- Best pizza in Columbia, and the only pizza of which my husband, who is from CT, approves. Nice people in there too. I recommend it to everyone!
I freeeekng love this place . Anytime we have family over from out of town this place is most. Anytime there is a Gamecock game we go there we just go there all the time. Great people ,great place, great atmosphere and amazing pizza and super awesome prices. We love it. Keep up the good work, see you soon.
It's the best New York style pizza south of the Manson Nixon line!
They have the best meatball sub this side of the Mississippi! They also use high quality ingredients, so the mozzarella and sub rolls are soooo good!
This is THE place to get pizza in Columbia If you have seen my size u know I've eaten a pizza or 2 in my time and this place is the best I've had since I've been in the states true NY style pizza made by true New Yorkers with a true New York feel to the place ...huuuuuge slices of pizza and I recommend the meatballs on yours as i always get on mine ... I love this place and you will too don't take my word for it come down and try yourself !!! I mean what are you waiting for STOP READING AND GO NOW !!!
New York style, buttery crust cooked well. Lunch specials during the week. Had a large meat lovers, the chicken bacon ranch will be next trip. You need to try this place.
Very good! We are new in town and trying out new restaurants. We will be back!! Very authentic.
Sebastian Georgallides
+4.5
Easily best pizza in town, aaaand best Italian sandwich I've ever had and it's huge! The owners are very cool as well
Service was prompt & polite. The slices were hot and tasty. Great pizza joint. Beer is served in plastic cups and the selection isn't expansive. Thin slice of pepperoni was greasy, still tasted great. Sicilian was a thick, square piece of crust, crunchy & soft--the bread is my favorite part of pizza, so right up my alley! You can add toppings to your Sicilian for $0.45 each. Yummy stuff.
My favorite spot for pizza... Without question. You won't be disappointed.
My 1st time here and ill definitely say the pizza was great. Crust had a nice chew to it and was flavorful. Perfect pizza to fold and eat. Will definitely be back.
This place is amazing! You want real NYC pizza. Then this is the place. Looks like a NYC pizza place too. They have sicilians and actually sell pizza by the slice. When you go to Nicky's you are transported to NYC. Love this place.
This is the best pizza in town, hands down. I’ve traveled a lot, and this equals the best I’ve had in many larger cities and other countries. Best of all — the dudes who make and serve the pies are awesome. Total bros, with awesome customer service. They and their pizza are the real deal!
On point. Slices were big. Sauce and dough were top notch. Worth every penny. Pitchers of beer are affordable and the perfect accompaniment.
This pizza is as close as we’ve come to our favorite Brooklyn pizza. The slices are large enough that you even have to fold it over. It’s not too greasy and if you like a crispy crust, ask for well done.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Columbia
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes