Review Valentino's New York Style Pizza & Restaurant - Titusville

Been going here since I was a kid. Great quality and great people. Brings back childhood memories that I now get to share with my daughter. We got the large Greek salad and large white pizza 🍕 🥗 😋

So far,we've been here twice,ordered take-out both times. We ordered the Sicilian Valentino Special pizza. Both times,our pizza's were excellent,and done to perfection. Even though we did take-out,while there,the family atmosphere was very evident,and we will be going with family soon,to enjoy a,so far,consistently made meal,with a smile. I would like to thank the young man behind the counter,for his pizza making abilities,along with a great sauce,and plenty of ingredients on the pies. The family does a great job all the way around,and can't thank you enough for offering a great service,meal,and atmosphere for us to enjoy.

Literally so amazing! From the wonderful smells, decent prices and absolutely delicious pizza and garlic knots. I’m obsessed. If you’re having trouble deciding on what to eat this is the place to be (especially for the pregnant mamas out there) amazing isn’t even close to describing this place. 10/10!!!

One of the best places to eat on the Space Coast. I've been coming here since I was a kid as it was one of my late grandfather's favorite places. Glad to see it is still open and the Sicilian is just as good as it was 30 years ago.

My family and I are big fans of Valentino’s. I regularly get the Baked Ziti and my husband asked for the kid’s potion this past visit as he was ordering the minestrone soup as well. While the food always tastes great, I will mention that with the new price increases, portions seem to have gone down in size a bit. It definitely won’t stop us from coming back. Best Italian in Titusville for sure.

Like all good restaurants, Valentino’s carries a legacy—in its particular case, one that stretches back some 100+ years to nostalgic, family-secret recipes emigrated from Italy itself. Maybe that’s why Valentino’s is my instant go-to for pizza in my local area. It feels personal. It’s not part of some chain dealing out processed dough in pre-measured portions. It’s hand-tossed, home-cooked, and original. Upholding New York tradition, Valentino’s keeps their crust thin and powdered—soft in the middle, crispy and browned near the edges. It avoids the usual “thin crust” crunch, but also isn’t doughy. Biting into a slice of Valentino’s pizza, I know what to expect—lots of cheese, a crispy crust, and just the right amount of grease. The flavor is a fine-tuned balancing act between dough and toppings, resulting in a perfected texture and taste. Because there’s no waste of excess dough, Valentino’s pizza leaves you feeling like you’ve devoured a legitimate pizza, and not a pan of bread flavored with melted cheese and meat sauce. At its best, Valentino’s offers a wholesome, filling pizza—one with that “secret-recipe” taste you can’t get from chain restaurants. Eat it in-restaurant, and it’s guaranteed to be steaming and warm, with cheese melting and stringy (and guaranteed to burn your tongue, too, if you’re overly ambitious—I usually start off by cutting the first slice into bite-sized portions with my fork while waiting on it to cool). As it’s a family-owned-and-operated restaurant, Valentino’s is more than happy to accommodate your preferences. A 50-50 pizza is no issue for them (Half peperoni and half veggie? You got it!), nor is a flatter, crispier crust (Sicilian is an option, though it’s pricier than the average saucer). Wait time can seem lengthy, but only if you’re eating on-site. Pizzas are generally made fresh-to-order, meaning that wait is worth your while. A big-screen TV provides more than enough entertainment while you wait. Atmospherically, Valentino’s resembles a darkened Italian pub, with painted murals along the walls and lamp-lit tables—a pleasantly noisy among the TV. clinking of dishware, and bustling of conversation. It’s a family-friendly environment, oddly sophisticated and inviting without being exclusive. Pizza may be Valentino’s forte, but it’s far from alone in its excellence. Valentino’s cheese steak hoagies and calzones are worth the trip, too. Calzones come at a generous size, though their simplicity often makes them a better side dish to split among friends than a solo meal. Cheese steak hoagies, on the other hand, are made to satisfy, packed with juicy meat and a choice of peppers, onions, cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mushrooms, and drizzled in Italian dressing. They’re a meal in their own right, or the perfect meal to split in half with a friend over an additional pizza plate. Hoagies come with a handful of potato chips as well. While pizza is definitely the drawing point for Valentino’s, they also offer a variety of Italian treats—from dinner plates to desserts—that are worth experiencing, so I encourage any frequent customers to experiment with the menu. If you’re in the Titusville area, looking for something unique, Valentino’s is an affordable, worthy consideration. Located in the Sears Town Mall, it’s an ideal place to eat before/after heading off to the mall theater for an afternoon showing.

My husband loves pizza so we had to try this place that was recommended by his coworker. I got the Eggplant Parmigiana Sub. Some people might complain that it’s bland, but I liked it. The chips that paired with it were salty so I ate some with each bite. The next morning I stuffed the chips in the sub and it was amazing! My hubby got a medium meat pie. It was yummy. My daughter got Baked Ziti. I tasted the crusted cheese on the edge and it was good. We shared Fried pickles. The sauce it came with was really good. We were stuffed but we still ordered dessert. The tiramisu was Heaven. They ran out of Brownie-crusted Reese’s Cheesecake so we replaced it with a cannoli. I’m not a huge cannoli fan, but it wasn’t bad. There are so many options to choose from we will probably go back for more.

Top notch service. Came here today to have a nice lunch with my dad. He's type 1 diabetes and crashed so fast it was terrifying. The staff jumped into action and got us carbs for him immediately. Jenny and staff kept checking on us and were just incredibly kind and attentive. The food was awesome and this little mom and pop place should be supported by our community.

Excellent food. This place has been in business for decades for a reason. There's no reason to eat pizza anywhere else in the area.

Old school New York style pizzeria and Italian restaurant. The mall is going to be torn down so not much to the interior, don't expect much. Their tomato sauce, garlic knots, meat balls and Italian sausage are all very very good. Salads are average. My Aglia y Olio was perfectly cooked and delicious. I prefer real parmesan cheese for entrees to powdered ones. Service is good.

This is truly a landmark establishment in Titusville. Prices are quite fair, good-sized portions, and staff is always friendly and ready to assist, however possible. This is one small business that needs to stay open.

Our first visit was more than memorable.. It was meaningful! Me and my four young children randomly came across Valentinos as we were browsing the mall and trying to escape the rain. I called ahead and ordered and just as promised it was ready within 20 minutes. We were kindly greeted by the smiling waitress as well as the owner himself, whom was behind the counter preparing a ticket for the next lucky customer. I was holding my daughter Gracey as I was waiting to pick up my order while my oldest looked after the other two in the dining hall. (Which was very spacious and kid friendly). Grace was interacting with the kind owner and was gifted mints as I was signing the check. I passed them amongst my children and we chatted along. I learned he proudly had 5 children himself. (or so he said-his wife did) Which I thought was very cute response). I mentioned I actually had six, but two were away at the moment. Nevertheless, as I was receiving my order he asked where I had parked and I explained by the Antique mall. (Which is across the mall). Without hesitation, he offered to help retrieve our car so that me and my children wouldn’t get soaked and neither would our dinner. I asked if he was absolutely sure and he insisted that his son Francesco would pull it around for us. I couldn’t help but accept such a kind offer from such a friendly family. (Which is very hard to come by nowadays). Within moments my car was waiting for us as well as his sons as they helped us get in our truck. I can’t reiterate enough just how much this first impression made on me and my family. We are so thankful for their hospitality, their generosity and delicious white pizza. Our whole family will be returning very very soon. Thank you again Olivio Family!!!! May God bless you all abundantly. Truly, The Fines Family

Love this place has a good classic vibe grate old school pizza the best pizza I have had will be going soon.

I have always bragged about this pizza to everyone, and I drive from Palm Bay to get it, had the worst waitress yesterday, she was absolutely miserable, the pizza was ok, the main pizza cook wasn't there and the pizza definitely suffers when he is not there, but its still better pizza than most, I cannot say if other foods are good but my friends portion was very small. Please work on your wait staff, not asking for perfection but this lady was nasty.

Its always the best from thw pizza to calzones strombolis its amazing if u like good italian this is the place to go..this one in the old mall is the best

Best pizza in town!!!! We drive all the way from Jacksonville for this delicious treat....and we're pretty snobbish when it comes to our pizza thanks to Valentino's 🤣🤣

I absolutely love pizza (who doesn’t) and have had it many places. But Valentinos’s by far makes the best pizza in town!!

In Orlando from Ohio for the weekend. We wanted pizza and Google shows this place as a top pick. We called 15mins before they closed. The owner talked with us and made a few recommendations. Best New York style pizza ever. Thanks Valentinos on garden!Highly recommend the garlic knots.

Been going there since I was a little girl and I love their food!!! Best pizza in town. They never disappoint and the service is great too!

Great little pizza joint with a small town feel. Always excellent quality and friendly staff. Always very busy as they are a pretty popular local spot. The restaurant as a whole gives off a great local feel which is vey charming. I personally like their Stromboli which is excellent. Great place to go with the family!

Your workers have a nasty habit of ignoring paying customers if they don't fit in the typical yet racist stereotype. So I am only giving one star and you dont even deserve that. terrible customer service and I would not recommend this place to anybody especially a person of color because they get treated less than human when you walk into this establishment. Will be reported n complaints are going to be made. I didn't have this happen to myself personally but I am a witness to the obvious racism.

The food was excellent, and the service was top-notch. I really enjoyed going there for my meals!

We go every we are in town. Authentic Italian food . Highly recommend their Seafood medley and Linguine with clam sauce .

I love this place. We came in late on Christmas Eve. The food was delicious. The service by a girl Cheyenne was the best.

The first time I had pizza it was great Loved it. Had to have the Valentino’s pizza fix every month. So sad the last three times we have gotten a burnt pizza. Awful. I’m sorry to say we will not be given them another chance.

Food is always fantastic!! Owners are always in house and super friendly!! We go to this place often. My husband is Italian and we are allowed to eat here!! lol

Service was fast and the Pizza was delicious! I would definitely recommend to anyone wanting a great pizza!

My mother, father, and son visited the restaurant for my son's 21st birthday. We ordered, Stromboli, a slice of Sicilian pizza, a slice of pepperoni, two spaghettis with garlic knots. Our waitress was friendly, our food was good, and everyone left happy! it was a great night at Valentino's.

Always great food and friendly service. Have always had date night with my kids here even when they where little.. good prices as well.