Paul's is a long time favorite in town. family owned and family oriented as evident by their sponsorship of local little league for decades.
a good slice with quality ingredients. nice environment,
A local spectacular spot been around forever. The owner, Paul still runs it with his son Evan and other family members. Has the best garlic bread and the best grandma’s pizza around. Also spectacular Mediterranean pasta and salad. The rest of the menu is awesome as well. Definitely worth stopping by if you want a slice or good comfort Italian food. Well-known local, honored family Italian place and worth a visit. You won’t be disappointed.
It’s outdated, the food isn’t high quality, but it’s a Southampton institution. That being said, my husband and I went on a date night we’re we ordered one slice of pizza from 10 places from Wainscott to Hampton bays and Paul’s had the best slice. A bottle of Caesar dressing is always in the fridge. Don’t come here expecting much from the regular menu, and staff is always rotating so service is iffy. Stick with the pizza and you won’t be disappointed
Great place to dine in or to take out. The stuff is super friendly, the service was super fast, and the food was great. The dishes were so big we could hardly finish all and we definitely have to come back to try the deserts.
They also have great selection for breakfast or variety of Pizzas to grab on the go.
Paul's Italian Restaurant was beautiful.... Food was Delicious and the Prices are Amazing. This Restaurant has a large menu there is definitely something for Everyone here. The Staff here is very friendly especially our waitress (sorry I didn't get her name.) I also had the pleasure of meeting The Owner Paul! Who was extremely pleasant and very kind. I highly recommend this place for a lunch or dinner out with the family.. I will most certainly be coming back...
I am very picky with the meat that I chose. It’s always either really burnt or too dry. Well this place hit the spot. The sauce was delicious and the meat was perfect. The portion sizes and the prices are actually good considering it’s in the Hamptons. The only downside was that we waited a longer time than usual for the waiter. The place is clean and COVID safe.
Friendly local place. Have breakfast lunch and dinner there. All choices are delishous. Large menu..better restaurant than almost all on the east end and reasonably priced. All staff are extremely friendly.cant wait to try the whole menu! Thank you servers Caroline and Jessica !
Just came in for a slice at lunch , ended up leaving with 2 more !!
![5]( "Recensione")
From the outside passerbys may mistake Paul's as a simple pizzeria. But, stop right there! Enter, turn left. Inside awaits a very tempting menu that includes not only your traditional favorites that taste just like Nonna prepared it but, so much more for the entire family. The friendly staff and owner greet you like a relative they've been expecting.
My husband believes their Zuppe De Pesce to rival any exceptional dining experience. He washes the platter clean with Paul's delicious garlic bread, served crusty and warm to your dinner table. There are nightly specials often prepared using fresh fish, delicious complimentary sides and includes salad or soup. There is also an expansive menu of sandwiches, heroes, and appetizers to entice even the most reluctant eater in your family. And upon an unexpected return visit, enjoy one of the best 1/2 lb burgers and onion rings in town. Another item that will satisfy the most hearty of appetites. You can't miss here as when all else fails you've always had great pizza! So mangia over to Paul's Italian American Kitchen. Noono Paul is waiting to welcome you to the family!
Great experience here! We were served by Kylie, and she was awesome. She took her time to help us find options on the menu that would cater to our vegetarian preferences for the night, made jokes, and just overall made it an enjoyable dining experience. The quality of food was great, thankfully it wasn’t overly salty like a lot of Italian places. The garlic bread was amazing!! Most entrees were between $20-$30 and comes with garlic bread and salad. If I’m ever in this area again I’d definitely come back.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Southampton
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes