Snick
We have been ordering delivery several times a month for a while now. They typically don’t start delivery until 5pm, and it can sometimes take a while since they’re so popular. It is so worth it though, they have the best sauce, the dough is nice and crispy but also just the right amount of soft. We adore the calzones and the garlic knots.
Finally decided to dine-in today. Our server was polite and prompt. We loved the homey feeling of the restaurant and the food was amazing as usual. Highly recommend!
Gabriel
Very old school little Italy kinda vibe interior. Workers were all charming happy folk. I didnt have my card but they were accommodating and were able to just punch it in the cc machine. Had the eggplant parm hero with sautéed mush and green peppers. Took me right back to nyc. I td em it was so bad i had to lick the plate.. lol all fresh ingredients cooked perfectly on toasted bread. Amazing flavor. Perfect texture. Will def come back on my way back up the florida coast. Thanks guys for the awesome dining experience!
Samuel Leckron
I have been eating here since I was knee high to a grasshopper. When I played soccer, if we won we got to have pizza here. Now days I go for more of the dishes, but still enjoy a slice every now and again.
This time visiting we started off with some garlic knots. I ordered the Shrimp Scampi, and others in my party had the Calzone and the Chicken Pomodoro. Everything was as wonderful as it always is. Glad they are back open and have touched up the place while it was shut down due to COVID.
Denise Gunnels
Went on a Monday night. Seated ourselves. The booths weren't the most comfortable thing I've ever sat in. Not too many people seated but they were doing a brisk delivery and take out business.
The waitress came promptly. Ordered a beer and a carafe of house Chianti. The Chianti tasted like it had been around just a bit too long but after a couple of glasses it was tolerable.
The garlic knots were stale. Fresh bread should have been used not Friday or Saturdays leftovers. Those should be made into croutons. I think they were several days old. The sauce they served them with wasn't anything to write home about. Pretty bland.
Go for the pizza. We did a half and half with the house special on one side and pepperoni on the other. The pizza was absolutely SCUMPTIOUS. Crispy crust, fresh ingredients and the meats used where very tasty on their own. Super yummy. It made my taste buds and my tummy so very happy.
Overall, the food was good and the service great. I would return again. You know you are some place real when the owner and the cook are speaking to each other in Italian.
The Travel Agent
Ordered the white pizza with pepperoni and sausage. It was huge!! We called and ordered before we got there, and asked to eat it in the restaurant. Wonderfully accommodating. Can’t recommend enough! It was more than enough for four people!
Richard Gotwals
Stopped in for dinner with friends. The wait staff was very helpful with my food allergies and ordering. The food was very good. Portions were moderately sized but taste was excellant. This is a small restaurant and the kitchens response to our order was a little slower than what I would have preferred but most of the salads came out quickly as well as the garlic bread so we were OK. Hadn't been there in almost a year and we were not disappointed in our meal. Good value too!!
Laurie Shanabarger
After a long day of working, my hubby and I stopped for dinner before the 2 hrs ride home. Dinning room was too cold so we took food home. Well people the food was great!!! No complaints about the food or our Waitress. I would go there again. I rate food 5 stars, Waitress, 5 stars, temp, 2 stars, restaurant it self I liked. I felt like home.
Mark R
Just got two large pizzas from Valentino’s on garden st Titusville and they were hot and delicious. These people really know how to make a great pizza and it is always hot and steaming on pick up.
Our Trilogy: Time
First time experience. The pizza tasted amazing! There were 5 of us and we all tried something different.. loved it all. On top of that, we originally planned to dine in but had some poor planning on our part and had to change our order to go half way through. The staff was super nice and understanding about it and got our order out quickly so we could make it to our appointment on time. Great staff and great food! Thanks guys!! 😊
Amanda Mathews
I stopped in at Valentino's one day just before noon just to try their food considering I've lived just down the street for 5 years but hadn't had food from there even 1 time.
Let me just say, as a woman with Italian blood in her and who also makes chicken Alfredo from scratch, I have very high expectations regarding flavor and texture of this dish when I order it from restaurants claiming to make it from scratch and I must admit I was blown away!
I immediately called my fiance to tell him (his favorite food of all is specifically my chicken alfredo) I found a place with a chicken Alfredo that rivals my own! Not to mention their garlic knots were also the best I've ever tasted from any restaurant.
Lastly, as if the food itself hadn't made enough of an impact, the waitress who works there was an absolute doll. So my fiancé and I already have plans to go there this weekend on our date night before we go to see a movie. Hands down the best Italian aside from my own that I've ever had the pleasure of tasting.
Shravya Murthy
Freshly made food. Their garlic knots were great! The pasta could have been cooked a bit more. It felt undercooked. The Sicilian slice pizza is quiet filling. Overall, a good experience.
Annette Lais
Our family had the supreme stuffed shells, cheese ravioli, cheese steak hoagie and fettuccine alfredo. All were yummy!
The garlic knots were crispy on the outside and soft in the inside complemented well with the sauce. The cannolis are on point.👌🏽
The staff is very friendly and polite. It is the type of mom and pop place you want to keep going back to because the items are homemade.
Fred's Internet Island
Wow! Great food. Cheese steak subs with onions and mushrooms are hot and fresh on a toasted 12 inch bun. We got french fries too. Big portions. Nice employees and easy parking right out front.
Marcy Fr
Garden St location:
Searching for a gluten-free crust? Tasty no cheese option? They have a cauliflower thin crust they know how to cook to perfection...crispy! Others have it but usually overload with moist ingredients or too much cheese so it does not crisp. Try it without cheese! Their red sauce is good, then add spinach, onions, garlic, or other non-moist topping, ask him to crisp it. Enough for 2 people or one very hungry. You'll love it! And your tummy won't hurt afterwards!
When splurging...Our favorite calzone is opposite, regular dough, yummy (but not quite as healthy...) just add feta inside and garlic butter on top. Crispy. Golden brown. Yum! Pair with salad. Enough for 2!
Servers are diligent, friendly, positive without being too talkative. Makes the meal enjoyable. Facility is small and normally quiet, peaceful. They do a ton of take-out business so the phone calls are nearly constant at peak times. Nice way to learn the menu, though! Good phone etiquette.
My only wish for improvement is their iced tea. Sometimes too weak and watered down. Could be brewed stronger. If we could match the tea from Mr Submarine or Lloyd's, they would have a perfect meal!
Kalene Chasteen
So delicious! The best pizza and cannolis we’ve had since we went to Italy. Loved meeting the owner Giovanni and hearing about the history of Valentino’s. Super nice staff and the food is fantastic
Dolly Decker Weaver
Every time I go there, I love the food! BUT...my only complaint is their forks. Is it me or does any one else agree, I can’t stab my lettuce! Not funny. If I know I’ll dine there today, I put my fork in my handbag. Kinda silly complaining about a fork but, their tines are flat! I don’t eat pizza. LOL.
Sally Barnes
Giovanni has personally selected wines for the menu. The Margarita pizza is wonderful. Don't miss the buffalo wings if you enjoy sizzling, sinus clearing flavor. Drop off the I 95 for a taste treat!
Edward Michal
Excellent pizza and friendly service. Their service after the hurricane speaks volumes about character. They had a limited menu and didn't jack the prices up. That alone is 5 stars in my book. Thank you
Danny Young
Worked for the owner for a week is now refusing to pay me those who are trying to get a job do not go here its under the table he will not pay you
Shantal Bordeaux Rosales
Good food and fast friendly delivery. Ordering again tonight. Nice to get delivery at the marina.
Sarah Falta Mason
Not only are the waiters/waitresses attentive and friendly, the food is delicious and fresh! The gentleman who cooks in the back is so kind and our kids love watching him make pizzas. We frequent this place and will continue doing so!!!
Randy Thompson
Highly recommended! The food is superb, the service is great!
Maria Ann Josephine Hayes
Great food and a wonderful atmosphere! I can't wait to eat here again!
Brenda Schenck
The place to go for awesome pizza and Italian dishes. They will make it anyway you want it!....also the best cheesesteak sub in Florida!
Jamie Hull
Great food, we had pizza and anti pasta salad. Staff is AWESOME!
Stevo Sepulveda
Love the atmosphere, the food and the service. Excellent!
George Ramos
Found the food to be poor quality and service poor, I asked for a refill 4 times and decided to stop asking.
Corey Johnson
Great pizza. Great service. I have been in the pizza business before. Dough is a major factor. The pies are great and consistent. Love the knots too. And the wings. Don't have anything bad to say about the food at all.
Cj Karpinski
Great pizza and awesome service from JJ. Will be back again
Julie Rheinschmidt Barron
Best pizza and service ever!!! We go in as often as we can!
Donna Brandon
Great neighbor Italian restaurant. Every thing we have ordered has been delicious. Good service, friendly staff!
Wes Babecki
Ordered delivery. Seemed very expensive and they didnt bring the whole order. Still waiting for missing item for over one hour. Pizza was good.
Pauliush
Best Pizza in Titusville. Best Pizza ever!!! redonkulous yummy!!!! Best costumer service in house, take out or delivery!!!! Love them!!!
Eco.ramon
Best Pizza in Titusville. Everything is made fresh, restaurant, facilities, and kitchen are kept clean. Staff go out of their way to offer exceptional service, get a draft beer and and a frosted mug! These chefs are the read deal and give you good American Italian. The family owners are deeply rooted engaged in the community and care about delivering a good meal and dining experience for an unbelievable fair price. Driving through stop in you won't regret it.
Solar4113
Best pizza yet. We are from NY and we loved it. My wife is not a big pizza eater but she thought it was great.
Tammy
Food was great and so was the service! <br/>We've stopped at this restaurant for the last 10 years on our way to south Florida
Tammyc96
Save your money. Poor quality and horrible service!
Rebecca Moody
Love the pizza!! Called late after a Daytona race when staying in Titusville, they had just closed and still made us a pizza to go!! They were fantastic and so was the pizza!! Will come back everytime we're in town!!
KEN
PIZZA AND MORE. THE BEST IN TITUSVILLE ANY PIE REGULAR OR SILCILIAN.THEN TRY THE HAMBURGER
Kathy
Fantastic!. The pizza is the best in Titusville! The Sicilian Egglpant is a summer special that is out of this world. We are longtime customers and enjoy all the meals that John, Anthony and Vinnie make.
Billy
Great food and service. Great place for the whole family.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes