Sluurpy
Reset

There is only one restaurant

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Birthday cake in West Islip

There is only one restaurant
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Carvel
86/100 (99 ratings)
Bakeries
Birthday cake
Carvelanche
Ice Cream Quart Soft Serve
Ice Cream
Café
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Free off-street parking
Accepts Credit Cards
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Cheap Eats
"Family owned location whose owner always goes above and beyond. This is a custom cake I ordered with lots of specifications. Beautifully made and..."
Mlschief123
"Excellent off the beaten path, local Carvel place... Wednesday is Sunday everyday! Friendly, fast efficient service, delicious ice cream sunday's..."
David S
"This store specifically has been handling all my birthday cakes since 15 years ago. To this day they have not disappointed. Best ice-cream cakes..."
Tommy Wang
"Just like the other reviews said. Owner and the staff have always been incredibly nice. Ice cream is always..."
Lawrence
"great ice cream cakes and great customer service! loved the sweet girl who helped me..."
Dilan Yilmaz
"Always a great establishment and Paul is super friendly. Ice cream sandwiches are..."
Wesley Wu
"Staff is awesome even when you show up late. And it's Carvel so it's..."
Theresa FromLI
"Best Carvel in the area! Owner is always aiming to please...."
Danielle Delaney
"Normal Carvel...a place to get your ice cream 🍦..."
Richard Benkov
"Every time I go to this store, I'm blown away by how kind every single person who works there is. They are generous, and the service is always..."
Alyssa Nosworthy
"Good service always yummy..."
Andres Ramos
"Best Carvel on Long Island. Whenever we are hungry for Carvel cake, root beer floats or flying saucers, we travel to west islip Carvel. The man who..."
Kathleen Goldin
"Owner always cheerful. Family loves the large holiday ice cream..."
meg reilly
"Hot summer days beat thing to have is soft serve cone. EVERYONE was super friendly and sweet. Love going..."
K O
"Great people that work there and it's Carvel can't get better ice cream..."
Theresa Iacovo
"Carvel in w. Islip is the best 👌 place ever, they are never stingy. Sad to say but I dropped the bag 🎒 😪 nd lost all of my ice cream 🍦..."
Barbara Liguori
"There are 4 carvels in my area, a cold stone creamery and a few baskin robbins and this is the only ice cream place we will go to is this Carvel. ..."
The Life Of Julian
"Ice cream was exceptional . No rest room , which didnt help . Service was lacking . Not real friendly . Needs immediate attention . But ice cream..."
andy hanna
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use