ollie spears (2 Forks 1 Plate)
+4
I got a pepperoni and Sausage pizza with hot oil.
This pizza is a hybrid. A cross between bar pizza and thin crust.
This crust was chewy. I enjoyed this pizza 🍕 pie. I'll be back.
Ok let me start with - Irish Pizza!!??
They already anticipated this question and put up a sign near the entrance with their origin story which is a pretty cool one.
The place was completely packed on a Monday night, we were given a wait time of 45min on arrival and I'm glad we stayed.
The pizzas were incredible and since they're thin crust you can easily finish one whole za.
My favorite was the salad pizza,we ordered 6 total and 2nd fav would be bacon with hot oil.
The place is affordable and if I come back to Connecticut again I'll make sure to visit here atleast once.
For the first time in my life I finished a whole pizza and a little more all by myself. Although yes the pizza is thin crust so it's easier to eat.
One thing that stood out was the innumerable pictures of veterans. They put up pictures of veterans from all across the country which I thought was really sweet, the waitress even asked me to send them a picture if I knew any US veteran.
Best New Haven Pizza and the place lives up to its reputation. Ambience is cool with walls of photos. Seerver is super friendly. Ordered 3 pizzas. Stinger and hot oil, stinger and tomato, cheese and pepperoni. All came on thin crust and perfect cheese melt. Best gulped with cold beer. Also enjoyed old fashioned a d manhattan as a starter cocktail. Perfect autum evening with the crisp air added to a fantastic evening.
I really enjoyed Colony Grill. The pizza is super thin so you can go through a lot. Do not miss the jalapeño oil!!! It was so good. All the flavor without feeling the spiciness. I wish they sold the oil in bottles to go. Sadly they don't.
Love the pizza here. The thin crust is the best. I love that the pizzas are small enough to eat on your own. The salad pizza is delicious too! The outdoor bar/eating area has plenty of seating.
I have eaten at the original Pepe’s, Sally’s and Modern in New Haven. This was my first opportunity to come here to Colonial and try the pizza. What makes this place unique from the others in my opinion is the micro thin crust. It is very light. You can almost eat a whole one on your own.
Ladies and gentleman, vegan cheese is on the menu now. Finally I can eat a fine pizza. But don’t get excited and go greedy like me. I’ve ordered all the veggie toppings. Choose three please.
I tried the salad pizza a few days ago, well, the crust was delicious, and the salad is salad.
If you are not a vegan, go with the real cheese though.
I love going to Colony Grill!! Pizza is awesome, I really like the hot oil pizza. Both the Milford and Fairfield are easy to get to.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Milford
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes