We had a fabulous dinner tonite after the matinee (Beautiful which also was wonderful)!
I had the shrimp scampi special and it was absolutely delicious and my friends had the best lasagna in town. We also treated ourselves to a couple decadent desserts which were worth taking a cheat day -Tiramisu and the chocolate cake! Very yummy! Always leave here happy!
Really a great atmosphere… Wonderful food! They are very creative on their appetizers and great service! I would highly recommend Sebastiano’s for anyone who enjoys a good meal!
We were very satisfied with our experience at Sebastiano’s. The waitress was very pleasant and provided good service. I had the portobello mushroom ravioli which was offered that evening and it was delicious! He had the spaghetti and meatballs which he enjoyed as well. We each had a salad which was also very good. The atmosphere was simple but nice. We would recommend!
You can have horribly long waits for mediocre food in Toledo on a Saturday night, but not here! We got sat quickly and had some of the best Italian food we’ve had in a long time. The service and atmosphere were great and the prices were reasonable. I’d recommend this LOCALLY OWNED restaurant to anyone. We’ll be back 🤓
Audry Karanovich Todia
+5
Absolutely amazing experience at this restaurant while traveling through Maumee. Laura was our waitress and she was just fantastic with our family!!!! Guitar player set the mood. Very happy we found this restaurant! Will definitely come back even though it's a 2 hour drive!
Love Sebastiano's! They made our anniversary special last March! Wonderful chef and the food is marvelous. Not the typical Italian chain food! Special entrees by the chef!
Great meal! Great service! Wonderful atmosphere with live music! & a pleasure meeting the owner John. Thanks for taking the time to come out and introduce yourself! Look forward to the next time.
Food was 6 stars service speed was 4 stars, overall a great place to eat!
My wife and I went there last night with friends of ours, and were immediately impressed not only by the friendliness of our greeter, but by the ambiance and 'coziness' of the restaurant as well. One of the owners, Sarah, waited on our table and connected with us immediately, and her co-owner husband Jonathan cooked our dishes to perfection. I had the gnocchi, and the greatest testimonial I can give it is that it's the best I've had since my Italian grandmother's, which she would make from scratch when I was growing up. The others in our party were equally impressed, and we're already looking forward to our next visit there.
This was our first time coming here. We eat next door all the time and I told my husband I wanted to go to Sebastiano’s instead. We had a wonderful meal and we will be coming back.
Had a wonderful dinner last night at Sebastianos! The food was excellent and Jonathon and Sarah were so kind and welcoming. It was definitely a family feeling and we can't wait to return!
Debbie McPherson Ducket
+5
My husband and I split a meal of Chicken Marsala that was excellent. We each had 1 1/2 pieces of chicken in a excellent Alfredo sauce served with fresh mushrooms. Plenty of food for two people to split a meal. The nice thing was the kitchen split it for us. We will definitely come back!!!
Amazing food, relaxing atmosphere and local family owned, what more can you ask for!
We ate there last night for RWT and it was by far the best meal ever, the bosc pear pizza appetizer was simple amazing (should consider keeping that on your menu)! The dinners were delicious and we will most definitely be back very soon! #youwillEATbetterinToledo
Been here 4 times, but under a new owner and management now. Menu is more diverse now. Food quality is still great. Both meat sauce and Alfredo sauce is homemade. For sure get the homemade tiramisu. Best Italian food I've found anywhere in Toledo.
We went here for the first time tonight. The food and service was excellent. We started with the toasted bread with olive oil, garlic, and basil for an appetizer. Both soups (minestrone and Italian wedding) were good. We had the bowtie pasta with meat sauce and linguine with Alfredo. The sauces were homemade and the pasta was cooked perfectly. A great choice if you are hungry for Italian!
Food was really good, but service was awful... All in all though, I would go back
This is a hidden gem in Toledo! Atmosphere is casual, but the food is wonderful. The pasta dishes are great, pizza is different but very tasty. Salads fresh and appealing. Desserts are presented in a refrigerated case that you can view when you walk in. Not the best idea in my opinion. Almost looks like the desserts are from Sam's Club. However, they do have a homemade Tirimisu that was pretty good. Only thing missing is bread. I would expect them to serve fresh Italian bread prior to or with dinner, which they don't. They include a small slice of a focaccia type bread with your meal. I do recommend you try this place though. It really is quite good!
Best Italian in Toledo!. Sebastiano's is easily one of the best restaurants in Toledo. The soups are wonderful and all the entrees I've tried have been excellent. The portabella mushroom ravioli and there is a seafood linguine dish with lemon that is out of this world!
Great dessert selection as well.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes