Old City Barbecue Williamsburg

Old City Barbecue, Williamsburg 700 York St - Williamsburg

American
• Barbecue

92/100
Give a rating

What's your favorite Old City Barbecue's dish?

Full menu with prices and photos
Based on ratings and reviews
Updated
92 /100
Write a review

Ratings and reviews

92
/100
Based on 513 ratings and reviews
Updated

The menu of Old City Barbecue suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of Old City Barbecue

TA

Trip
Last update on 23/03/2023
4,5
228 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 06/12/2023
4,5
1 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 03/09/2020
4,8
102 Reviews

R

Restaurantji
Last update on 18/02/2020
4,5
122 Reviews

Menu Old City Barbecue

  • Snack
    • Organic Smoked & Fried Wings
    • Duroc Pork Belly Bites
    • Heritage Farms Fried Pigs Ears
    • Pickle Plate
    • Smoked Pimento Cheese
  • Soup / Salad
    • Brunswick Stew
    • Chopped Romaine Salad
    • Arugula Salad
  • Salad Add-Ons
    • Bacon
    • Pulled Pork
    • Chicken Tenders
    • Pulled Chicken
    • Portobello
  • . . .
  • Browse the menu

Available menus

Reviews

Facebook
Joseph Hautz
+5
I’m speechless! The service was top notch and the food....well I’m definitely taking my family back for more. The pork belly bites are the highlight of the starter menu along with the smoked pimento cheese. As for the meats, brisket is the best I’ve had in all my travels! The pulled pork and chicken was tender, moist and seasoned to perfection! All served piping hot and ready to go. The pablano Mac and cheese was to die for. The fries were excellent but the sweet potato waffle fries were definitely worth every bite. The fried pork belly was equally amazing! My son had the Bahn mi sandwich which he talked about the whole back to our resort. It too was fantastic. So much for being speechless, definitely one the top meals I’ve ever had. The only thing I’d like to see is a smoked artisan sausage added to the menu. Yes, it is a little pricier than normal low end bbq, but with locally sourced and sustainable menu items, the freshness and love put into the product is definitely noticeable. And the few more ‘exotic’ menu items are a great way to introduce something new but in a comfortable and familiar way. So for the few negative reviews I’ve read, it definitely wasn’t our experience. Nor was it he experience of the other diners we could hear raving about the food. This place is now in my top 5 eateries that I’ve ever visited.
Facebook
David Holcomb
+5
This place is IT!! I love brisket and this place is where it’s at!! Plenty of fat on the brisket to make it succulent. I took a chance on the pork belly and was pleased, thick cuts of pork with crispy fat edges......I am in heaven!!! Their tater salad has bacon, my favorite potatoe salad since my German oma’s. The cole slaw was crisp, tangy, and just the right amount of creamy, plus a little kick!! My server, Brian, was great. He brought us a Heritage Brewing Mint Chocolate Chip pint, interesting and good. This place is a must visit BBQ joint when your in or anywhere near Williamsburg VA!!!!
Facebook
Edward Mulvihill
+5
We had a large party on the last night of our family vacation last night. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. The atmosphere was great facilities were clean. But none of that compares to the food. OMG so good. Everyone in our party was impressed. I had the sweet and spicy wings, the pork belly tacos, mac & cheese and cornbread. Everything was Delicious and authentic. Great meal to end our family trip on. Highly recommend.
Facebook
Rachael Nelson
+5
Scratch made glory. Smoke, pickles, best pimento cheese I’ve had. If the slow smoked Duroc pork BBQ and brisket weren’t enough, trying all the house made condiments is worth another visit. Locally owned with uncompromising quality. Clean and unpretentious. Go and spend some money there!
Facebook
Delaine Shaw
+5
We just love this place. We eat here every time we come to Williamsburg. They have the Best staff and awesome food. The food gets better every visit!! We have a blast at Jamfest!!! See y'all on our next trip to Busch Gardens.
5
Wesley “djweso” Oman
+5
We had a great meal. The brisket was very good as was the pulled pork but the pork belly stole the show! It was fantastic! The greens were very good. Pickles were tasty. Not my style of coleslaw but good.
5
Dondré
+5
Absolutely phenomenal barbeque. I mean really, it's fantastic. The service is also very great. Our server was excellent, nice and patient as I ordered almost one of everything on the menu. The Bourbon honey mustard sauce on the wings is excellent. The ribs amazing. I'm telling you this is some actual good BBQ.
4
Bianca Lomax
+4
Came with my patient and her ladies group. The service was wonderful. I had the arugula salad and I don’t eat meat. They also have a portobello mushroom burger also. Price was fair given the size of portions. Will definitely come back for the drinks as they have what looked like a decent size bar.
5
Anna M Hatcher
+5
Delicious smoked meat and super fresh arugula salad. Also impressed about the great service and waffle sweet potato fries. 5 stars of 5. Clean. Tasty. Kind.
5
Olivia Lindsey
+5
I got the pick 3 tacos sampler: the chicken was good, the pork belly was better, and the brisket was best. My side was the poblano Mac and cheese which was EXCELLENT. Very creamy with the perfect amount of heat. 10/10 highly recommend the brisket taco and Mac and cheese. The wait staff was also very good, fast, and friendly.

Description

Timetable

Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
11:30 AM - 08:30 PM
Wednesday:
11:30 AM - 08:30 PM
Thursday:
11:30 AM - 08:30 PM
Friday:
11:30 AM - 09:30 PM
Saturday:
11:30 AM - 09:30 PM
Sunday:
11:30 AM - 08:30 PM

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Facebook
Facebook

R

Restaurantji

Info

Compare the best restaurants near Old City Barbecue

bianca Sluurpy rate Google rate Facebook rate
TA

Old City Barbecue

92 4.5 4.8 4.5
Starbucks 75 3.6 4.5
McDonald's 70 3 2.5
Frothy Moon Brewhouse 91 4.6 4.5
1607 Coffee Company 100 5
Local Burgy 91 4.6 4.5
Mr. C's Pub & Grill 80 4 4 4
Pho 79 Vietnamese Noodle Shop 82 4.1 4.5

OLD CITY BARBECUE, WILLIAMSBURG - 700 York St - Menu and Prices

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 92 based on 513 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +1 757-378-5125

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1
X

How do you rate your experience at Old City Barbecue?
INVIA