Name: St. Peter's Catch Restaurant
Address: 58 S Erie Ave, Montauk, Long Island, I-11954-5370
Telephone: +1 631-668-7100
Price range: $$ - $$$
Rating: 82

The menu of St. Peter's Catch Restaurant suggested by Sluurpy users

Ratings of St. Peter's Catch Restaurant

Trip

Last update on 19/03/2024

4,0

46 Reviews

Google

Last update on 23/12/2023

4,2

48 Reviews

Menupix

Last update on 06/05/2020

4,0

10 Reviews

Reviews

DJ Hohn

Amazing lobster Rolls! Unspoiled by dressings or spices, just meat on a fresh New England style bun. I am a bit spoiled since there are lobster fisherman in my family from Maine. I have never had lobster this fresh unless it came off my cousins boat that day.

Catherine Murtha

Love their fish toco. Have to go eat there every time out in mtk. Owner is a really nice gent friendly and happy and staff lovely ladies. So you must try then go next door to Montauk brewery.

Drew Turano

Very good lobster roll. Friendly staff. Pricey but it’s Montauk and u do get what u pay for. 4/5 due to smaller portion than I expected. And fries— pass on those.

READ ALL REVIEWS

How would you rate your experience at St. Peter's Catch Restaurant?

Description

Cuisine

Seafood American
Meal types

Breakfast Dinner Lunch

Price range

$$ - $$$

Report the restaurant as closed

Request the menu of St. Peter's Catch Restaurant

Join the community of Montauk

Add St. Peter's Catch Restaurant to the address book

Timetable

Monday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Tuesday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Wednesday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Thursday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Friday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Saturday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Sunday:

09:00 AM - 09:00 PM

Compare the best restaurants near St. Peter's Catch Restaurant

				TA
St. Peter's Catch Restaurant	82	4.2		4
Harvest on Fort Pond	88	4.5	4	4.5
Naturally Good Foods and Cafe	87	4.4		4.5
Montauk Bake Shoppe Limited	80	4.4	4	4.5
Inlet Seafood Restaurant	80	4.3	4	4
668 The Gig Shack	80	4.4	4	4
Joni's	76	4.4	2.3	4.5
Pizza Village	80	4	4	4

The Chef reccomend

Shrimp Lobster Fish Fish & Chips Lobster Roll Tapas Fish Taco Tacos

Related restaurants

	Swallow East Restaurant
	Bennett Shellfish
	Plaza Surf & Sports
	Bex Waffles
	Naturally Good Foods and Cafe
	Ben & Jerry's

The Restaurant St. Peter's Catch Restaurant, recommended for its excellent non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy, has garnered 16 positive reviews and is noted for a price of $$ - $$$. Being one of the best places in Montauk, it's always advisable to book to ensure a spot. Call None. If the number is busy, you can use the contact form on None., The place is ranked 45 out of 81 in the Sluurpy ranking of Montauk, with a rating of 81.
In the last 3 months the most recommended dishes have been non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy and non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy. You might also like Lobster and Fish Taco., Now we focus on the cuisine, which is Seafood, ideal if you want to savor non abbiamo informazioni sulle opzioni di cucina.
To summarize
What can I eat at St. Peter's Catch Restaurant?
non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy and non abbiamo informazioni sui piatti Sluurpy
What is the rating of the reviews?
Rating: 81
How much does it cost?
Price: $$ - $$$
Rating

Cuisine 🧑‍🍳: 16 recommendations
Ambience 🍽️: 6 recommendations
Service 💕: 14 recommendations

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT

What's your favorite St. Peter's Catch Restaurant's dish?

Ratings and reviews

/100

Based on 164 ratings and reviews

Updated 2024-03-19

St. Peter's Catch Restaurant Montauk

American

• Seafood

• Sit down

MENU

MENU

MENU↗

MENU

MENU

The menu of St. Peter's Catch Restaurant suggested by Sluurpy users