Personally I think the pizza leans on the overly greasy side but is still..."

James Pollock

"Food is great, never a long wait. Great lunch specials and..."

Joseph Belton II

Parks Pizza Kitchen

"Just found this place and I am in love, my boyfriend says they have the best calzones in Tallahassee and I loved their pepperoni pizza. Highly..."

Syris Love

"You guys this place rocks my socks! I’m a pizza junkie (I have a 10 year old), but it’s hard to find unique options. This pizza place meets all..."

Qedrin Booth

"Our first time to have pizza at Parks Pizza was on May 1, 2019 and it was the best pizza we’ve had here in our 5 years. Be aware, even though the..."

J T

"Parks Pizza is tucked back right off Monroe but I’m glad I stumbled upon it. Pizza was great and the owner and employees were super friendly. There..."

Ethan Conrad

"This was by far the best pizza I have ever eaten in my 27+ years in various parts of Florida. If you love NY thin crust pizza, you will not be..."

Al A

"This place is wonderful! My boyfriend is lactose intolerant and they gladly split our pizza in half. I had the Vodka Pizza, and my boyfriend got the..."

Amanda Durmaz

"Good pizza. Friendly..."

Ernest Berman

"Update: we tried the goat cheese and artichoke pizza tonight (added mushrooms) and I just HAD to bump it to a 5. Just great today. Paired with a..."

Tyler Teagle

"One of the best pizza places we have ever been to. Food is fresh and delicious. Staff is super friendly and the place is just more than..."

Susanne Uhlig

"I just found this place and I’m pretty excited for it! They have a lot f standard pizzas but aren’t too fancy. I got the buffalo chicken and..."

Cory Windorff

"Great pizza! Pesto and goat cheese +++ is delicious and tasty salads too!!!. Parks pizza is hiding behind Fed Ex and a bagel shop across from Wild..."

Rue Collins

"The wait was worth it. I ordered two with extra cheese and there was really extra cheese on them and it was delicious NY style pizza like I grew up..."

Rita Clariot

"I love eating here. It's so homey, the vodka pie is delicious and all my kids love the pizza here. It's a great place to have some good, family owned..."

Dianna French

"This place is the bomb... Visited for my birthday and they made my night completely!! The food was made with passion and the hospitality was great!..."

Lori Ann Ford

"I've visited this restaurant about 5 times in the last 2 weeks just to grab a slice or two. I generally go out of my way to do so and have been very..."

K Ford

"The Best Pizza in Tallahassee hands down. Many favorites. Buffalo chicken, pesto goat chees, balsamic chicken. The atmosphere and decor are nice...."

Tom Park

"This place is absolutely wonderful! The staff are funny and kind and the pizza is cooked to perfection! I got the White Pesto pizza and the cheese..."

Joseph Camacho

Tour Of Italy Italian Kitchen

88/100 (1451 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Being from New York all my life and eating Italian food kind of 24/7 I know good food this is more like a Greek type of a setup because I tried a few..."

Jeffrey Rothman

"We’ve lived in Tallahassee for three years and have always heard good things about this restaurant and finally decided it was time to give it a try..."

Lizzie Danielson

"Delicious food, excellent service with a lot of attention, highly recommended! Make sure to reserve a table. We tried the burrata with garlic bread..."

Amrit V

"What a fantastic find for us in FLA. Being native New Jerseyans, we thought there was no way that we'd find Italian food that was any good in North..."

Tony Viscardi

"After hearing many, many rave reviews for years, I was so excited to finally make our way here. And really, it lived up to the hype. Our family..."

Halie Pullen

"Absolutely wonderful. A friend recommended to eat here and I'm so glad I did. I had the lunch menu and I couldn't finish. The bread was delicious..."

Bill B.

"Must do reservation’s, but definitely worth it. The service was great, the meal was great too. Had the veal parmigiana and recommend highly. Made..."

Mark Shoplak

"This is the best Italian restaurant in Tallahassee. I don't care if the other ones have fancy chefs, or Gucci appetizers. This one is CONSISTENTLY..."

Anthony Derck

"By far one of the best restaurants in North Florida forget just Tallahassee. Authentic Italian cuisine at remarkable prices. The customer service is..."

S Williams

"Great Italian cuisine! We had the honey-burbon salmon and the fettuccine alfredo. Both were fabulous. The place was full (Friday night) and we had..."

Dane Roaseau

"Bulgarian owner, mexican kitchen, waiters might as well be Polish, Thai and Swedish but the Italian food is good. If you are in fact Italian, don't..."

Seebzz

"Had a large Greek salad on this visit. Very good and plenty big and filling for lunch. Filicity, our server was a pleasure and charming. They are..."

00 Buck

"Absolutely lovely hospitality and mind blowing food. Everything is so fresh and the flavoring is on the dot. Had tried once years ago but so so happy..."

KV Manepalli

"We sat outside and it was very nice. We all enjoyed the food. The caprese salad was wonderful. As with all restaurants they were short staffed. Our..."

Betty Johnston

"Giving this place a 5 based solely on the taste of the food which was excellent. Service on the other hand could use improvement. The server seemed..."

Krista

"This place is my absolute favorite Italian restaurant. I always order online and take it home. I have been eating here for years and my order is..."

Cassie Pritchard

Blaze Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"Omg where do I begain.. This is by far the best fast and fresh pizza we've ever had. The crust was baked perfectly and ALL the toppings we super..."

The Real Kimberly Thomas

"Awesome. Just an awesome place to eat :) love the food, love the atmosphere... Just yum! Pro tip! The to go box is perfect for half a pizza..."

Terrance Taylor

"Came here on pi day (march 14th) to get $3.14 pizza. I ordered veggie pizza which is nice since all their bread is dairy free and I got vegan cheese...."

Patrick Cousineau

"Lovely, and peaceful as always. The music is mellow, staff check up on you often and are also very professional. I love the unlimited toppings. Today..."

Paris

"Best place to get a pizza for cheap! They even do vegan pizzas just for you. I went with my Beau the other day (he's vegan too) and one of the..."

Rhamira Joi

"I love the pizza. The food next table looks pretty good too lol place has a modern look, nice and..."

elle n

"Good pizza. Thin crust. You can make your pizza half and half so you can taste more than one creation. Great atmosphere. Lemonade kick..."

Denise Mckinney

"The staff is always friendly, and they expertly create your pizza using fresh and high quality ingredients. I've never gotten a greasy pie from..."

Grant Kincaid

"I love the concept, like Chipotle but pizza, great price clean dining area. We took home what we didn't eat and it's even better as we take it out of..."

Ret M.

"This is a definite go-to after studying. The wait is reasonable and the pizza is good—the best part is that it is also open..."

Anne Lam

"I had my first experience at a non-smoking pool/sports pub right down the street from my neighborhood last night. This place is super clean, classy..."

Audrey Copeland

"Very friendly . Friend and i go on a sunday afternoon. We only one there but was nice n clean . Lot to do there for fun . Pizza was fresh flat bread..."

ziggy pop

"I LOVE this venue. Came in one night had a live band wha! wha ! I was stoked to see the team working there everyone was nice and the food was swell...."

Kerry Hartley

"This place rocks. I really like coming here for pool and they have great food too. If you want to eat, don't forgot to check Groupon. They often have..."

Tucker Nebel

"My favorite lunch spot in Tallahassee. Great $5 lunches with quick & friendly service. Awesome activities in the evenings as..."

Jason McDowell

"$5 chicken philly w/ fries for lunch, monday pong, and aycd $10 on Wednesdays...Halftime is the..."

Robert James

"Amazing service and even better food! Nice diverse crowd and the bands/live music is..."

Tosha John

"Its a great place but is closed as of..."

Casey S

"BOOM BOOM WINGS!!! W/ ZUCCHINI FRIES!!! AND A GARNET AND..."

Artistic Soul29

Jason Crabb

Riccardo's Restaurant

88/100 (1024 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"We always have a wonderful experience when we go here! It quickly became our kids favorite place for pizza every Friday and the calzones are my..."

Kassandra Bell

"Went here for dinner on a Friday while in town for Fsu game weekend. Restaurant is small and quaint. The place was full right at opening. We got the..."

Nickolas Whidden

"The bread wasn't anything special but the garlic butter was good. Our meals were good but nothing super amazing that we would have again. Well, maybe..."

Tabitha Butler

"Food was excellent. So far the most satisfying food I have eaten. The staff was great and checked on us at appropriate intervals. Oh and the food was..."

Eric Pedzinski (ZiN)

"What a wonderful little spot. Great ambience and service, great prices and delicious food. My favorite dish so far is their pizza. The crust is soft,..."

Virginia Silva

"Great meal! Took my daughter here after the VT game because she hasn’t found good any good Italian yet in Tally. Seater quickly and ordered..."

Chris FL Tornado

"I had the penne with pesto and goat cheese and added sausage. The food was flavorful and came out fresh. The secret bread and garlic butter were top..."

Kelli Strother

"Riccardo's is a hot local Italian restaurant serving up a variety of traditional and modern dishes. Home of the famous "secret bread," we weren't..."

Bradley and Charles

"Great service. Food was delicious. Parking is inconvenient. Other businesses around were utilizing most of the spaces..."

Sue Corley

"Great food. Closest thing to a New York style pizza I've found in Tally. The place is busy for a good reason. My only complaint is that parking can..."

Kenny Marshall

"Absolutely amazing. The restaurant was nice and dark inside. Quiet. Winderdul place for a date night or night of company. Food was absolutely..."

Bree Mahree

"Love this Italian Restaurant, it's my favorite in Tallahassee. Very nice people, the menu has something for everyone, and they have a great beer and..."

Frankey May

Momo's Pizza

88/100 (1824 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"We needed a quick bite before heading out for the evening and tried Momo's Pizza. What a neat place! The vibe is modern kitchen with a hint of big..."

Colin Bosler

"I have made multiple visits to Momo's Pizza located at 1410 Market St STE C1, Tallahassee, FL 32312, and I must say that it was a fantastic..."

Joe Manausa

"I love Momo's Pizza! They have an amazing selection to choose from with a bunch of fun and delicious flavors. I ordered their Pesto Chicken Calzone..."

Jess Y

"I loved the salad.The portion sizes are large. The pizza was so good. We got a small pizza but it was quite large. We tried goat cheese, cheese..."

Betty Woodward

"Fantastic! We ate a "Mo Money, Mo Problems" I wich I had taken a picture. The flavors of salami, red onion, honey and goat cheese meld together for..."

Beth

"I loved this place. I've got to say, I think the buffalo stix were way better than the slices of pizza but everything was good. The staff was really..."

Dani Drugan

"Stopped by while in the area and did not disappoint. Would highly recommend if you're like me and enjoy to trying foods local to the area your..."

Sarah Anne

"This is my favorite pizza place in Tallahassee. I have great memories of coming here after a baseball game and getting a slice. Pizza is great, every..."

Matthew Schaper

"Best pizza ever! My first time going there and it was so worth it. Definitely recommend getting special slices if you wanna try something new. They..."

Caliegh Slagle

"Calzone was excellent, my wife had a slice, very good 👍. We think this place has the best pizza in Tallahassee. We will be back..."

RG

"I had my first experience at Momo's this week... I was BLOWN AWAY at the quality *and size* of their food. My friend and I ordered some goat cheese..."

Amy Brown

"Got the munchies? This place is an oasis in the middle of a college town that has super large slices of delicious pizza and ice cold beer! Love..."

Travel Eat

Bubba's Pizza

"Excellent pizza and great service tonight! We got the Veggie..."

Chuck McGillen

"Garlic knots are exceptional, lots of real, crushed, hot garlic! Pizza was really good as well. The crust was chewy and crispy, cheese was quality,..."

aaron stewart

"Pizza is great, especially the Bradley's sausage and onions. The garlic knots are not the best, neither are the wings- both were soggy. They also..."

Kim Knight

"We love this pizza place! Their white pizza is absolutely amazing. We have ordered from here many times and have always enjoyed it. Also, the guy..."

David C

"Born and raised in Tallahassee and hands down my favorite pizza joint. Definitely New York style pizza and better than some pizza we found in NY..."

billybobjoe bonecrusher

"My Husband and I dined in at Bubbas last night for dinner ONLY because we told our daughter we would go out for ice cream at Brusters and it was..."

Weeping Willlow

"Love this place! Tried the Philly Cheesesteak for the first time and it was AWESOME! Very tasty with the right amount of seasoning. The meat was..."

Linda Friedlander

"Great flavor! The lunch slices are super thin which is good and bad. The regular pizza looks amazing. Nice topping..."

Alain De La Paz

"This place is the BEST! Had no idea it was here! Their pizza sauce is really tomatoey and awesome. The key lime cheesecake was so good too! Will..."

Gabrielle Boissiere

"I have ordered pick up from Bubba's a couple of times, the first time out of curiosity. It's pretty delicious. The pizzas are huge. It's close to my..."

Alyse Hooten

"One the best places in town when craving a slice and the garlic knots are out this world. The egg roll styled cheese sticks are also a hit. Don’t..."

Joseph Miller

"Always the freshest salad. The personal pizza salad and drink for lunch is awesome and a great deal. Try it with anchovies, bacon and fresh sliced..."

dan george

"Good pizza.....had the SOB with pepperoni and garlic. Friendly staff and now I'm a regular. The price is right the taste is..."

Sean O'Mara

"Wonderful staff and delicious food!! Best garlic knots I've ever had!! The pizza is so..."

MC Sullivan

Midtown Pies

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"Highly original and delicious specialty pizzas. I personally recommend the Cherry Bomb, that damn thing blew my dumb cracker mind. My tongue had a..."

Kevin Cole

"Amazing gluten free pizza, which is so hard to find where I live! Love this..."

Cindy Ramos

"The absolute best Margarita pizza I have had since returning from Italy. Fabulous food fabulous..."

Carolyn Applegate

"Had a really long day but your eggplant and roasted fig pizza made it all better. And it was ready 20 minutes before the promised time. Great..."

Jonathan Johnson

"Quick service, great flavor and perfect..."

Javier Laureano

"Best pizza in a long time! Our Maggie Mae pizza had the perfect ratio of..."

Katharine Price

"Amazing pizza, beer and people! Ask for the "Julius" Cesar Salad..."

Connie Tessmer

"Along with their sister restaurants, this is consistently some of the best pizza in..."

Nick Cronk

"When God invented pizza, this is what He had in..."

Brien R. Sörne

"Midtown Pies is a great part of the manor at midtown. I have spent quite a few late nights there to keep the party going with amazing..."

Mike Goldstein

"Best pizza in town, as always!! Pricey but worth..."

Tom Jackson

"Delicious gluten free crust option! I got the Freaks & Greeks pizza - soooo..."

Jennifer Davenport Lowery

"Amazing experience! Super friendly staff, delicious food that came out quickly, and cool..."

Kristin Dross

"Excellent food! Great..."

Andrea Bass

"I'd give it 100 stars if I could. My dad and I called an order in and it included the cheesecake calzone. They called back and let us know they were..."

Mackenzie Peterson

"This was a nice place to try. Kid was in the mood for pizza. I wasn't. Fortunately, their pizzas can get so far away from traditional pies, it's..."

Ehrin S

"Great location next to Ology Brewing Co. With good pies and a small bar in the back. The pizzas were great but a little salty. Almost gave 4 stars..."

Miriam Rodriguez

"We were in town for the game and decided on pizza after. Everywhere was crazy and busy. I figured we would be waiting awhile for our pie but it was..."

van tran

"Tried this place with my family as they recently opened this location. We had three 10” pies as well as garlic knots. Everything was absolutely..."

Tierra Lee

"Easy phone order. No issues picking up. Great pie. Had the Bruno. Excellent chew on the crust. No..."

Matthew Mayo

"The staff was really friendly and quickly took our order. I had pizza for lunch so I tried a sandwich. The bread was toasted a bit too much for my..."

Mark Thomas

"Stopped by for some takeout. Parking was a little challenging but a simple pass around the block was enough to allow a spot to free up. I had ordered..."

Gregg Lantz

"Extremely kind folks working here! Visited multiple times and they’re a always helpful and have a smile on their face. Prices are ok - one day I..."

Katie Callis

"Originally this review was about a negative experience. It seems they had a crisis during an FSU game rush and it was bad timing for..."

Jordan Powell

"As I bit into this calzone, I was immediately hit with a sense of befuddlement - how could it be this good?! It had the most appealing cheese pull: ..."

Robinson Rodriguez

"My wife and I have been patrons of the Gaines Street location for about two years. The combination of Gaines Street Pies and Oyster City Brewing is..."

Steve Estes

"Fast pies with the advabilty of gluten free crust. A very good menu with many combos and sandwiches. Parking is nearby and 2 cash..."

Daniel Krick

"Delicious. Five adults. Two pizzas. Almost a whole pizza left over. It was huge. XL. Tasted oh so good. I will be ordering from them again. I am..."

Craig Benner

"Fantastic pizza, chewy but still crispy crust, a variety of sauces and some really interesting toppings. If you love good pizza but don't care for..."

Ashley Barber

"This is the latest store of the local chain. The pizza called the white album is particularly good. It's next door to a brewery. The next time, I..."

Gary Sokolow

"Thin crust, not as crispy as I usually like but still really good. The atmosphere is loose and small town. They are reducing their use of single use..."

bravokidroxy

"Love going here for the temptation pizza. Being vegan isn't always easy when eating out and the staff is always knowledgable and makes suggestions..."

Kam Green

"Pizza by the slice or a whole pizza, there is no wrong way to enjoy Gaines st pies! They have endless toppings and the staff always goes above and..."

christie c

Lotsa Stone Fired Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

"I love how friendly the workers are and the pizza is amazing! Definitely recommend trying it if you haven’t..."

Alexis G. Stewart

"Lotsa’s pizza is amazing. The best stone fired pizza in..."

Em Young

"The staff were very kind/welcoming and accommodating and quick. The location is great for either dining-in or take-out. I was able to order vegan..."

Kirsten Larsen

"We ordered 4 pizzas plus a garlic bread for lunch. Everyone enjoyed their pizza and we couldn't quite finish the garlic bread (it's big!). Pizza..."

Sean M

"I got the Bianca with mushrooms instead of tomatoes and good gosh it was good will be going there again also if you have a sweet tooth go for the..."

L. W.

"Mr. Joey was a super friendly and accommodating guy 🙂 food was fresh and fulfilling 😋👌🏾 restaurant was neat & clean! 5 stars..."

Kniles 340

"Tonight was my kids and I first time there. I was kind of hesitant because it's in a college area but the staff was so nice and the pizza was fast..."

R. Jenkins

"So I was walking back to my apartment and I was greeted by the enthusiastic Tallahassee Lotsa Pizza Crew. As I was half-way through building my..."

Adam Schoen

"So so so soooo good!! Visited on their re-open and created my own pizza for free. The staff, establishment, and pizza was so amazing that I’ve been..."

Ganay Thompson

"Wide selection of toppings, as well as a "Build Your Own" option. I ordered a cheese pizza with garlic, peppers, and ricotta. It was amazing! There..."

Henry Huot

"Nick and Dillard put in the best service out there. Pizza comes out just how you like it and they are a really friendly staff. Never had any..."

Arsh Husain

"Toppings sliced fresh and dough made in house. The team on site was upbeat, worked well together, and were naturally eager to please. The're still..."

Michael Miller

"I'm a sucker for a good upstart story - especially in the ultra-competitive pizza market. From the single/original location as "Lotsa Mozza" in..."

Daniel Pineau

"Dillard’s cooked my pizza really well. I enjoyed my time with him and everyone there. He made my experience tonight a great..."

John Colletti

"Hello this is a rating on Dillard’s he has excellent customer service and because of him I look forward on coming back again! He made lotsa worth..."

BrittanyH123 H

"Veronica who works there made the experience at Lotsas amazing, I’ve never experienced better customer service in my life. Also the pizza there is..."

Fiord Toribio

Brickyard Pizzeria

Wheelchair Accessible

"We returned one cold rainy night and everything was just right. Though our first experience wasn't the best, I do give them a four. Just goes to..."

Mark Proulx

"The best pizza in Tallahassee! I love this place, eat it ALL the time. They have other good food too. The ziti is good and the spaghetti is also..."

Lynn Pruett

"Favorite!. I don't know how anyone could not like this place. I drive from midtown to go here. We always get it to go. I love their sauce on..."

Lep03

"Great pizza!! I've been looking for authentic New York pizza, this is it!! Sausage is ground down really fine just like back home. Love this place,..."

Dines Alot

"Excellent customer service, thank you Christine! Meatball pizza and Syracusa pizza were delicious, perfect stop on our way through..."

Traveler12

"Great..."

TallyTrish

"Wonderful!. I love this pizza....Best in Tallahassee. I am from New England and have been searching for a comparable pie for the last 12 years. I am..."

Themightylore

"Love Their Pizza. This place has a really nice atmosphere and the pizza was delicious. I recommend the Pizza Siracusa & Garlic Knots...but I doubt..."

Morganabigail

"Good and Fun. Friends and I meet there each month, and we all go with others in between. They consistently serve good food and the staff are the..."

Dorothy

"Great thin-crust Pizza. If you're from Long Island, you'll feel right at home. The ingredients are first class, the service is attentive and the..."

Dutch Oven Guy

"Went to the Brickyard on Urbanspoon recommendation and was not disappointed!..."

Anton

"Classic NY pizza best in town. They use Roma as there supplier, which is always a great start. I have never had bad food here. Good pizza , Good..."

Tim Smith

"Very good pizza, great crust, fresh veggies and toppings. They also have great garlic rolls. Definitely one of the top 3 in..."

K.D.

"This afternoon Becks and I made the short drive from my office to the Brickyard Pizzeria for lunch. The Brickyard Pizzeria is located on Kerry..."

Sweet Tea & Bourbon ~ Mike Bonfanti

"The pizza is now only take out it seems. They use to have a few tables but it doesn’t seem since COVID they have opened that up, I don’t think..."

Annette Wilson

"The people there are so kind and hard working. They made my meal with great quality and I love the lunch two slice deal. Every time I come it brings..."

Connor Allen

"Ordered the homemade Parmesan butter, little bland this time but still a good choice. Also, ordered antipasto salad. Amazing portions and always..."

Kasey Nicol

"Excellent marinara sauce. Great pasta dishes for half of what you pay for less flavorful stuff..."

joe Young

"Update: if been coming here for a couple of years now and I still love this place. It's definitely the best Italian in..."

Steven Soltis

"Great restaurant. Food was excellent and staff was friendly. And you can't beat their $6 lunch specials that include a..."

Matthew Shapiro

"Friendly staff and great food. The rolls were so soft and yummy. I ordered the eggplant rollatini and was very..."

Kat Medrano

"As a northern transplant (job transfer), I'm here to tell you, fellow transplants, that this may be the best you're going to get in Tallahassee...."

Kate Passeggiati

"This place is great the food is super tasty and the service is friendly and fast. Brian is a great server very witty and has quick..."

Anthony Montalvo

"We did a bunch of platters for my nephew's graduation this weekend, they were delicious. We especially loved the spinach lasagna and the pizza. So..."

Cindy Tanenbaum

"Great pizza and other Italian dinner options! Meatballs are amazing, and so is the buffalo chicken grinder sandwich if looking for something..."

Alison S

"I love the food here. The eggplant rolatini is amazing. The customer service has been great every visit. I hope they go back to in house dining soon..."

Joel Hagans

Milano Pizzeria

87/100 (1098 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"We enjoy this little neighborhood pizza joint. Good food and friendly service in a comfortable environment. They have a great room for large parties...."

Marian L

"Delicious pizza! Stopped here after getting back into town to give it a try and I was not let..."

MO

"This is a good neighborhood pizzeria. The dining room is nothing fancy but it is comfortable, the food is very good, prices are average, and the..."

Pat Imar

"COVID-19 restrictions in Tallahassee severely limit dining options Sunday evenings, and we had almost given up hope finding a good place to eat. We..."

Steve R.

"Very delicious food! Their service was quick and wonderful, and the prices are fair. They check on you often, and are happy to accommodate additions..."

Lauren Collins

"The food is always good. The dinner rolls are good when fresh and hot, however they dont save well so getting any to go is a waste. Portions are..."

M T

"So, this was my first time ordering. The online ordering process was very easy and user friendly. I ordered spaghetti with meat sauce and sausage and..."

Don F

"Locally owned, lovely small, quiet spot with delicious Chicken Marsala, Eggplant Florentine, fresh, warm, homemade rolls and good wine. Perfect..."

Lesley Conrad

"Omg!!! Hubby and I just had Milanos for the 1st time. It will definitely not be our last time. The Chicken Diablo and Eggplant Florentine were..."

Saralynn Redding

"You delivered pizza to my home a couple of weeks ago. The customer service was friendly and efficient. The pizza and garlic rolls tasted amazing! ..."

Hilary Parsons

"This is a little place you might just fly be if you're not looking as it is close to a closed mall, but it's a little gem. Not upscale all. Very easy..."

Chip Chalmers

"Best pizza I've had in a long time. We are from out of town and picked this spot on a whim. I am not disappointed. Crust is crispy on the outside,..."

Maxwell Perry

"Finally, a pizza place that knows what their doing. The food is excellent, the servers are helpful, and humorous. If you want your pizza cooked well..."

Jacob Reece

Blaze Pizza

"Decided to get some pizza after a two hour doctor visit and it tasted amazing thankfully. Cooked within 5 minutes. I had the build your own pizza w/..."

Cristiana Holland

"The service was amazing. They helped guide us to get the best tasting pizza in town. You can build your own or choose signature pizzas. If you are..."

Rene Alvarenga

"This place made me a wonderful pizza and the staff is great . The cleanliness of this business is Top-of-the-line… great..."

Michael Vaughn

"During July, Blaze had a month long deal going on Hawaiian small pizza for $8.99. That is my fav pizza, so I got it twice. First time was delicious...."

Dr Marilyn Naito

"Yummy fresh made pizzas in no time. Got 2 for the four of us and everyone got what they liked. Good..."

Dave Thornton

"Stopped in for a quick bite. We ordered two side salads and half a pizza. It was amazing in so many ways. The ingredients were fresh and there..."

Greg V

"“The subway of pizza!” - my Swiss friends who absolutely loved it haha they do a great job at Blaze. If you like the ability to customize things..."

Jay Finlayson

"It is a great pizza place. You can choose toppings from their variety of options and added to your personal pizza. Flavor was great, the cheese bread..."

Eve Lebron

"We stopped here while using the electric vehicle charger nearby. Dan, the general manager was incredibly friendly and accommodating and brought water..."

Josh Cleland

"The pizza tasted delicious and the customer service was excellent. The restaurant was clean and welcoming. There were a variety of fresh toppings..."

Hilary Parsons

"Very nice staff and excellent pizza. General manager Dan is on top of it and made us feel very welcome! This is a great stop if you are utilizing the..."

Katrina Rice

"The pizza was soooo good! The staff was very friendly and the ingredients were fresh. I highly..."

Doug Edwards

"I don’t typically write about chains but this location in particular is wonderful. The food is good and the people complete the experience...."

Rob T

"Went to the Grand Opening event today and I have to say this Blaze looks amazing!!!! Customer service at this location even when super busy was the..."

Brian Burke

"Was impressed by their oven and the quality of the crust, but not by their red..."

April Boutin

"Wonderful eating experience. From the friendly staff to the delicious pie and unique drink blends, Blaze Pizza is on..."

James Clemens

"The best employees ever..."

Jacob Kenton

Blaze Pizza

84/100 (1780 ratings)

Build Your Own Pizza Large

Salad

Blaze Pizza Build Your Own

Build-Your-Own Pizza

Classic Sauce

Green Stripe Pizza

Gluten Free No Cheese Pizza

Chicken Pizza with Pesto Sauce

Drink Nitro Lid

Pie

Flatbread

Blaze Pizza Half Classic Cheese Pizza and Half Pepperoni

Wheelchair Accessible

"Blaze Pizza exceeded my expectations! Their customizable pizzas were delicious and cooked to perfection. The variety of fresh toppings and quick..."

Daniel H

"They have lots of vegetarian options. Build your own pizza is a great way to explore different combinations. I ordered 11 inch veg pizza with 3..."

Nabiha nasir

"This was a great experience as this was our first time! Everything we ordered was well worth the $35 we spent on 2 pies, 1 salad, & 4 drinks. We..."

The BBCO Show

"I was absolutely ecstatic to find out that Blaze had vegan options here. I had the pleasure of trying out the half pizza with the cheesy bread combo..."

Joan

"Tasty personal pizza! I love their options to order different style pizza with lots of sauces, toppings, doughs, cheeses, meats, veggies and..."

B K

"They were able to handle our office lunch order with ease. Dan was super helpful. The gf vegan crust is..."

Hartmann Lynn

"Stopped by Blaze for the second time today - and it was absolutely delicious! I got the cauliflower crust my first time, and I wasn't a fan at all...."

Kate F

"I came over here because I was denied service approximately 45 minutes before close at rock and roll sushi and DAMN am I glad I did. I ordered rather..."

Justin

"Filled that cheesy bread craving!! Thank you!! This place has vegan and vegetarian options too! Parking is a very large parking lot you’ll never..."

Ray G

"The employees were friendly and they made my pizza perfectly. Lots of spicy sauce, plenty of cheese, and a boat load of veggies. They Bahr it to a..."

BAWANA PERRY

Five Star Pizza

84/100 (1306 ratings)

"5 star pizza is one of our go-to pizza spots for pick up. Our preference is for their thin crust pizza, but the regular crust is good, too. We prefer..."

Karleisa Rogacheski

"First time ordering here and absolutely will be returning. We live 30 minutes south of 5 Star Pizza and have lived and worked in Tallahassee for..."

Steve Barron

"We stayed in Tallahassee for three nights. On the last night, we just wanted to stay in snd order a pizza. We had seen pizza boxes from Five Star..."

Juvenal Vique

"We tried the cheese and chicken pizza. They are a little more expensive, 2 large pizzas cost us $35. I enjoyed both the pizzas, they were good, tasty..."

Ibrahim

"Only place in town that I order delivery instead of pickup. The "Everything" pizza is delicious and has a lot of toppings. The pizza from here is..."

Kayla Robinson

"My husband and I had some friends over and decided to order pizza rather than cooking. This was our first time ordering from these people. Often..."

Deanna Dickerson

"The quality is on point, holds up so well even when delivered. I could eat it cold - they're that good. Do yourself a flavor and eat some today. My..."

Michael “Reaganomics Lamborghini” Jordan

"The pizza here's great!! Got a small pepperoni and cheese for my daughter and chicken poppers for me. Everything tasted fresh except the sauce but..."

The Real Kimberly Thomas

"This place really is a 5 star pizza 😳 wishing we had one back in Waco,TX right now 😩💜..."

Christina Metcalf

"Jim did a great job making my Chicken Pizza hot fresh crunchy bottom juicy chicken and cheesy on top. He was patient and helped Me with options and..."

Amanda Tran

"Five Star is my favorite pizza. I get a meat lover speciality ever week. My grandson and room mate survives on Five Star. I think you should reward..."

Clarice Woodard

"Easy to work with on the phone, pizza time quoted 10-15 min at prime time on a Friday, I think they had it done before that, efficient and lean..."

michael jordan

"My first time ordering was today from there.......let me just say this they are the 💣..... okurrrrrrrr.....💅the food was delivered hot,hmmm I..."

Tylar Caldwell

"Great customer service; ease of online ordering. Friendly and competent staff. Their pizza is our..."

S F

"Second time have ever had 5 Star Pizza. And for the side of town I located, very impressive. Pizza, wings and rolls still hot and delicious. Thank..."

Thomas

"This pizza took me back to my childhood so I had a nostalgic moment when taking the first bite! It reminded me of how Chuck E. Cheese pizza use to..."

A W

"The owner and staff are extremely friendly, the pizza was awesome! I ordered from them for a work event at a bank where we fed several employees and..."

Brooke Coulliette

Decent Pizza

84/100 (1176 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Free off-street parking

"We went to Decent Pizza on Saturday night and it was delicious!! We tried the Veg head pizza and the Buffalo chicken pizza. It was sooo good! The..."

Kelly Gibbs

"Hands down the best pizza in Tallahassee! It was tantalizingly delicious in a way that tickled my taste buds and sent them into a frenzy of joy. I..."

Kyle Krueger

"Got there when the doors opened on 12/9/2023. Pizza was good/fresh. The cook (female with black hair) really needs spoken to. I didn't have an issue..."

Charles Propes

"I've ordered from decent pizza before as takeout. I love this pizza. Family came from Orlando to visit in route to their destination. Dinner was..."

Kevin Edwards

"I recently had the pleasure of dining at "Decent Pizza" in Tallahassee, Florida, and it's safe to say that this place stands out in the realm of..."

Gary Hodes

"In the past (five years or so ago) we went often because we lived more in the middle of town. In recent years, I have not gone, but mostly because it..."

Claire Smith

"Decent Pizza is one of the best pizza places in town run by an extremely awesome person. Jacob is passionate about his customers and delivering a..."

Logan Gray

"For no particular reason I haven't been to Decent Pizza in many years. Decided to give it a try today and it was phenomenal. The only complaint I..."

Wes Smith

"Great food! Great staff. Ordered 3 pizzas to go. Done in 20-25 minutes. Pizza was delicious. Crust was perfect. Will be back..."

Eric Rivera

"Our family visited recently during the FSU Homecoming weekend. We were so glad to see that Decent is still going strong after all these years! We..."

Alpha Nurse

"So delicious and the price is very reasonable. The parmesan bread knots were scrumptious, too. One of my favorite pizza places in..."

Kate W

"If you like New York Style pizza, you are going to ♡ Decent Pizza. Hand tossed Pizza, made fresh. Fresh produce, fresh local sausage, REAL Cheese!..."

MICHELLE RODRIGUEZ

"My family of four and I LOVE Decent Pizza! We enjoy their pizza, its as close to New York style as it gets down here in the south. They also have the..."

Amber Kilgore

"Cool atmosphere and the pizza was fantastic. Crispy crust with great flavors. Also tried the spinach salad with balsamic vinaigrette. Overall it was..."

David Martin

"We cone to Tallahassee once a year to do the local arts and crafts festival...Tallahassee Market Days and we always make it a point to eat here...the..."

Joyce Jones

Jimmy John's

Wheelchair Accessible

Lunch

"We stopped in for a sandwich at 9:00 pm, after driving 13 hours from Texas. Although they closed in an hour, the staff greeted us with smiles. The..."

Lisa Thompson

"These guys know how to handle a rush. I was so confused and thought I had placed my order on the Pensacola street location that is under remodel. I..."

Tiffany Bailey

"Great food! Great service!! Great prices!! Just plain GREAT!! I take mine to go but they also have a great place to eat if you want to sit down..."

Rebekah Harris

"The fellas at Jimmy Johns on Pensacola St. allowed me to have a wonderful experience while serving me from start to finish. Dalton was my cashier, he..."

Brii K

"The staff is always super friendly. They always have my tailgate order ready and correct. They are also very fast we when have a walk in..."

Mary Sims

"These guys are always kind, awesome,and of course FrEAKy FAST!! Been ordering for sometime and never had any issues! Good fresh subs made how i like..."

Cynthia Harrell

"Never had a problem here; the drivers are VERY fast, and the food is always accurate and..."

Megan Boebinger

"They're always on time with speedy delivery. Staff is courteous and always gets the order correct! No complaints here...."

sarah campbell

"I live right by here and i order sandwiches online and they are always delivered within 10 minutes. FREAKY..."

Ryker Register

"Great place! Can't beat for the price of the delivery time. Seriously love how fast they..."

Jose Hernandez

"Wow ... This is the first time I ordered a delivery. The guy was here in 15 mins. Freaky fast for..."

shams ajmeri

"I always get my sandwich quickly and the drivers are very polite five stars..."

Hamdi Barakat

Gaines Street Pies

83/100 (1245 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"The food was delicious and the service was great. The people that worked here were very polite and patient. Cesar salad had a little kick a bit too..."

Sarah Gonzalez

"I mean who doesn't love Pizza? Lol. I like the different options they have here for toppings. I've only been here for lunch times but have a bar so I..."

Tillis Ward

"This has become my favorite pizza spot bc the flavor is just sooo good and I love this style of pizza. Ive tried a few other local places but they..."

Elizabeth Sala

"Food and service is 5 star , ambience is 4 1/2 and music is about a three maybe even a two ...."

Blaine Philipson

"Pizza is great. Staff very welcoming. Builing could use some TLC, but if I were a college kid it'd be..."

Micah G

"So delicious. I ordered from the app since I needed to pick up groceries from the Publix Greenwise up the block. Everything was ready on time and the..."

The Woke Unicorn

"Despite the simplicity of its menu and the fact that you first order and pay at the register, then the food comes to you, I found Gaines Street Pies..."

BlueShoes Adventures

"Pretty good pizza place. The place is decorated with a comic theme, and it's definitely an interesting place to eat for tourists or locals. The food..."

Brandon Evans

"The staff was helpful and friendly. The food was amazing. Pizza had a nice crust , very flavorful. Wasn’t saturated with grease. We had a slice of..."

Manuel Gonzalez

"Great college town pizza! Close to the Convention Center..."

Adrian Dillon

"Great college pizza here. Pricing wasn't bad. We fed half a football team here and we didn't over crowd the location. Servers were great. The pizzas..."

Nigel Eldridge

"Everytime I go here the food is always perfect. The staff are always so kind, even in the late night rush. I recommend the Bruno Sammartino, it's my..."

Michael Maloy

"Loved this place! It was epic and the food was amazing. Pizza..."

Chad Randall

Brooklyn Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"I had a wonderful experience here! Not only was the cheese pizza delectable, the service was top notch. This will definitely become our family’s..."

Ariel Contento

"I’m from Ny born and raised and I always liked my pizza extra cheesy and saucy I ordered extra on both! However I did not receive! This is what I..."

Dom Donna

"Awesome place! Always knew it was in town but never considered it. Finally tried it out a few weeks ago and it's great! I've been back 5 times! They..."

Brittany Gordon

"The cheese and pepperoni pizzas were amzinggg with some ranch, perfection!!! The service was great and the employees had a great attitude. 10/10..."

Olivia Fatta

"Always 5 stars from the delicious food to the excellent service! I love..."

Robyn

"This place was delish!! The pizza dough was fresh, the 🥗 was also good, as the breadsticks and calzone. Huge helpings! Definitely worth..."

Mary Ann J

"Brooklyn Pizza is a must try!! The NY style pizza is unbeatable and has the perfect amount of sauce and cheese! Their service was a 10/10. We dined..."

Aubrey Steinorth

"I'm a New Yorker that's spent the last 15 years in South Florida. I've had pizza in South Florida that comes close but just misses being NY pizza...."

Dan Tria

"Amazing place and amazing owner !! Been waiting for a place like this! Y’all gotta get some of..."

LennyLaGoose

"Love this place! It’s now my main pizza spot after discovering it not too long ago. Customer service is amazing and the food is even..."

Armani

"Omg, I am in love. I've had pizza all over Tallahassee, but hands down. The best!! We ordered, pizza, a calzone, meatball sub, and the pepperoni..."

Whitney Bailey

"Was skeptical to try bc I am from Brooklyn and know how good pizza tastes. They did not disappoint. This was vey authentic, taste original just how I..."

Tina Charles

Mike's Stone Baked Pizza

"My office is down the street and we frequent Mike's due to proximity but we moved further and I still prefer going to miles. Great pie's and..."

Mario Solari

"Mikes had awesome wings and pizza! Will be going there again over any other pizza place. Will recommend this place to..."

Joseph Anglim

Mellow Mushroom

83/100 (1105 ratings)

"My family and I always love coming to this location. The staff is so friendly and helpful every time, and the food is delicious! I live all the art,..."

Kate F

"Clean, friendly, and fun. They made our visit special, including making the kids an enormous pretzel. They had vegan options so we were able to..."

julie vanexan

"Great for healthy food choices it just for pizza and beer. A large craft beer selection on tap and bottle not to mention the full bar availability..."

Andrew Johns

"Good service, they were very friendly. Great food! Fun..."

Jonathan Welsh

"Always takes awhile to get your food but it's well worth the wait, calzone was amazing today! And waitress was extremely nice and attentive. Always a..."

jerahme ryan

"Very good food choices. My favorite app is the bruschetta. The music fits very well with the beautiful wall..."

Mary Montague

"Love our before game spot.. Had pizza this time and it was amazing.. Our daughter got a cookie Sunday to celebrate an early..."

Gizelle Beverland

"The food was very refreshing, my waitress was very polite and checked on me often. I will definitely return for..."

Shirrea Hinson

"This place is excellent the calzone is outrageous and the servers are all..."

Arnel Enger

"Great piazza and very good salads. Fun bar and funky..."

Greg Verhagen

"Love this place! The weekly lunch specials are definitely worth it, as well as the specialty hand-tossed pizzas. Bingo and Trivia nights are my..."

callie herold

"Absolutely impeccable service. Great people, awesome atmosphere. Excellent, top notch toppings. Delicious vegan cheese. Beautiful beer selection...."

RL ØSYS

"Had an amazing vegan pizza with artichokes and mushrooms that was delicious and huge in size. Staff was accommodating and informative. They also were..."

Kirsten Larsen

"Just like all other Mellow Mushrooms, the pizza here is delicious! Large portions for decent prices. Great appetizers and beer selection. Awesome..."

Deidre Garner

"I am a fan of Mellow Mushroom. What a fun loving up beat place to go. Mellow it is but there staff is lovely. I had the pleasure of trying some..."

Kerry Hartley

"From out if town but not disappointed at all in comparison to my own local Mellow Mushroom in central FL. Food & service were excellent. Was with a..."

Fran Darms

Red Elephant Pizza & Grill

"We really enjoyed our overall experience tonight at Red Elephant. The hostess sat us is less than 15 minutes on a busy Friday night. Our server was..."

Savannah

"Some of the wait staff was late, so it took a little time to get our orders going, but everything was very quick after the staff showed up. The..."

Jay Finlayson

"I went today. Our waitress was so friendly! Our food was nice and warm and we enjoyed the atmosphere. My only note would be the menus felt dirty and..."

Ainsley Whittington

"The food and service are great every time we go with very reasonable prices. I understand that when it's near closing time employees are ready to get..."

Jonathon Gandy

"Highly recommend! John, the owner was such a pleasure to work with. My first interaction with him was filling a pizza order for 168 sorority girls...."

Anna Garrish

"Solid 4 on the review. Take out is generally good, but they will skimp out on some of the dishes from time to time. We ordered a sandwich last week..."

Tony Conticello

"Amazing food. Service is always top notch. Never had a bad meal. Very..."

Chris Mcrae

"So delicious! High-quality pizza and quick, kind service. Fell in love with their 1001 chocolate tower cake. Would definitely go again and highly..."

Ethereal Muse

"One of my favorite black and blue cheese burgers is served here. This time I opted for the beautiful salad and it was perfect. They frown on licking..."

Abbe Justus Flynn Realtor

"I love Red Elephant, the atmosphere is great and the pasta Yaya is to die for. Drove through and had to stop in while we had the chance. The lunch..."

Jonathan Toohey

"I've been to Red Elephant many many times over the last 10 or so years, but I can't believe I've never written a Google review! It's definitely a..."

Halie Pullen

"We love Red Elephant pizza; it’s our go-to when ordering pizza to go. The online ordering process is easy, and pick up is fast. Highly..."

Rebekah Huggins

"Food was good and so was the service. We were seated right away and our food came out..."

Scott Suber

"Good reliable food. Service is ok depending on the..."

Matthew Schaper

"Foods good service is great and if you want a quick meal not a bad place to..."

Rob fig

"Waitress was very kind and courteous and helpful. Pizza was delicious, house salad was fresh. It was too cold inside the restaurant. Inside needs a..."

Myrtie Hucks

"Best Pizza joint in Tallahassee hands down. Ther food was spectacular, and the service was incredible. The staff were very friendly, and the service..."

Marvin K. Little

"Isaiah was the best customer service rep to provide my meal. If if wasn’t for him I would have left a bad review. He needs a Raise Or..."

Craig Mackey

"I happily pay a bit extra to come to this Papa John's because this particular Domino's next to it is total trash. I generally like the taste a bit..."

Lindsey Wilson

"Great service, was fast 👏 and they were busy! They also had a wonderful team! Cooks were on top of everything and were..."

Brandon

"Best chain and best papa John's in Tallahassee on this side of town. I'll say nothing is spectacular about service, but nothing negative either. I..."

Tana Reshea

"Papa John's yum!! Easily accessible and right off the parkway. Quick and painless takeout, ordered via phone, and ready as promised in just 15 min...."

Samantha H

"This restaurant is great. Preparing speed is so fast. I ordered customized pizza. And can be accepted coupon in the internet. So i got pizza cheaper..."

조정아

"Fast service and the young lady looked to be working solo, but efficient and friendly! Bon..."

Lala Arnold

"We get pizza here every Friday for work. And the midday guys are always super friendly and fast and the pizza is delicious! We ordered two pizzas,..."

Shay Lawson

"I must admit that was and is the best pizza I've had from papa John's in a long long time..."

Anthony Pierre

"Thank You so much for correcting the error I made on line! Top notch customer service!! Speedy delivery. Excellent Pizza. Very Friendly..."

Rodney Grindstaff

"Papa John's is usually pretty good. However, the last time that I ordered a bacon and mushroom pizza, it was SO SALTY. I couldn't even finish it...."

ItaliFirenz

Uncle Maddio's Pizza

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Mid-range

"The best pizza in town. Especially the gluten free..."

Shirly Bheer-Sukhram

"Just received my free gluten-free vegan pizza... Excellent crispy crust... Fresh ingredients... Friendly staff... Fast service!!! So HAPPPPPPPY..."

Cyndy Brantley

"Five star pizza and service. My new favorite pizza..."

Roxann Dressel

"Had the Big Max pizza, (all meat) it was really good and the staff was friendly and brought my order to me hot and fast..."

Hank Ford

"The food is great and so is the service. Very friendly. We had an honest mistake on our order on one occasion and they fixed it promptly and..."

Becky Orchard DeStefano

"Our food and service were spectacular. My son had the four cheese and we had the..."

Jennifer McCarthy

"I order my pizza with buffalo sauce instead of the usual pizza..."

Kevin James

"I love going there amazing pizza and great customer..."

Georgette Gray

"Best, freshest pizza place in town with the best..."

Kate McElreath

"I love Uncle Maddio's pizza. I bought my brother and mother for the first time for the free pizza. The customer service was GREAT, the pizza was..."

Lanedra Lowe

"Tonight was our first time at Maddio's and it won't be our last! Food was awesome and so was the..."

Keith KGee Griffin

"Pizza was Delicious Wonderful topping selection. Staff was friendly and helpful. Will definitely visit..."

Amanda Johnson

"Really good quality pizza! I used to visit Uncle Maddio's when I lived in Atlanta, and when I moved back to South Florida there wasn't any location!..."

Evan Westafer

"I haven't been the Uncle Maddio's in a while. The food was really hot and fresh! The flavor of the cheese bread was so good. I love the variety of..."

Amy Kay Furtys

"Very knowledgeable about celiac disease and cross contamination. They have their toppings in a separate area, switch gloves, and usually have the..."

Bernice Miller

"Best pizza crust, best toppings, and hands down the best customer service! Their chef inspired pizza is the best, pic one, it doesn’t matter, they..."

Judy Matthews

"We absolutely loved this pizza. The flavors were beyond expectations! We ordered the spicy ranch pizza and added steak and meatballs. Its a must try!..."

Mike and Amber Leftwich

"We stopped by there on a whim and had a delicious meal. Pizza was super fresh and tasted amazing. Service was on point and restaurant was clean...."

Sandra Wilson

"The service was great, they were patent in letting us figure out what we wanted as well as made suggestions. The baked wings were decent, the pizza..."

The Real Kimberly Thomas

"Great build your own pizza place. Gluten free crust and dedicated toppings makes eating with Celiac much easier. Very friendly staff made out lunch..."

Paul Stone

"Last week was my first time eating here. I will definitely be returning. Super friendly staff amazing..."

Price Carter

"I didn't have the opportunity to eat here but my car broke down and I had just bought groceries these people allowed me to put my food in there..."

Carol Taff

"I been driving by this place for months wonder was it good or not. So I asked my co workers what was the best pizza in Town and one said Uncle..."

stevie williams

"The wings where a little greasy but all in all great..."

Kristopher Thompson

"We're vegan, so we're always looking for really great, different pizza places that have vegan cheese options... this pizza was SUPER YUMMY AND..."

Heather Beaubrun

"The person who took my order was very helpful and..."

Lakendra Smith-Hall

"My daughter requested this for a birthday dinner and a movie. I wish we had one closer to us, we would eat here more often. She got the 4 cheese..."

Chuck Wray

"The pizza was some of the best I've had here in Tallahassee. The staff was friendly and welcoming and I like how they make the pizza right in front..."

Rebecca H.

"Great pizza. Wings were pretty good..."

Michael Harnish

Dave's Pizza Garage

82/100 (1113 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

Dinner

Lunch

Cheap Eats

"Best pizza in Florida! And yes, I'm bold enough to say this. Just the pizza itself is enough for a reason to come every time I have a craving for..."

Wyatt Arangilan

"A small, locally-owned business with friendly and fast service. I ordered the Valentine's Day special, a heart-shaped pizza with matching T-shirt,..."

Jbr09

"It's all in the sauce.. To be honest, I am not a pizza sauce lover. I will always order "light sauce" with my slice. This place, however, makes a..."

JennH

"Awesome pizza, friendly service and the brookie sundae is off the..."

Sharon Howell

"This pie is the real deal. I'm a thick crust guy and this pan pizza is my favorite in town. The owner is always in house and takes great pride in his..."

Jeremiah Crum

"Yes, please!. My experience with Dave's pizza pie is OMG. I love his crust and my everything had a perfectly distributed array of ingredients with a..."

Sherry Thompson

"Favorite pizza in Tally. Nice atmosphere. Cool decor. Friendly service. Great pizza!! And reasonably..."

Jjc12d

"Just left there for a late lunch and absolutely loved the place! The crust was perfect with a light buttery crunch and Dave was very nice and told us..."

Heather Rose Wells

"Solid. It's good pizza. Dave's crust is middle of the road, not pan and not NY-Style. If you like that kind of crust, you'll enjoy Dave's Pizza..."

William Kristoph

"Great pizza!!!. Dave's Pizza Garage puts out a mean pizza. I have been several times and I have not been disappointed yet. I also highly recomend the..."

Cmelton1970

"Big Time Great Pizza!. What a treat to discover Dave's Pizza Garage. I have sampled pizza all over town for over 30 years. Dave's pizza is the best I..."

Head Beagle

"Thank You!. Tallahassee has a ton of pizza places but Dave's really stands out. The ingredients may be simple, but its good quality pizza that tastes..."

Cheyayn Davidson

"Superb!!!!!. I only recently moved into the city and I recently ordered a large pizza from "pizza hut". UGH. It was a kid's size, greasy, barely any..."

Christiana

"Awesome food - best wings in town!. Cannot say enough good things about Dave's. Wings are the best, pizza is great, calzones are huge. Very..."

Alg04c

"The Better Slice. This little pizza shop is under new management and he even has a different kind of pie. The cornerstone to any pizza pie is the..."

Rggs

"Good Pizza, Great Meatballs. I had heard about Dave from a coworker when he was cooking pizzas out of his house. Now that he has a real restaurant I..."

Crr10f

"Pizza was great and a good value for what you get. Staff were super friendly. We will definitely be..."

Hotdog69

"The food is incredible and the staff is pleasant and friendly. The portions of pizza and calzone are generous, well made and addictingly good. This..."

Bonnie

"Last Friday, I grabbed a quick lunch at Dave’s Pizza Garage on North Monroe Street. I’m always searching for good pizza in Tallahassee, and..."

William Kristoph

"The Taste of Tuscany consisted of tomato sauce topped with spinach, red onions, sun dried tomatoes, chicken, minced garlic and basil. The Bleu..."

Sweet Tea & Bourbon ~ Mike Bonfanti

"Great cheese pizza and wings special. Pizza was crisp, not floppy. Good cheese to sauce balance. Wings cooked tender and had great sauce. Zero..."

JC Guppy

"We will definitely be back. The Not Your Mama’s Spaghetti Pizza is by far the BEST pizza we have ever..."

Aymee Weaver

"I was blown away by Dave's Pizza. It is truly the best pizza place in Tallahassee. I have traveled all over the United States and their pizza rivals..."

Michael (Mike)

"Has an awesome time with all my guys here. Everything was delicious as usual. The crew is always so friendly and explains the menu if need be. You..."

D May Ingram

"I wish I had taken pictures of our pizza. We ordered a large supremo and I asked for it well done. The idea being to get the pepperoni crispy..."

Brian Gentry

"Always amazing, best pizza in town! I’d say best anywhere, but I don’t get out of Tally enough to make that..."

Coop-Master-Flex

"The apple salad is really good...get it with the dressing if comes with. Everything was fresh and the tables were clean underneath. ( thank you staff..."

Natasha O'Neill

"Second time eating pizza from here while visiting my mom in Tallahassee. We love it! It has just a little heat we've never had in a pizza before...."

R B

"The food, the staff, the owner, the restaurant - to sum it up? Every meal I've had has been savory & flavorful, but not bogged down with too much..."

Kristin B

"Great experience and food was fresh and hot. Everytime we go everything we try is wonderful. Highly..."

Ruth Cole

"It had been years since we've visited Dave's Pizza Garage, but it was just as good as we remembered! My husband and I both ordered personal pizzas..."

Halie Pullen

"Ordered poutine, a personal honey jalapeño popper pizza pie, a four meat calzone, and the Buffalo chicken salad for my family. The cost was fair,..."

Tevis Page

"Of course it's Sunday so football was on but it was a great experience. The crust was like a cloud in my mouth. Very light but filling. Very good..."

Jennifer Musser

"I am from Buffalo, NY, and I approve of Dave's Buffalo Chicken wings! The best chicken wings, pizza, and beef on weck in Tallahassee. All around..."

Adam Friedman

"Excellent food! The cheese, the crust, the veggies and the sauce are all fresh and delicious. Bonus: the ranch dressing is homemade. A family..."

Lauren Brooks

"Pizzas were great! Thank goodness they were, because the restaurant was filthy and they had just opened! Recommend take out or bring your own wipes..."

Pamela Jackson

"Very good wings! The fries were a tad soggy, but to be fair I got the bacon cheese fries. Be prepared to spend a bit, but I do recommend you try..."

Kellie Muldoon

"I have loved Dave's from its original location. And will continue without a doubt anywhere they go. You walk in a customer, you come out..."

Barbara K

Momo's Pizza - Tennessee Street

82/100 (2095 ratings)

Wheelchair Accessible

"Great pizza. Fantastic value in terms or what you get for the price. Service is fast and the atmosphere is somewhere between a college town and a..."

Dennis J Giannetti

"Staying in Eastbank campground (Georgia) Out for a drive, decide on pizza. Google says Momo's has a 4.5 rating. Drive an hour for a pizza? You..."

Judy Garnett

"We are closer to the Market St location and have loved every moment. Every pizza or slice has been super delicious and although the atmosphere is a..."

Julie Mowbray Bell

"Our favorite place to get pizza in town! The large easily feeds a family of five (two teenage brothers included) and then some. My husband and I used..."

Delainey Harrelson

"My favorite pizza place. I would eat here everyday. Awesome music Awsome..."

Dale Mcdaniel

"Super delicious as always! Been coming to Momo’s since 1999! Quick and friendly service! Pies are always fresh and damn tasty! I saw the biggest..."

Nicole Sierra

"Love Momo’s! It’s alway a must go to place whenever we are in..."

Donnie Olmsted

"Traveled from Alabama & stopped in for some pizza & beer.......omg we've been back at least 3 times! Best pizza I've ever..."

Adrienne Daly

"Cashier was polite and quick on her feet. Pizza was awesome and came out pretty fast, especially for Saturday at dinner time. Our table was out of..."

Haley Ann

"Amazing food and service as always. It was so much fun to take my son to a place that has been my fav since..."

Krystal Shuler Hernandez

"Highly recommend!! So delicious and the employees are awesome and..."

Brittany Steedley

"Momo’s is the best, pizza is so good and fresh, employees are super nice too. Since I go to school nearby so I’ll be coming back..."

Gareth G

"We were in town visiting our son & his wife & wanted to get some pizza. They had recently found Momo's & took us there. The pizza was excellent! My..."

Sherri Lafever

"As a repeat diner at Momo's Pizza in Tallahassee it is always a delightful experience from start to finish. The aroma of freshly baked pizza welcomed..."

Gary Hodes

"This was a cool little pizza joint our daughter recommended when we went to visit her. It is located near the FSU campus and there was plenty of..."

Mark Wizda

"Overall they offer a nice large slice of pizza at a reasonable price. The ingredients in particular their ground beef was not as fresh OR has a..."

D M (Bigdtravels)

"You can never go wrong with Momo's pizza. If you're in Tallahassee, Momo's branches are unparalleled in quality and authenticity. In my time living..."

Max Banach

"Home of the mammoth (and delicious) slice. As a native NYer, I’m picky when it comes to pizza and this place delivers. Everything about the slice..."

Ben Stein

"Good pizza, hole in the wall looking..."

Phu Huynh

"The pizza was good. it didn't take that long for the pizza to come out. The waiter was funny, I didn't catch her name, but she had glasses and a..."

Briana Giaimo

"In Tallahassee for FSU homecoming and my husband and I just drove 7 hour so as always we order out first night. Well we were given list of..."

SoulGlow

"This hole in the wall grease spoon is amazing. The "slices of pizza are as big as yo face" and the lunch combo can't be beat. Delicious NY style thin..."

Christina Polovich

"Absolutely massive slices that might as well be a whole pizza in itself. Tried the Queso Chicken which was loaded with cheese but tasted..."

Ashwin Vivekanandan

"That perfect N.Y style crust that bubbles up and is thin, yet chewy and filling. Very cheesy and the slices are huge! Really. You could order just a..."

K'Cee Ortiz

"Service was very friendly and pizza was delicious. Went around lunch time on a Saturday and the place was busy. Great prices! One single slice was..."

Nathan K

"Not as good as north Tallahassee, but when you ask for extra *** they don't skimp. We asked for extra garlic and people have been running away from..."

Steve Collyer

Uncle Maddio's Pizza

82/100 (1510 ratings)

Steak and Blue Pizza with a Gluten Free Crust

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Buffalo Chicken Wings

Accepts American Express

Accepts Discover

Seating

Wheelchair Accessible

"Ordered from Here several times now , and the food has been consistently good, Especially liked the Mushroom Truffle pizza. Plus the staff here is..."

Tim Smith

"Favorite pizza place! I prefer thin crust pizza and Uncle Maddio's is my first choice. They use high quality ingredients and the product is..."

Excitedfoodie

"The Portobello Pesto pizza was awesome! We couldn't resist the cookies. The recipe could probably be tweaked a bit, but it was still a good cookie!..."

Jesshika

"We got a half and half with their pesto portobello and jamaican jerk pizza. My half was the jamaican jerk..and I have to say..it was awesome. Its..."

Chub-Li

"Buffalo. Pizza. No celery--- an awesome pie worth the $8 bucks. The blue steak is very good too. Been here several times and each experience has been..."

CMTally

"Chocolate. Chunk. Cookie.. The meatball panini is excellent. The pizzas are thin and are good based on description. The highlight of the meal,..."

JennH

"LOVE this place!. This is one of my favorite places to eat. The cost is a little high, but worth it! I typically get the gluten free crust (as..."

A.S.

"Like it!. Been there a dozen times or so. Great menu and tasty food. The convenient location helps,..."

Mikehtally

"Pretty good. I've been in a couple times during my work lunch. Haven't been disappointed so far. Great service. I love that they have a gluten free..."

YumConnoisseur

"Great Pizza!. Made my own pizza and loved it! The thin crust is wonderful. The staff were very friendly and helpful. Definitely will be..."

Sweetlady

"Good food, lead the way of pizza industry. I like the fact you make it there. I think this concept will explode. I also like the way you keep it kid..."

DerrickCrandall

"Fantastic! Smells terrific.. Very nice staff. The owner is present.. Very grateful that we went miles out of our way off i10 to get..."

Kathy Macri Diaz

"Not Bad. I took the kids to Uncle Maddio's for lunch before we went grocery shopping. The concept is interesting, the ordering/cooking process..."

Sweet Tea & Bourbon ~ Mike Bonfanti

"Excellent Pizza, Great Value. I've eaten at Maddio's four of five times now. What a pleasant surprise! I wasn't expecting much from a pizza joint..."

Ben K.

"Homemade, fast, fresh, freaking delicious. That sums up Uncle Maddio‘s for me. This new pizza “joint” is located on Mahan in the new Publix..."

Tasty Tallahassee

"A trip to the zoo meant grocery shopping got pushed back to Sunday. Before braving the supermarket’s aisles with two restless preschoolers I..."

Sweet Tea & Bourbon ~ Mike Bonfanti

"I had such a great experience here. This place was catered at my doctor's office and I just had to go back on my own! I got the steak and blue pizza..."

Ladybug Robinson

"Best pizza place in town. If u dont like the pizza its your own fault- u can build ur own with whatever ingredients you want, fresh ingredients. Puts..."

Dylan Dean

"The pizza is simply delicious and the staff super friendly! Highly..."

Sandra Wilson

"Never ever had a bad pizza from Uncle Maddio's! There are a few of their signature pizzas I love, but I also love that they can still be customized..."

Halie Pullen

"Joshua was great! He made my pizza very close to a classic thin-crispy crust cheesy new york style pizza. Will be going again. On top of that, he did..."

Troy Kalish

"Pizza was so delicious. Sweet tea was just the right amount of sweetness lol. Love how this place is set up with all toppings in front of you so you..."

Tonya Sanchez

"I love this place. Everything is made to order. A lot of drink options, including alcoholic. Cheesecakes, cannoli, and cookies available for..."

Shannon Turnage

"Got a calazone and cookie. Zero regrets. Food was great. Will be back again. Staff was friendly. Place was..."

JC Guppy

"Crust was a little to greasy for my liking, but I'm a pretty hard critic when it comes to pizza. Ordered the Margareta pizza was just okay. Hard..."

Mike R

Liliana Ugarriza

"Great pizza. Overall solid. Good flavors and toppings. Fresh ingredients. We'll go..."

Dan Mosman

"My lovely wife and I had undeniably delicious buffalo chicken pizza, Sante Fe chicken salad and lovely pints of ice cold and refreshing Proof IPAs..."

Mel Chang

"Hannah was very nice on the phone and when I came in to pick up my order there was a mistake with the pizza size. She didn’t tell me I was wrong,..."

Khalil

"Great place to eat lunch or bring your family. Reasonable prices, great customer service, fun family friendly atmosphere. The food is delicious and..."

Cindy Anderson

"Spent at least 30 min setting up an online order for my family and the whole thing crashed….argh!!!!! Decided to call in the order out of mere..."

Reset

There are 60 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Tallahassee

Ranking

Sort A-Z

near you

Filters

Greg Verhagen

Mickey Ellard

Lisa Riley

gordon devoss

Elliott Grace

TommyKilleen

Jen Keegan

Laurel Mathis

Samantha Spore

Courtney Skidmore

Bryan Rexford

Jessica Grace

Dave Almquist

Alan S

Lucille Spann

Austin Fletcher

Thomas Thomas

Sharon Perkins

Brent Maxwell

Randy

gaudys molina

Lissa Aquino

Linz H.

bobby d

Brooke Nosovitsky

Edward W. Hood

Stephen Cumbest

Dave Almquist

Tressa Smiley

Dana Sweat

Brian Roberts

Maipeng Wei Wei

Senior

Gb Hernandez

Cigney Smith

Nelson Ocampo

Daniel Pineau

Alexander McKelvy

Jr Curtis

Michael Jones

Tasha Conner

Jabari Grayson

D'Anterio Johnson

Christy, RDH

Sly14kt Copyrighted and Trademark

Kenny jay

Angelica Baeza

Dashweil Ervin

GERGENATER

christopher leon

Lauren Hamilton

GardenCat

Colleen McClure

BayouGator

Jbr09

Vonk.casey

Tim Smith

Sweet Tea & Bourbon ~ Mike Bonfanti

Lisa Smith

Raylan Givens

Nanette Schimpf

Kathryn Miles

Malcolm Mason (Auctioneer)

HK

Timothy Rach

Mandy Simmons

David Arendt

STAN Jones