Pushy staff and cash only but very good pizza. Very crowded but I guess that's what you get when your voted 2nd best pizza in the USA. Love the ricotta on the pizza. Eggplant pizza was delicious.
Best pizza in the south east!! The line is typically out the door during lunch time but do not panic it moves fast and is worth the wait. The ingredients are fresh and they have a wide range of pizzas to choose from. Also always say yes to their free olive side , it is delicious! All their pizzas are good you really can't go wrong but my favorite is the lasagna one.
Pedimos 4 trozos diferentes de pizzas y todas estaban deliciosas. Tienen una masa fina y crujiente, y suficientes ingredientes que no decepcionan. La atención es muy rápida aunque el lugar para sentarse es un poco estrenó lo que fue un poco incomodo. Comi la pizza calabreze que tenía mozzarela, pollo, ricota, espinaca y Bolognesi y estaba muy rica. La recomiendo 100%.
The pizza's are great here. They have so many different types of gourmet pizzas - Eggplant pizza, Hawaiian, Lasagna pizza, Chicken and Spinach, Pizza Pomodoro etc. The Grandma's Pizza is outstanding and a must eat.
Two small problems though. One - They are a Cash only restaurant and Two - They are over crowded most of the times, with the queues extending outside the door quite often.
This pizza place is good not excellent.
WHATCH OUT THEY ONLY ACCEPT
C A S H
and if u dont have cash, dont worry, the also will earn % from their ATM.
IRS please give them a visit, i promise u they are not reporting
If u want to have the most expensive
Ice cream go there, $7.00 for a cone
Good luck
The pizza was really tasty. The have the really nice red pepper blend that added heat and flavor to any slice it was added to. I'd definitely go back. Hit them up the next time you are in town.
Amazing pizza!! Our family of 4 ate really well on $30!! We will definitely be coming back. Only thing to know ahead of time is that's it's CASH ONLY :))
I was visiting St. Augustine and stopped for dinner at Pizza Time on St. George Street. St. Augustine's Christmas parade apparently happened earlier in the day and the city was packed. It was wall to wall people all over, and Pizza Time was no exception. The first time I walked by the restaurant, the line was out the door and up the street. At that point, I didn't try getting food at the restaurant with a line that long.
So, if someone would have told me I would make this statement, I would deny it to the very end, but I am here to put it in writing today.  I experienced Pizza this weekend as good as, and I willingly say better than pie I have eaten in New York.  I grew up on New York pie and even in my travels all over Italy, there has never been any to match New York pie.  So where is this place you ask; St Augustine on St George St.
These guys have a trip advisor review stating that they have the second best pizza in America and after trying the "grandmas" and the pepperoni I'd agree. I will not be tasting pizza that good for a long long time... well worth a visit if you are in St Augustine
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in St. Augustine
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes