Wicked Lick
335 Duval Street - Key West
Recommended by Sluurpy:
2025
2024
2021
#227 of 340 restaurants in Key West
Updated on
Sluurpy Quality Index
PROPRIETARY
Popularity
100/100
Quality
66/100
Data Completeness
67/100
Verified Dish
Add Missing Dish
🚚
Delivery
🥡
Takeout
♿
Wheelchair accessible
📊 Popular Times
Not busy
Moderate
Very busy
📷 Photos (11+)
+3
more photos
more photos
Photo 1 / 11
100%
Google Reviews
388
Google reviews
Loved the atmosphere and staff, my wife and I got 4 different flavors of ice cream. Ghirardelli chocolate YES mint chocolate chip OK key lime YES blueberry cobbler OK overall ice cream is light, some of the flavors ypu can taste more of the cream and smoothness others I could taste more texture and ice. I liked how it has a from scratch flavor about itself. The toppings list is great, my.wife got their sugared waffle in which they torch before putting ice cream on and that's EPIC. I loved the dessert we chose that night it was really good. Would get another dessert from Wicked Lick
Read more
Google
Gotta love the name and slogan for this top rated Ice Cream Parlor on Key West. We were lucky enough to stop in and met the owner who was as nice as can be. We ordered the Coffee and Mint Chocolate Chip - best ice cream on the Key!! All made fresh on site. Very clean, well stocked with tons of flavors, and grab a shirt or hat while you are there. We will always come back to this place.
Read more
Google
Stopped here for something sweet and it was alright! The ice cream is nitrogen made I believe so it is light and not too heavy on the stomach. You can tell it’s freshly made which is a plus.
Google
Don't get the PB ice cream... Every time I have had it, the fat coagulates and it is super greasy and you have a layer of fat at the top of your mother. The blueberry cobbler was good but it would have been better with chunks of cake mixed in to get the full cobbler experience.
Google
After spending time walking in the hot sun we stopped in here for a scoop of ice cream… the positive is that they make their own ice creams and they have some fun, unique flavors. The only negative was that they don’t serve/sell a single scoop – Doesn’t make any sense, as every other place does and being mildly lactose intolerant, I prefer to limit my ice cream intake, especially on a very hot day.
They do let you try before you buy and they have a decent size selection to choose from. The flavors we tried were awesome! Highly recommend stopping in. Oh, one more negative is they only have chocolate sauce, not hot fudge to go on top. They would totally get 5 stars if it wasn’t for this and the lack of selling a single scoop.
Read more
Google
Never have I had ice cream that was chilled and created right in front of me! I had the coconut agave ice cream, which was delightfully creamy, light, and two scoops was the perfect amount. Not overpoweringly sweet like some other ice creams, perfect for cooling down on a hot afternoon!
Google
The nitrogen ice cream is so cool and they make it in house. The key lime ice cream isn't on the menu but they have it! You have to ask for it. FYI: the small size is actually pretty big (2 scoops). 10/10 recommend.
Google
Ice cream and shakes here are yummy. Just the thing you need to beat the heat. However, prices are slightly steep probably because this town is frequented by tourists.
Google
Cool concept with delicious ice cream and large portions, these are small and they were hard to finish. This is the Cookie Butter (I think that is the name) and Pistachio...both excellent. They are 6.90 for a small plus a $1.50 for extra toppings. Pricey yes, but they give you a lot of ice cream and tastes fresh and high quality so no complaints here, and as you can see when I ordered a topping of waffle/wafers they gave me a ton. Very happy experience. There is no where to park near here so either walk or Uber. Worth a try!
Read more
Google
This has got to be the most delicious ice cream I have ever eaten. The flavor is wonderful and the texture soooo creamy and soft. I love that they grind up the pistachios for their pistachio ice cream, and the butter caramel sauce is INSANE. I wish we would’ve known about this place earlier in our stay. Do yourself a favor and get a scoop…or 3!
Read more
Google
Explore more in Key West
Recommended pages
Help improve this page: