We drive all the way from Jacksonville for this Mexican food. It is the best in all of North Florida. The Ceviche is something else, we love to throw a dollop of the guacamole in it. Get the veggie burrito and add meat it’s to die for.
Fabulous, Authentic Mexican cuisine at its finest! A very classy twist on Sangria you can’t go wrong with white or red recipe. Staff was polite and courteous owner came out to meet my family.
If your looking for water downed Tex mex or surfer food you may want to dine elsewhere... The shrimp ceviche was killer and the peel & eat shrimp with custom blended Mexican spices are a must!
Honestly it is a welcomed Gem for any foodies who know great Mexican old school cuisine. The Sopa de Mayan was some of the best soup we’ve ever had.
We will be repeat customers as local Ponte Vedra Beach residents!
Scott, Liam & I had late brunch here today; it was very tasy! I had the Hangover Skillet with over-easy eggs, potatoes, peppers, onions and chorizo. Scott had Huevos Rancheros and Liam had Chips and Salsa. The salsa was super good!
I've eaten here twice. Both times the food was delicious. First time I had the carnitas, the second time the shrimp tacos and black beans and rice. Everything was so good. My friends all loved their dishes, too. A friend got the green burrito which I tasted. Wow.
I didn't give it a 5 because the first time the service was awful. The server was sloooooow and she tried to tell us that the happy hour prices didn't apply to our drinks. We had to go to the bar to get it straightened out. She also knew nothing about the menu. The second time the service was excellent. So maybe the first was a fluke.
The ambiance is great. We sat outside the first time and upstairs the second. A very relaxing vibe.
A-flipping-Mazing. We sat at bar on patio, drinks were amazing, oysters were perfect, we're coming back for breakfast. I recommend cucumber jalapeño, it's a best seller for a reason people.
I got the vegetarian burrito. It was filled with veggies, wrapped in a green tortilla, and covered with salsa. The guacamole was so tasty! The black bean soup was good as well.
Need service training. This is a great restaurant with delicious food and drink menu. We have repeatedly had bad service the last 3 times we've dined there. I hope management fixes their floor staff's neglectful and inattentive service issues. It's imperative for the success of your reputation because word is spreading that you have poor customer service and its a deterrent to dining at this restaurant.
The Hot Chocolate in the Mug is Great. Delicioso
Had dinner with my friends and everything was AMAZING!! The food was delicious, great service and the Margaritas. Everything is fresh and with great flavor. I recommend this place if you are looking for delicious and authentic Mexican food.
Miccosukeerootcellar
+4.5
Delicious food and fun atmosphere. Definitely a St. Augustine favorite. Cozy tiny restaurant with GREAT food.
Fantastic flavors. Mango on fish was fantastic. Not very many options for kids
We had the cochinita pibil platter and queso fundido and sangria! We are delighted, the queso is amazing! We shared the main dish and the Mayan spiced pork was juicy and tender! Maribel was a quick waitress and our glasses remained full!! We Will come back... yes the place is clean!
Had lunch here. I really enjoyed all the different flavors of the food. Our waiter Daniel was a real Gem. Love that there wasn't a wait when we showed up and we're seated right away. I look forward to my next trip to St. Augustine; Casa Maya will be on my list to visit again.
This is a really great restaurant. It was a nice atmosphere with great music playing. I order the Tacos Al Pastor and they were delicious. I was going to order more but time wasn't on my side. The staff there are really nice and friendly. They came immediately when we needed something and constantly asked us if we were okay. They had some good drinks that you could order too. I'm definitely coming back here when I'm in St. Augustin.
Fun spot, great atmosphere. (Only sat outside) live music was good and the food was great. Absolutely amaizing fresh guac. Plantains we're cooked perfectly.
This Amazing gem has flare, delicious food, live entertainment, trendy bar area to drink while your table is made ready. We were seated by Larry, the general manager, who made us feel right at home. Spacious parking lot right next door! Food is authentic and delicious.
My mind was blown and some other parts, by our bartender Xavier, he was very welcoming, knowledgeable, kept us entertained, and humoured. The cocktails that he crafts are absolutely amazing! The food here is also top notch, the people in the kitchen work with great ingredients and know what they are doing with them. I highly recommend this place!
Oysters were large and from from Maine. The guacamole was tasty but Kirstyn made the visit with her excellent service! We came back from the jalapeno margarita and were not disappointed.
We dined at Casa Maya on February 21st for lunch. We were immediately seated in the upstairs balcony which has a wonderful view of the street activity below.
Service was quick and attentive.
We had the corn tortillas and salsa to start followed by Cohinitia Pibil. There are add on’s available for an additional cost. We also had the Ceviche. Both were delicious.
I look forward to returning to St. Augustine and dining at Casa Maya again.
We came to Casa Maya for drinks. Really enjoyed the vibe of this place, especially the outdoor seating. Great place to chill and catch up with old friend. I ordered hibiscus flowerita and I forgot what my friend ordered. We both really liked our drinks. The service was good. Definitely will come back again next time and try out the food.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in St. Augustine
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes