Our first experience was a great one. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, small cheese pizza, 20 everything wings, and a large antipasto salad. The food was ready on time, the staff was very friendly, and our dinner was delicious. Bonus points - the owner's father helped me carry the food to my car. Highly recommend!
Last night I ordered a small sausage and peppers. I can't begin to tell you how impressed I was. I arrived too early to pick up so I waited around. Anthony, you never rushed that pizza while I stood there. It was beyond perfection. My mother never had your pizza until last night. Hands down our favorite pizza in town!! The crust is perfect! Thank you so much for not rushing it, well worth the wait!
The food we ordered was honestly the best I've had in a while! We had a large pizza, fried dough bites, sesame wings and garlic knot sliders and everything AMAZING!! Everything was cooked perfectly, the flavor of the wings and pizza were crazy good! They don't skimp on the cheese or sauce like other places around the area. We talked to the owners while we were there and they are great guys and you can see they love what they do! I am definitely coming back and recommend you call today and order!!!
I am more than impressed with this eatery. The employees were so pleasent. This is going to be my new pizza place. I recommend this for anyone looking for great prices and good food. ��
excellent food, very friendly, got the 2 lg with 40 wing special, a cheeses pizza and upside down pizza with a thin crispy crust excellent, wings everything and grilled wings were so good and crispy, fried dough bites with cinnamon sugar to die for, and pepperoni sliders on garlic knots wow will e returning, great prices
We've been ordering from Pie Squared for about a year now and we have always had delicious and fantastic food. It's always fresh and hot. I totally recommend the Cali wing's because they are the best wing's I've ever tasted, ever!! The sesame are good too, but a little spicy. We love the grilled, but they are all spectacular. If you love pizza, this is your go to place, no need for another.
This pizza changed my life!! Literally!
I was on the road with a couple friends, busking in the street. Anthony had just opened Pie Squared and invited us to all come try a slice.
He gave all three of us a perfect, freshly made, classic cheese slice on the house.
Not only was this one of the nicest things anyone has ever done, but this is literally the best pizza I’ve ever had!!!
My family is Italian (first generation) and lived 30 minutes from NYC so I’ve had good pizza, but this one was truly the absolute best, ever.
It’s been 3 years since I was in Utica, and I’m still dreaming of this pizza!!
It has forever ruined pizza for me lol 😉
No other pizza even comes close!
P.S. - He also gave us the little fried donuts with fresh raspberry sauce. Incredible also!
I was in town on business and stopped in to check it out. Anthony, the owner was very friendly and helpful. Despite being very busy and no apparent help, he was in total control. There was a few people ahead of me and he apologized in advance for the wait. Anthony recommended the square pizza. It was very good and fair price. I'll definitely be coming back when I'm in town. Can you imagine how great it would be if he had some good help? Great job Anthony!!!
I've been blown away by every new item I try from their menu. The very best pizza in Utica and beyond. Every specialty pie is out of this world. I especially like that the boneless wings are made from real, shaved off the bone chicken, and not just frozen breaded nuggets like most places. You can tell everything here is prepared with talent. So many creative flavors and options. Definitely try this place and it'll become one of your favorites!
Love the variety of wings. Pizza is pretty good. Customer service is amazing. Sometimes they're just too busy. But on more than one occasion def worth the wait. Always a good experience
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Utica
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes