Don't be fooled by the small shack. They make the best pizza we ever had. By far! The sauce is perfect, never burnt or too acidic like other pizza parlors. The cheese is very high quality and not greasy and the crust tastes just like Italian bread. If you try their pizza you will get addicted to it
They have tables outside, which during the summer are wonderful, but during the winter are very very cold even though they do have an outdoor fire pit. They are open year-round, but during the winter months it's almost all take out, there is no indoor seating. They also have free delivery within 5 m
We came here after a football game, its not a place I would have seen going down Kettle Creek but its definitely a reason to travel down that road. The pizza is really good, thin crust and not oily. The meatball parm we ordered was the best I ever had. The win about it is that its outside near the w
Everything we have gotten from Gencarelli's has been excellent the pizza's, the appetizer's, the dinner entree's !!!!! And besides the food the whole staff is AMAZING they treat you like FAMILY, Gencarelli's is the best thing to happen to our little community in silverton !!!!!
Today was my 1st order as I heard about it from other people. I'm a white pie lover so I had to give it a try & it really was the BEST One I've had in the area !!!! I would highly recommend this place for your next pizza order !!! I am now a loyal customer!!!!!
Just got 2 pizzas from them earlier. Their buffalo chicken pieces is amazing. Even open and delivering in the snow! Great food and nice people!!
Best pizza! Thin, crispy,gooey cheese and yummy sauce. I don't live near, but I will be BACK for sure!
Best cheesesteak in Silverton, highly recommended. Get it with mushrooms, peppers, and onions.
NO LONGER AT LOCATION. It was a great pizza place, unfortunately they are no longer in business there, I don't have any details.
Very good Pizza. Good price too. 👍
FINALLY REAL PIZZA 🍕 IN THE TOMS RIVER AREA IT'S AWESOME!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes