I went with three girlfriends and we had a blast!! The bartender was super friendly even though she was busy and it was one of the best Bloody Marys that I've had! The French fries were very good and came out quickly. Can't wait to go back and try one of their Bloody Mary that looks like a meal! Great place to start out my 50th bday celebration!!
I found this place on Facebook. If its good enough for former Packer players, its good enough for us. We stopped in on a Monday and got the Sirloin special for $10. The salad bar was good and the steak was well seasoned. Drinks were really good. I'd stop in again next time I'm in this neck of the woods.
This was my first time at Smitty's. Our waitress was very friendly and everyone enjoyed their food and salad bar. Would recommend to others!
I went on a Friday fish fry night. Bar and dining were busy. There was just two of us so we decided to sit at a tall table to leave a 4 seater table open for a bigger group. It just so happened the bartender Jenny, was our server. She was amazing and efficient. The fish was perfect my baked potato was the best I'd had EVER! I really can't say enough good things about the service or the Friday fish fry. I really don't eat fish.....but when I do, it's ONLY from Smittys Overtime Inn.
This place epitomizes Wisconsin. Hot and delicious food, friendly bartender with a ton of hustle and the service was fast and friendly. Let’s not forget that the prices are unbelievable. What a value!!
Best place love it such nice people excellent wait staff always excellent food and service a must go to❣
Had the boiled shrimp dinner. Thought it was great! Service was pretty quick and they were right on top of refills for drinks also. All in all great experience.
Great food, great people ! I would recommend Smitty's Overtime Inn to anyone.
Stopped by for a late lunch. Tried the fish special. Very tasty and very reasonable priced. Service was prompt and friendly. We commented on how reasonably the prices were for their lunch and nightly specials. We will definitely stop again
Had great food we had the fish fry is was very good service was great
Small, Hometown bar/restaurant. What an awesome menu,such variety! We loved our meal! prices were reasonable, service was awesome. Drinks were good. We will absolutely return here on our next drive through town, in one year!! Wish it was closer to home. Would highly recommend stopping here. Dinner and quite a few drinks and still under $60!
Pretty good place! Never eaten here before, never heard of it, so thought we would give it a shot. Glad we did. Its off the main drag, so prob why never heard of it. I got the pizza, hubs got the Fri special: Prime Rib. He couldnt get over how good it was. I agree...very tender. The pizza was ok-nothing special. Our waitress was nice & very attentive-checking on us & refilling drinks. I ordered a chef salad to go w the pizza-she said i could just go & clean out the salad bar instead-and offered us all salad bar just to get rid of the stuff. Everything u want 4 a salad. The chili was pretty good also! Hubs said he would def go back since hes stationed here!
A little off the normal route but so glad we made the decision to stop. Food was great, prices fair and the staff were very pleasant! Excited to go back again and try something besides the salmon and prime rib. The soup and salad bar was a nice appetizer.
Owner is very Nice seafood platter is delicious Alfredo is to die for beer cheese soup was amazing and salad bar was great I highly recommend everyone to check them out if your looking for great food for a reasonable price. Also you get alot of food for a decent reasonable price. Super delicious we will return for more of your yummy food.
We had pulled pork sandwiches and a kids grilled cheese and kids chicken tenders with my family of 4. Great food, great prices. Our hostess was amazing, friendly and kind. Felt very comfortable with my two young kids there.
My wife and I dined here tonight. I had broiled cod and it was the best I've ever had. Large portion, fixed right, with drawn butter. Also salad bar and baked sweet potato. Wife had shrimp and it was good.
The food was excellent, staff was very friendly. Highly recommend stopping for a great meal and drinks! We will definitely be back!
Fabulous Food whether stopping for a Fish Fry or other succulent specials such as Prime Rib or Chicken 🐔 !!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes