Love the atmosphere and the the NYC mural and pictures on the walls. The staff was very friendly, the server very quick and efficient. Truly felt a little like NYC without the congestion outside.
They have both inside and outside dining. We ordered a single piece of pizza which was huge and very tasty. Also ordered the garlic knots which did not taste like garlic but were very very tasty without an overpowering garlic taste. The consistency was perfect, taste was just a little bland but adding a little salt and red pepper flakes which were on the table made them more tasty
Will definitely return!
This place is definitely a 3.5 stars if not some more. The service is always good, the food fresh and the servers attentive and knowledgeable about the menu. The actual place is a little crowded but clean… even the bathrooms!! And that’s rare for a place that is so crowded. Go hungry 😋 and expect the food to be yummy 😋. #enjoy and the rest will be pizza history 🙃. We had the 14” Manhattan pizza with hot chicken wings and left there more than stuffed with a box of leftovers. It was definitely worth the $$. Hope you #enjoy it!!
Amanda “Haute Hair23 by Amanda” G
+5
Our experience was great! From the mommy we walked in to the time we got our food!!!! Our kids are now wishing we had one of these locations in St.Louis!! From the plentiful toppings to the cooked to perfection crust!!!! They definitely don’t just hire anyone to cook & you can tell! We ordered an 18in 1/2 Bronx 1/2 cheese! It was the perfect size for a family of 4 & the price point is awesome! They also sell by the slice if want to try a bit of everything 😁
I cannot say enough great things about this place. This is one of the top pizza places in Lee County. As a former New Yorker, I can tell you with confidence that the slices here are amazing. The buffalo pizza and chicken bacon ranch pizza are my favorites. If you want the best chicken parmiagana sandwich in this area then you have to order one from here. The bread, the mozzarella, the sauce, the chicken. SUPER DELICIOUS. The staff is super friendly. The only negative that I would say is that they should be open later on Fridays and Saturdays. It would be nice.
DELICIOUS!!!! One of the best NY style pizzas (without visiting NY) around! Tony's rocks a variety of different pizzas with catchy names! From the "Bronx" (which I had) to the traditional deep dish Sicilian, there are plenty of pizzas options to choose from. The serving staff is pleasant and fast! You can pick from just a single (HUGE) slice to a whole pie. Eat in or carry out, you won't regret either choice!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Fort Myers
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes