Bagel Jay's Amherst

Bagel Jay's, Amherst 4498 Main St - Amherst

Fast Food

70/100

VIEW MENU

VIEW MENUS
Reviews
Call
menu

MENU↗
Timetable
Make a reservation
Order online
Share
Map
Ratings
Add photo

VIEW MENU

 Reviews +1 716-839-2222 Timetable Make a reservation Order online Add photo Share Map Ratings
Full menu with prices and photos

VIEW MENU
Based on 470 ratings and reviews
Updated
70 /100
Phone
+1 716-839-2222
Write a review
Share
Look at the photos

Menu Bagel Jay's

  • Popular Items
    • No. 3. Egg, Bacon, & Cheese
    • Flavored Shmear
    • No. 4. Egg, Chicken Sausage, & Cheese
    • Bagel (1/2 Dozen)
    • No. 1. Egg & Cheese
  • Taste Tempting Specialties
    • The Delaware
    • The Buffalo Club
    • Albuquerque Turkey
    • Athens Turkey
    • Mediterranean Tuna Spectacular
  • Deli Favorites
    • Roasted Turkey Breast
    • Ham
    • Roast Beef
    • Corned Beef
    • BLT
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Bagel Jay's (menu)

Ratings of Bagel Jay's

Google
Google
Last update on 07/12/2023
3,9
405 Reviews

TA

Trip
Last update on 23/03/2023
2,5
5 Reviews

Reviews

4
Bill Robinson
+4
The bagels are very fresh (we saw a guy making them in the back) and the sandwiches are very delicious. The veggie cream cheese is very flavorful also. The staff are decent and not overall friendly but not rude either. The prices are a little expensive, a family of four spent $36 on 4 sandwiches and 4 drinks.
4
Michael Cooperman
+4
Excellent place. Only reason it did not receive five stars was because the prices have been jacked up considerably in the last year. Rendering else was great! I'm not blaming them personally (not their fault), but it does take away from the overall experience.
5
Justin Cox
+5
Good location, easy to get in and out of. Service staff was friendly, bagels were delicious, and menu offerings were great too. Tried the "JayNormous" bagel sandwich. Sandwich tasted great, but tall & cumbersome to weild. Would recommend any of the meats on it (sausage, ham, bacon), but in a more managable size.
READ ALL REVIEWS
How would you rate your experience at Bagel Jay's?

Description

Report the restaurant as closed
Request the menu of Bagel Jay's
Join the community of Amherst
Add Bagel Jay's to the address book

Timetable

Monday:
06:30 AM - 03:00 PM
Tuesday:
06:30 AM - 03:00 PM
Wednesday:
06:30 AM - 03:00 PM
Thursday:
06:30 AM - 03:00 PM
Friday:
06:30 AM - 03:00 PM
Saturday:
07:00 AM - 03:00 PM
Sunday:
07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Compare the best restaurants near Bagel Jay's

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

Bagel Jay's

 70 3.9 2.5
Panera Bread 70 3.3 3 3.5
Kyoto Japanese Restaurant 85 4.3 4.3 4
Mi Tierra Restaurant Amherst Mass 79 4.3 3.5
Jimmy John's Sandwiches 70
The Filling Station 90 4.7 4.8 4.5
Insomnia Cookies 77 4.2 4.5
7-Eleven 70 3.3

Related restaurants

Edith's Route 60 Diner, Amherst

Edith's Route 60 Diner
Golden Crown, Amherst

Golden Crown
Omi Omy, Amherst

Omi Omy
Jazzboline Restaurant & Bar, Amherst

Jazzboline Restaurant & Bar
IHOP, Amherst

IHOP
Subway, Amherst

Subway
Bagel Jay's, located at 4498 Main St in Amherst, has been rated by Sluurpy users with 3 recommendations, ranking 107 in Amherst. To make a reservation, you can call +1 716-839-2222 or visit their website http://www.bageljays.com/., 3 Sluurpy users have confirmed an average price of None, with 1 super positive reviews.
The most recommended dishes by users are: non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy and non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy have received 3 reviews, other users have suggested these dishes to try: non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti disponibili and non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti disponibili., At Bagel Jay's you can enjoy typical Fast Food cuisine, rated as excellent by 1 people. For those with intolerances, they also offer non abbiamo informazioni sulle opzioni di cucina options.
To summarize
What dishes can I find on the menu at Bagel Jay's?
non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy and non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy
What is the rating of the reviews?
Rating: 70
How much does it cost?
Price: None
Rating
  • Cuisine 🧑‍🍳: 0 recommendations
  • Ambience 🍽️: 0 recommendations
  • Service 💕: 1 recommendations

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT

What's your favorite Bagel Jay's's dish?

Ratings and reviews

70
/100
Based on 470 ratings and reviews
Updated
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use

1
X

How do you rate your experience at Bagel Jay's?
INVIA

Browse Menu
Add review
Add photo
Make a question
Suggest restaurant