This place is a must on our yearly visit to St. Augustine. We have yet to have a bad meal here. Amazing food, friendly service and the biggest (and best) pizza's this side of the Mississippi River!!
Stopped in for dinner tonight and was greeted with smiling faces and a hello! The food, especially the garlic knots, pizza and desserts are top notch, but their service cannot be beat. Highly recommend this small business, they're doing it right!
Friendly and accommodating staff. My wife and I came in unknowingly around closing time, we were able to sit and eat our meal. Our dinner was excellent, we had the chicken parmesan and baked ziti. We also had the chocolate cake, absolutely delicious!!! We will definitely be back again!!!
Good family italian food, but a little pricey. Could use a little more garlic and basil.
The best Pizza in St Augustine. Samantha and Anna always. Makes my visits the best. Paul Kevin and Kevin. Make the best pizza ALWAYS!!!
Meat Lovers Was Best Pizza Ever Had. Pizza was so good I slept with the box
We are moving to the beach and gave this a try. So glad we did! Best pizza since leaving New England. The subs won't disappoint, so much meat unlike other sub shops the slap a few pieces on.
The staff are all very friendly and attentive, the food is delicious. I've had several different things at Romano's on the island (chicken parm sub, fried ravioli, meatballs, penne vodka, chicken cacciatori, lasagna, calzones) and it was amazing every time. I highly recommend Romano's on the island to every one!
Horrible experience !!! Food took 1 hr and 25 minutes to be delivered 4 miles - Girl answering phones VERY rude actually hung up on me - Forgot dressing for my salad - Delivery driver didn't have change for my $20 - REALLY - I would not recommend -
Closest to NY Sicilian pizza! Excellent crust with that crunchy bottom and that sauce was outstanding! If you're ever in the area go by and have Anna and Austin hook you up.
Went the other night with a group of friends and everyone enjoyed the food, atmosphere and service! We have been coming here for years The new owners have updated the decor and told us that they will be soon extending their menu we can't wait! Definitely check this great restaurant out!
Great pizza, lots of options. We ere on vacation and decided on takeout for a break from seafood. It was really great! The pic is uploaded!!
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in St. Augustine
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes