Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Bagels in West Islip

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Higbie Bagels
89/100 (1283 ratings)
Bakeries
Cafe
Cafe
Lunch
Breakfast
Bagels
Cinnamon Raisin Bagels & Rainbow Bagels
Café
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"Reopened recently after a fire. 5 Stars! Nice selection! They do have minis here. Bagels are always fresh and soft. Not doughy like some of the..."
310group
"Not only are the Bagels fantastic but the assortment of cream cheese choices are amazing. Love the West Islip colors on the special bagels. I really..."
Sal and Ang Montanino
"Best Bagels in the area. Expect a line out the door on weekend mornings but worth the..."
Thomas Wilson
"An authentic old school bagel with bubbles cooked proper made with love. The best bagels on Long Island super nice owner and employees...."
David Marotta
"Higbie bagels are simply the best.. crisp on the outside & soft in the inside & even more amazing if their hot.. staff is friendly &..."
AJ Buquicchio
"Me and my family were on vacation and my Cuzin highly recommended my kids wanted to go there every day but managed at least a couple times the staff..."
Fredro Star
"Just moved to west Islip a few months ago. Now I was in search of a new local bagel shop in close proximity to my place. First off, this place has..."
Justin Saurer
"Perhaps the best bagels I've ever had in my..."
Peter C
"Great bagels. Ex excellent cheese Danish, whenever they make them. Not every day Quick and easy the veggie cream cheese is to die..."
Dennis OCONNOR
"Some great bagels. Staff friendly, place clean. Bagels were a bit expensive, but seems like all the places went up. Overall I'll go there..."
Art “A2Jr” Angst
"Everything flagel with eggs, avocado and pepper jack cheese was perfection! The girl who helped me was super friendly and efficient (loved the thumbs..."
Healing Room
"Omg absolutely the best breakfast place! I ordered from them thru Doordash and I can happily and honestly say they are the best breakfast sandwiches ..."
Maria Nicole
"Bagels are very good. However the past few times I have asked for vegetable cream cheese the amount barely cover the bagel and there wasn't even..."
Janette D'Angelo
"Staff is very affable and courteous. Bagels are fresh and very very tasty. Variety of cream cheeses with a wide selection of sandwiches and wraps..."
Julio Amaya Jr
"The new owners have done a fantastic job. Not only are the bagels just as good as before, but they now do breakfast sandwiches. Best bagels on..."
BETH ZANNI
West Islip Hot Bagels
86/100 (172 ratings)
Bakeries
Cafe
Cafe
Lunch
Breakfast
Bagels
Café
Café
Breakfast
Lunch
"Best spot for sandwiches!! I love this place. Been coming here for years. Great staff, great service! Their “Big One” hero is the best I’ve had..."
Luis Castillo
"Amazing bagels, both by themselves and as a breakfast sandwich. Good amount of seasoning on the everything bagels, soft, and..."
Kelly Kay
"Service was fast and super friendly. The BESC I had was 10/10. I'll go out of my way for food..."
Joe Santos
"The bagels are amazing and the staff are so friendly. I walked in 30 minutes before they closed on a Sunday and ordered an egg sandwich. The grill..."
Dylan Kirsh
"Just got bagels from here for the first time and was very happy with the service and food. Bagels were fresh and the Puerto Rican woman at the..."
Rich Gruttola
"Always a pleasure. No other bagel place is this..."
Maureen Feeney
"Theirs egg sandwiches are the best an love the everything..."
Karl Snyder
"You can count on this place being open during most storms. They have a pretty good selection of meats for a bagel store and that comes in handy when..."
Dom Gee
"This place has really good bagels. The typical selection. Egg sandwiches are made well and the bagels are fresh. It's a small place but don't let..."
Greg Foster
"Very good! Prices are great..."
John
"Great bagels! I recommend the French toast bagel. The only issue I had is no seating to eat there 😏. But it's still very..."
Paul P
"Great priced bagels, extremely generous on the cream cheese, however their breakfast sandwiches are nothing..."
M J
"Been buying the best bagels and coffee here for about 20 years. Great bagels, boiled and baked for that great NYC taste, crunch, and texture. Great..."
Steven Berge
"Love West Islip Bagels! Bagels are always fresh, and the have great veggie cream cheese. Excellent customer service as..."
Marianne Poore
"everyone is always so friendly! good..."
Kristal Biscardi
"Great staff. They friendly and nice. Loved their..."
Brianna campbell (Bree)
"Best place to get a quick breakfast in the morning in the area, have gone there for... well pretty much all my life, they open extremely early for..."
Kyle Eiklor
Bagels Buzz
76/100 (7155 ratings)
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Breakfast
Bagels
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Cheap Eats
"There bagels are amazing everything agel with chicken salad amazing there employees are amazing love the..."
Darlene Stanley
"i recently walked into the WI Bagel Buzz for the 1st time. i was greeted right away with a smile. they were getting busy. it was about 11:30am. i..."
Debra Agenjo
"Always very happy with my healthy egg wrap with fresh veggies from here. Order breakfast often here and so delicious and hot and ready quickly...."
Kim Matty
"My clinical group and I from Adelphi stopped at Bagel Buzz to interview the owner and get lunch. The owner was so nice and the food was delicious. We..."
Kaylee Lamonica
"I absolutely love this bagel place ! Not only is it clean and inviting the staff are so friendly and even remember you by name ! Let’s talk about..."
Danielle Marie
"These people are great. They all a great workers and even due to short staff due to covid they have great work effort. These people will always put a..."
Alexandria Patton
"I love this deli, I stop here every morning before work for my sausage egg and cheese, not only are they quick and affordable, but also delicious!..."
david bloom
"Very good service every time I..."
Robert Voce
"My favorite bagel spot around. Best egg sandwiches on the island. If Bagel Buzz closed so would a piece of my soul because That’s how much I love..."
Rob Malone
"This is the best bagel place I have ever been to in my entire life. Everyone is so..."
Kayla Serowik
"I’ve been coming to this location for almost 7months and definitely don’t plan on stopping. Their bagels are very fluffy and fresh, and great..."
Yourstrulydragon
Stuff-a-bagel
70/100 (862 ratings)
Restaurants
Quick Bites
Brunch
Breakfast
Fried Eggs Cheese & Sausage on an Everything Bagel
Rainbow Bagels
Bagels
Cream Cheese
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Brunch
Breakfast
Cheap Eats
"Great spot for bagels and really good cream cheese. Not the spot if you’re looking for a specialty coffee but they’ve got all the staples. We..."
Scott
"Great place to stop by and pick up some freshly made bagels before hitting the water to..."
D HAHA
"A little to expensive for me very clean and efficient. But I can get an egg sandwich for almost half the price at j&g deli in..."
Robert Ricciardi
"good food, prices and..."
Erin Bell
"Travel nurse from northern Michigan. They don't make bagels like this in Michigan. I've read the recent reviews and my opinion on the negative..."
Brett Scholten
"Good bagels. Good prices. Decent coffee. I didn't always get what I ordered, so I started writing it down on paper and handing it to the counter..."
Paul Hoffman
"When we first moved to town we went to every bagel place in the area. The taste of the bagels here far exceeded the rest. The owner is a jerk (rude..."
Nash Birnholz
"Best bagel spot in the area. Don't let others one-off reviews scare you away from this place. Been coming here for years and have tried bagels from a..."
Evan Andersen
"The new management is wonderful! It’s VERY clean. Very friendly staff. Bagels are always good too! No..."
Cristina Cutrone
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use