Excellent service, excellent Buffalo style cup-n-char pepperoni pizza, the breadsticks are like a Utica tomato pie, and my new favorite dessert, the fried dough is a must-try. The menu is exactly the same as Mike's in Skaneateles (I believe Sissy is Mike's wife). This place is a treasure on the East side of Otisco Lake.
First time ordering from Sissy’s and wow!! I ordered the NY Style pie with wings, hands down the best pizza I’ve had in SEVERAL YEARS!!!!
Thank You for showing you care too. The quality of ingredients and the attention, shows you give a “____” !!!
So So VERY good.
No more searching for amazing pizza.
Found it.
Until next pizza night 💙
We have tried all of the local pizza places and Sissy’s is by far our favorite!!! Delicious pizza and wings and my kiddos love the fried dough! Love being able to place my order online and they notify me when they are ready to deliver- which they did in freezing cold and snow! Always impressed!
Finally! A remarkably good pizza place right here on beautiful Otisco. The pie had a crisp crust with great flavor, great sauce (many choices), wings large and meaty with more great sauces, and the calzone was as good as any I’ve tasted. So happy we are lucky enough to this type of quality near by. We plan on becoming regulars.
Came here while fishing at Otisco Lake Park and everything is delicious! Even the salad is fresh and delicious! Will come here again and again!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Marietta
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes