Liove McAlisters. Always great!! Recommend it to anyone.
My daughter wanted to stop here. She got a sandwich which she really loved. I got potato soup. The potatoes in it were hard and the soup was very salty. But she enjoyed her brownie too.
McAlister’s Deli is a great place for lunch. I have now been to a couple locations for McAlisters and had a great experience both locations. Their sandwiches are a great size for lunch, and they provide a lot of different options. The atmosphere is perfect for a quiet lunch with family and friends, and the staff is great. They come around and check on you, making sure you have everything you need. The place is very clean, including the bathrooms. The prices are fair as well. Definitely recommend you give them a try!
Enjoyed my first visit to McAlister’s Deli. This location is connected to Castleton Mall so parking is a little crazy on a Saturday evening.
Very friendly cashier who was helpful and answered questions. I took my cashier’s suggestion and had the Choose 2 option with half a Savannah salad (with Sherry Shallot dressing) and the Spud Max. Both were very good, but I actually enjoyed the salad the most. I would come back again just to eat a full sized version of this salad and dressing.
Pricing isn’t too bad. For three of us to eat and drink, it was just over $30.
Food shown pictured:
My meal: 1/2 Savannah Salad and Spud Max
Meal 2: 1/2 Southwest Cobb and Spud Max
Meal 3: Club Sandwich and Macaroni and Cheese side
It was pretty quiet for 1pm on a Monday but that's great for me! No crowd, no lines and peace. The place was clean and service quick and pleasant.
I love eating here. The food is great, the staff is kind, and the restaurant is clean. I could eat here everyday if I could. And I'm usually skeptical about drinking water from public places, but the water here is delicious and I love their "brookies".
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Indianapolis
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes