We've never had any complaints with Portage all the times that we have come and or put orders in a head of time. We ordered a specific pie today. Got it home and cut it to eat and it was so tart that it physically made tongues hurt from the tartness of the berries. We added sugar to the top of the p
Pies are expensive here there's no doubt, but we bought a grape pie from them that was incredibly delicious.
I've tried a few grape pies in the region and none compared in taste or perfect crust to the one I bought here! We'll be back again!
Great pies! Just bought their strawberry pie. It's pretty good! Freshly made. Just come prepared. It's cash or check only and if your looking for something specific then call and order ahead. It's literally a tiny hallway to pick up pie orders. They have some already made but selection is limited. S
The best pies I've ever had! Dessert is an important food group for me, and Chautauqua has no shortage of it. From Perry's ice cream to Amish baked goods, there is plenty to eat up. The pies I've had at various restaurants and farm stands have been good too, but none have compared to Portage Pie! Ou
This is how much pie we have left after we got it today. I’m thinking we’re doing pretty good so far. Well what can I say about this place. It absolutely amazing. We snuck it at closing time today and got the last pie available. Banana cream. Just add that one to the list of awesome pies at this pla
Best pie on the planet!
Be sure to order ahead to ensure you get the flavor you want. They were featured on PBS a couple years back as an amazing pie place! You will be ruined for other pies, they just won't compare!
Most amazing pies I have ever had!! Last visit was Concord Grape and Peach. This is the most amazing flavor combo ever!! Grape jumps out followed by the peach, and a crust that is pastry like. You almost dont want whipped cream here, it will take away from the wonderful flavor of local fruit.
Great pies. Expensive but worth it. Crust is wonderful. We got the key lime this time. Yum! Reserve your pie cause they sell out!
This pie place is the best. It's best to order in advance because just showing up you are not guaranteed to get a pie, or the one you may want. It's definitely worth the stop. Pic featured is a pie that just came out of the oven. Pies are made fresh daily.
Absolutely the best pie anywhere! The building is no longer a faded blue but a deep red. No credit cards. Only Cash accepted.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes