Van Wolff
I liked the pizza - it was really very tasty! But bring a flashlight, it was very DARK inside. We couldn't read the menu but the waitress said we did have a flashlight attachment on our phones that we could use. She said our eyes would get used to the dark. It was really strange. They serve 'their' size pizza which was huge but it was a very good price. I really liked the pizza and the sangria was very good. If only I could see more. It was very noisy (music and voices) so don't come here if you want to have a serious conversation. The biscuits (sea salt, chocolate excelsior) were very good. It was within walking distance of the Sheraton. I don't know how to rate this restaurant - I regretted not seeing and hearing in there because that would have made it great.
Amanda B.
I don’t usually do reviews but this place was a solid 8/10. The calzone was really good the only thing I did not like about it was it was a bit too doughy on the edges so a bit too much bread and that it didn’t have the crunch factor I was looking for, but this is just me being very nit-picky. The pizza was super good again 8/10 the crust didn’t have that crunch I’m use to but it was the closest thing to NJ pizza that I had in awhile. I was going into eating here with no expectations so if you’re reading this trying to decide whether you should try it out go into this place with no expectations because you will be blown away! I highly recommend trying them out for yourselves! The other thing is I have no idea how the staff is as I ordered delivery through Postmates, but whoever made my pizza thank you for taking me back to my hometown!
kimberly castro
First time coming in and wasn't sure what to get . The staff was very friendly and patient with me. They took their time suggesting and explaining all their pizzas! I ended up going with their margarita pizza which was definitely the best choice !! Definitely coming back soon
Abi S
Used to be the best... Now the worse pizza in Whittier. This is not a Fake review. The Garlic knots were burned from the bottom. The Salad that came with Family meal never got delivered and the Pizza was so salty we tossed it. It was a Uber eats delivery and I payed 90 bucks for garbage.
Richard Good
Had a Stromboli very greasy but tasted good marinara is good but a bit too runny daughter didn't like the pizza very much had a slice of pepperoni not bad for the value
Joseph C.
Tony's Pizza is a great little hole in the wall. Friendly hard-working staff. Great selection of pizzas you can buy by the slice or whole. I even made an extra large pizza out of one of each slice of about three-quarters of what they offer. It was $30 but worth it because it was like a delicious sampler platter of what they offered. I also ordered two slices the second time I came which comes with your choice of either soda or salad. They also have good Stromboli and calzones. They have a good variety of Italian style food. I haven't tried it all but I will surely come back again to try the rest of it from time to time. My only complaint is that sometimes the tables stay dirty after people have eaten. But after I told them of the dirtiness of the tables someone came out immediately and cleaned them up. I also like the old style pictures on the walls and the fact that it is a pretty cozy place to eat.
Nicole McCormack
I've been wanting to try this place for months and finally did tonight and it was really disappointing. We called our order in and arrived 40 min later to find out they didn't have our order written. They said they could make it in 15 so we waited. They got it out around that time frame, which was nice.
We ordered a large 2 topping pizza with
mozzarella sticks. I didn't notice until I got home but the lady ringing me up overcharged for the pizza. Based on their website the total should've been about $25 without tax. Mine was $30 after tax. So it was about $2 overcharged (probably ringed me up for an x-large). Normally I wouldn't care but they've already messed up my order...
The pizza itself is okay, really greasey. The mozzarella sticks are good and I love the marinara. I would've given 3 or 4 stars if the order had gone smoothly.
jade
It’s pretty decent if you wanna just get a slice of pizza, but dough is still quite raw but the garlic knots are so GOOD and the marinara sauce too. I recommend those, quite chatty staff although but everything else is good!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes