The best reasonably priced pizza which definitely does not lack in flavor. Staff always listen and go above and beyond to make your order just the way you want it made. Delivery is always come fast. My family orders from Alfredos about 3-4 times a week….. WEE LOVE ALFREDOS
I can't understand some customers that believe that the quote "The Customer is Always Right" when they are complete unaware of the costs for the food they order and the time and effort it takes to make such food, and the standards for selling it. They believe they should get additional add-ons and extra food for free when nothing in this world is given for free. This is norm of equal trade for products you desire from a merchant as a customer.
First time ordering from here. We did pick up for a simple pie and garlic knots. Between the 4 of us we ate everything. Wasn’t the best pizza but it was very good. I’d order again.
I order from them on Uber eats and they are unparalleled.
10/10 best. Prices are insane, food goes crazy
(They have the best lasagna I've ever had and it was BOGO too)
The pizza needs to be crisper more cooked but the seasoning they use is delicious. They are very nice people and good service
This is the BEST PIZZA JOINT. In West Babylon, Altalia is over rated over priced and has gotten too big for their bridges
The ppl who work here are the kindest honest ppl you can deal with the prices are unbeatable the food is Delusious they have actual coupons with great deals (Football season boys and girls this is the place) I am getting hungery just typing this. Hell, there is the best on the island. The ONLY! thing I can make a complaint about would be the small parking lot, but aside from that, with dosent effect Alfredos, this is the place
So if you visit LI and you're in the west, Babylon, Babylon, and North Babylon even west Islip, get your food here, nothing else compares
The new owner is a great a guy, hard worker and the pizza is delicious!
The owners are wonderful, fun just great atmosphere and prices are fair and food is always delicious.
They have an extremely efficient system in place with ordering. They know there customers. The food is excellent. Staff is friendly. They are very hard working customer satisfaction is their main priority. When our order was a few minutes late they gave us free garlic knots. A great little pizza place.
Uber Eats Buy 1 Get 1 is a deal you can't beat! Absolutely delicious
I had a great chicken roll there. Having just the right amount of sauce and salt takes skill in preparation. They really did an A+ job and it was some great chicken roll. You're going to love it.
Best chicken roll out there! Every time I order from other places they are next cooked through, not Alfredos! its always cooked perfectly through never have to wonder if im eating raw dough or cheese!
One of the best slices on this stretch of 109, and one of the best on Long Island in general. I’ve had Pizza from the North shore, South shore, to the Hamptons. The cheese is excellent. Sauce is great. Prices are very fair, not those overpriced junk slices. The 5th star is missing because the crust leaves something to be desired.. it doesn’t have an aftertaste & isn’t soggy or anything, just a bit bland and slighty underdone- but it doesn’t compromise the slice at all. Also, I’ve been going here for years and the workers aren’t the nicest. But that’s not too big of an issue for me personally, as I go there for food not conversation.
Friendly staff, best prices, and top quality. This is our new favorite pizza place, we couldn't be happier every time we order from them. Thank you for the free mozzarella sticks on my birthday! They're one of our favorite things to order.
This place is definitely a wonder.
Management is great. Service is always excellent and prices are perfect.
I ordered using door dash and one of the items I ordered was taken by the delivery driver, the owner or manager was kind enough to remember and the next time I ordered they gave me a discount and free desert.
They won me by showing me they care about their customers.
You guys are doing a great job.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes