Wonderful, friendly and attentive service. The restaurant must have been renovated since many of the photos posted on Google were taken. It now looks very upscale! However the menu still has breakfast and lunch classics. Food arrived hot and delicious. Prices were very reasonable. Our server Julia was so nice, and deserves a special mention! Highly recommended for a delicious breakfast or lunch in warm, friendly surroundings.
Dropped in for a Sunday lunch, needing a handicap-accessible facility.
Service was pleasant and efficient. I had the best Reuben I have ever eaten and my husband , who ordered a very rare hamburger, received exactly that. It appears that restaurants don't want to give a customer rare meat any more and we've been disappointed on many occasions.
This place is a find and, although we don't get out to Southold very often, this will be the place to eat when we do.
Perfectly poached eggs ( a rarity, I find), delicious real corned beef hash (try it here if all you've ever had was that stuff from a can), out waitress came by to top off coffee as if on cue, the price and service were both very friendly.
In addition to the regular breakfast items, Jeni's offers truly special specials: I've never heard of breakfast risotto (cooked w/ veggies, cheese & other good things) but will have to give it a try next time I go.
Always an excellent meal! Good home cooked food with fresh ingredients and awesome staff. We love it there and have been going for breakfast and the occasional lunch for years.
Typically food here is pretty good for what it is. Basically a breakfast and lunch place.
I went there one Sunday and ordered a simple eggs/bacon/toast breakfast and thought I'd treat myself to what they had listed on the menu as "fresh squeezed orange juice". That to me that means only one thing - orange juice that has been freshly squeezed and came from an orange. Not a container. But what do I know?
When I tasted the orange juice it was pretty clear it was not fresh squeezed. So I asked the waitress if it was fresh squeezed or from a container. Her answer was "both". So I asked her "how's that"? She replied that it was fresh-squeezed in Florida then put into a container. So basically it was (hopefully!) Tropicana or some other Brand X container orange juice.
You just can't make this stuff up! This should have definitely been a Fawlty Towers skit. I'm still laughing about it and they didn't even charge me for the entertainment 😁
I often have clients meet with me on the weekends to look at vacation homes throughout the North Fork. My customers love to stop into Main Street Grill for a cup of coffee and baked goods when the arrive in the morning after their trip out from NYC or Nassau County. The service is small town perfect and the baked items are always a hit. They serve a mean breakfast at the Main Street Grill.
Come here for a hearty breakfast or brunch. Service is friendly and quick, food is tasty and fairly priced. For these reasons I come back frequently with the family.
Our go to breakfast place. We also caught their pop up dinner . Salads, steak and chicken dishes were delicious. Awesome staff also!
My favorite place to eat on the North Fork. Always pleasant staff, fantastic home cooked food, and great service.
Delicious .... went for dinner when there was a pop up dinner event and everything was just perfect ... just a bit of a wait but well worth it.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Southold
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes