Sluurpy
Reset

There are 4 restaurants

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

Best Ice Cream in Windermere

There are 4 restaurants
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Jeremiah's Italian Ice
93/100 (995 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
American
American
Coconut Gelato
Tasty Italian Ice Flavors
Bahama Freeze Strawberry Lemon
Lemon Basil
Mango Italian Ice with Ice Cream
Banana Italian Ice and Chocolate Ice Cream
Sugar Free Tangerine
Horchata Italian Ice
Scoop Froggy Mint Chocolate Italian Ice with a Swirl Gelato
Mango with Vanilla and Strawberry with Vanilla
Ice Cream
Gelato
Caramel Apple
Strawberry Shortcake
Soft serve ice cream
Pumpkin Spice
Oreo
Mango Gelato
Fast food
American
Wheelchair Accessible
Parking Available
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Accepts Mastercard
Accepts Visa
Accepts American Express
Accepts Discover
Seating
Cheap Eats
"EXCELLENT place for a quick, refreshing snack. The gelati was incredible, I would definitely recommend this..."
Anthony Sangenito
"I really like this place so much and i had it the other day with my two sisters and one of my..."
Radha Tulsieram
"So delicious! And the young girl taking our order was friendly, and patient. She even helped me pick a flavor. Wish I remembered her..."
Jessica Rivera
"The best Orlando spot for a cold treat! Dang now I want to go back..."
Scott Wolf
"Awesome place. Kids love the ice cream..."
Rahul Rkcian
"It is A Awesome � great place to Visit and the Outside seating is Nice �. And the Pina Colda Italian Ice is tasty, as well a Strawberry..."
Bonnie Mitchell
"Awesome Gelati and customer service! The staff at every location is always so friendly and..."
Bob Staples
"The ice team is always tasty and the service is always friendly! A great place to celebrate after school..."
Tony Pittsley
"Love this place there's no ice cream like it. We try come here at least once a..."
Dominick Dimattina Jr.
"So delicious! I love trying out new flavor combinations every time I..."
Cari Withrow
"It was bitter cold out, but this place was awesome! A friend described it poorly, so I was hesitant, but the ice cream was amazing and I'm..."
Tim Wood
"I am from out of town. This is my second time coming here. My 4 teenaged nephews recommended it. Very good place for dessert ! Oreo Italian ice was..."
David Gonzalez
"This was a great place for ice cream. The girl who waited on us was so friendly and nice. Our Italian ice treat was delicious. We got a medium but..."
Janis Reynolds Mitchell
"Sour green apple Italian ice is amazing..."
Rachel Mulford
"I had the best first experience here with my boyfriend. I live in Destin FL and was visiting in Orlando for a week and noticed an ad on Facebook for..."
Halle' Pearce
"I loveeeeee this place! I feel like a kid in a candy store everytime I go! The watermelon and strawberry Gelati are my favorites!..."
Kimberly Davis
"Ok , I came back after a bad experience and I can say that this is my neighborhood ice cream place and the service is much better ,as always .I had..."
Milly Navarro
"I love this Jeremiah's, the ice cream tastes amazing, there's constant variety on the menu, and the employees are very nice too, the location does..."
Allen Pimentel
"This place was great! Was the best Italian Ice I ever had. We had mango, orange flavors with vanilla. Very clean and the workers were super friendly...."
Peanut Pupper
"Great after dinner place! Very creative way to involve Italian Ice and Ice Cream! I had the strawberry and ice cream and it was heavenly. Like..."
Chris Childs
"Lots of flavors and combinations. If you’re not sure about which flavor to pick ask to try them until you find your..."
Annette Harris
"Always a good time with some ice cream. A young lady who works there named Bella is a gem. Very customer..."
Steve Mulloy
"Yummy! This Italian ice is delicious and if you want some extra creamy sweetness, add ice cream to it! Plenty of parking and seating. I suggest that..."
Kat Fred
"The staff was friendly and as always my order was..."
Dawn P
"Daughter enjoyed it. As an ice cream aficionado, I didn't care for it much at all. We got a small size for my daughter and it was more than she could..."
Brian T
"Who would have thought that ice cream and Italian would make a good combo? I got the vanilla ice cream with Pina colada Italian ice and it was..."
Leon Robinson
"Family favorite for the dairy free Italian ice. Their peanut Italian ice is..."
Randall Peterson
"LOVE IT ALWAYS!!! Pup even had some doggie I've cream. Great way to make Monday a little less Mondayish. Updated 3/27/2022 We tried to go and try a..."
Aaron Prohaska
"First time at jeremiah's italian ice and we were amazed at how delicious it was. We look forward to returning and trying it..."
HUBERT
"Soooo good! Our family has a problem with these delicious frozen treats, we're addicted! If you haven't experienced a "Geloti" you need to do it as..."
Brad Duncan
"I had the chocolate Italian ice with Oreo cookie crumbles, it was soo good. This is my new favorite..."
Marjorie Coleman
"They made an error in my order. I came back to get a new gelato made for me and for the inconvenience they gave m 4! Amazing..."
John Fernando
"Cotton Candy gelati is everything to..."
Anica Cousley
"The Mango Gelato was amazing and my server today was so nice and helpful! I love how you could sample them in case you are stuck between a few..."
Winston Lightbody
"It's different because of the ice and ice cream mixed in a cup but I didn't enjoy the p nutty and chocolate flavour..it tasted like raw peanuts and..."
Nikita Murali
Allen's Creamery And Coffee House
88/100 (477 ratings)
Dessert
American
American
Ice Cream
American
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Cheap Eats
"Try the pulled pork sandwich. Nice place to kick back and..."
Marc Wilder
"Just moved down here from Northern IL and I tried Allen's today. I had a coffee. Service was great. Nice atmosphere and Coffee is great. I would..."
Jeremy Porter
"Love the ice cream and the service was EXCEPTIONAL! Patrice was an absolute doll! Definitely going..."
Nicole Downing
"My first visit went very well. Tried Caramel Caribou which was heavenly! Love the ambience of the place. Definitely will be returning soon..."
Uzma Osman
"Delicious donuts and great atmosphere. I will definitely be..."
Andrea Rose
"Our favorite ice cream place! So many different flavors and the kids love the chill..."
Christina Mirance Garcia
"Nice place to sit and relax watching to world go..."
Rod Larsen
"The Key lime pie milkshake was amazing, along with excellent service. We will be stopping in more..."
Toby Starr
"Excellent! Apple fritters and good old fashioned wake me up coffee! So long panera..."
Cherry Christian Davis
"Amazing ice cream and Apple Fritters the size of your..."
Clay Harris
"Brilliant for a coffee and doughnuts, relax and..."
Graham Parish
"This place is super cute. The original ice cream was better when they first opened, but they have switched to a different vendor now. It's still..."
Diver Dee
"The Best of the Best!!. We love Allen's!! They have the BEST Donuts anywhere....They have the BEST Beef Brisket which we found out is smoked for over..."
Mark-alen
"It's not a chain. I enjoy having ice cream with my two boys and enjoying the tree lined street outside or watching them shoot baskets across the..."
TJ
"Allen's is so great! Anything said otherwise is nuts! Fantastic icecream... Best I've ever had. Every flavor tastes just like it says it will...."
Alyssa DeMetro
"Best ice cream in town with a great variety of flavors! This used to be my hangout spot when I was in high school. They are closing doors on..."
Kev Win
"Ok so this little place is deceptive. It looks like a walk up ice cream place (and it is) but inside there are couches and a tv and a table with..."
Mark Wisehart
"Nice place. Good prices. Unfortunately they are closing on September..."
Beverly Piñango
"one of the best flavors of chocolate I’ve ever had, can’t wait to go back and try their other..."
Camilo Romero
"I took my mom as she wanted a banana split. I wanted a place local & that was not a long drive. I found this cute little ice cream shop in Downtown..."
Corey Middleton
"I thought the ice cream was good, the friendly staff is 10 times better! (Kidding, the ice cream is really delicious!) The combination of sundae..."
Peter Loesch
"Great place to stop on a hot day...or any day...great staff and good ice..."
M Madia
"Super cute shoppe! Not many milk alternative options but the ice cream and service was soooo..."
Tiffany Payne
"Good flavors, your standard ice cream spot. Prices were Windermere, so if your ready for that…enjoy! Staff was friendly and has a good variety of..."
Ian Davis
"Friendly staff and wide variety of flavors and different choices. They have milkshake, cones, even nitrogen made ice cream! Our first visit they..."
Aaron Long
"Super cute ice cream shop in a great location! The hometown feel makes it even better. Shops like this are hard to come by these days. The caramel..."
Rachel L
"Mmmmmm the coconut icecream its the best. Everyone should try..."
Reginald Penrod
"Sadly the shop will be closing later this month :-( I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice..."
Aaron Prohaska
"We love getting an ice cream after having dinner during the food truck event every month. Family place, super clean and nice to visit while in..."
Travel & Fun
"Allen's Creamery and Coffee is a nice ice cream shop. It's location is a great place to visit for a treat before or after a stroll in downtown..."
spamset willy
"I tried out there nitrogen i e cream it tasted amazing. I will definitely be back soon. Staff was very helpful and explained..."
John Pinkowski
"First time here and it’s wonderful!!!!!!!! Best milkshake I’ve ever had in my..."
Jessica
"The staff is friendly and don’t mind offering you a sample. I had a classic ice cream sundae with soft serve. It was delicious! We enjoyed our ice..."
Ames
Jeremiah's Italian Ice
82/100 (594 ratings)
Dessert
American
Italian
American
Italian
Guava
Parfait
Italian Ice & Soft Ice Cream
Vanilla Ice Cream Chocolate Ice
Grasshopper Mix
Watermelon Ice and Vanilla Ice Cream
Strawberry Shortcake Mix
Pecho Gelati
Ice Cream
Strawberries Gelati
Gelato
Peach Gelati
Birthday Cake Mix
Piña Colada & Cookies & Cream
Fast food
Italian
American
Cheap Eats
"Delicious. I combined orange ice with vanilla ice cream. It tasted similar to an old fashioned creamsicle but far..."
Barbara Moran
"Flavors are SO good, lots of samples, can mix flavors -..."
Heather Kennard Flanagan
"Update 3/9/2023 Jeremiah’s is great, as usual! My daughter had a coupon for a free small item that she received from school so of course we had to..."
Mel
"Amazing as always! We have been to several locations, and it's always great to see how friendly the staff is. They seem to always enjoy the..."
Steven
"We love, love Jeremiah’s gelatis, which is a combination of Italian ice and soft serve ice cream! There is a huge variety of Italian ice flavors..."
Nesha Z
"My go to dessert place whenever I am on the road in the area. Great flavors and always refreshing on a hot day in..."
Alan Lichtman
"Best Italian ice and I always get a nice customer service, the employees are very kind. I definitely love this..."
Andrea Herrera
"We finally went to Jeremiah’s. Seating seems to be limited at most locations but we found a seat on a bench while I quickly ate my soft..."
Amy
"It's was amazing they are nice people give u 3 samples there wonderful I can't stop going there cause its..."
Jaiceona Green
"Elizabeth and mom here!! We love Jeremiah’s we come whenever we can!..."
Maria Elena Pereira
"Jeremiah's is the best place for a sweet treat on a hot day. They always have a variety of flavors so even the pickiest person will find a flavor..."
Nicholas M
"Great staff and good food. Be sure to sample a couple..."
Michael LeBel
"Best ice-cream ever!! hands down... Also, great friendly..."
ruben mena
"Most of the time, this location is a hit. Yesterday...not so much. There's a male employee who just literally throws your order into the bag and out..."
Emily F
"A yummy place to grab a treat. We go here for special occasions with our kiddos usually. Decent prices for a tasty dessert. I like the blend of the..."
Nate Patrick
"This place has amazing Italian ice! They have a unique combination of flavors that will satisfy any sweet tooth. As a vegan I felt like I had several..."
Deepali Kanji
"This place is awesome. Even on a hot Florida day, their Italian Ice stays cold. Great flavor choices, and if you aren't sure about what you want,..."
Nicholas Buol
"Easy to get to of 535. Ice cream mixed with Italian ice is awesome. We had chocolate with mint and strawberries and vanilla, both were great. They..."
Ronnie Marshall
"Not only was their italian ice, gelati, and soft ice cream AMAZING but their CUSTOMER SERVICE surpasses any establishment I have visited. The moment..."
Angivelis Encarnacion
"Always an awesome experience! This is my favorite treat place around. Absolutely delicious and great to mix the frozen ice with ice cream. My..."
Scott Cummings
Bruster's Real Ice Cream
79/100 (667 ratings)
Dessert
Fast food
Ice Cream
Fast food
Mid-range
"I have eaten Busters since I was little in Jacksonville and I was so happy when I found this one opening in Windermere! The freshest Ice Cream &..."
Brooke Kantack
"Great spot for walk up ice cream. Flavor selection is good, ice cream is creamy and flavorful. However, last time we went we got two hot fudge..."
Bina P
"So fun, my and my friends' balloons were really nice. And it was also a really exiting and fun atmosphere. The Baloon Twisters were so fun and..."
Gio Ribeiro
"Ice cream was great and we loved the balloon artist outside. He was so much fun. I can’t wait to bring my..."
Randi Zevon
"All Ice cream is not equal. Bruster's is definitely in the top running for some of the greatest ice cream you'll ever have. Fair warning, lines can..."
Dakarai Ward
"The ice cream was good but the real treat was the balloon man out front! My kids LOVED the balloon costumes he made for them. Super friendly,..."
AImee B
"Our whole night was made by Gabe the magician/balloon artist!! He made our daughter a heart balloon hat as well as did the coolest magic tricks!..."
Korina Cockrell
"The ice cream was amazing! So yummy and refreshing! I also got a cool free balloon hat from these amazing balloon artists from Balloon Twisters,..."
Mikee Ombao
"Isabelle and Max were great, provided amazing customer service. My son Leo, and my daughters Lindsay and Emily loved it, exceeded..."
Julian Perez
"We had a great time having ice cream’s and balloon artist. Gabriel was awesome. Will definitely come again next..."
Amilcar Velazquez
"The Balloons Artist was absolutely awesome 😎. Need him..."
Sheron m White
"Absolutely the best balloon artist. You all have a winner with this guy. The million dollar man! How far do you all..."
Aaron Greer
"Ice cream is delicious and my daughter was SO EXCITED with the guy out front making balloon animals! Fun experience all..."
Laura Smith
"Finally came here for my first time and it was really good! Staff was friendly and offered great recommendations and even let me try a few flavor..."
Josh
"this was my first visit to a bruster's. the employee was polite and gave me coupons for next visit. no wait time. i got a dino sundae and cookie was..."
Alexis Talicol
"The Bruster's team did a great job creating our son's birthday ice cream cake on 27 hours notice. The cake, filling, ice cream and icing were of..."
Sam Wakim
"Highly recommend. My niece will go nowhere but here for ice cream. They have a great loyalty program and new flavors monthly. Italian ice as..."
Longtime Local
"We visited for the vegan ice cream. The selection was slightly limited but what we got was excellent. Possibly the best we've..."
Michael Johnston
"Great ice cream but the balloon man made our trip even better! Our kids had a..."
Christina Purkiss
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use