My wife and i went to surprise someone and figured we would get a bit to eat. Well lots of things on the menu looked good. My wife had the pizza and i had the chicken club. Let's just say that you don't see this kind of quality and quantity of food in a lot of places. The club sandwich was awesome and my wife loved the pizza. The 2 sides we had was mac & cheese and potato slices we like nothing we've ever had anywhere, York54 is a must go. The service was just as good as the food. Great job. Will recommend to anyone.
I cannot even begin to say how incredible this place was I was meeting up w girlfriends For a getaway but had arrived early I needed something quick to eat
I go in here it smells great has a great vibe they are very efficient and it was very quick I had a BLT. That was absolutely amazing with a beer and a nice cold glass
Everyone around me was having pizza which also looked amazing great great little place
I have had the food many times. It is always amazing & fresh & delicious! Yesterday I had the kale salad with cashews, grapes, beets & goat cheese. I added curried chicken...omg is all I can say! It was a large portion & I had leftovers for home! Friendly, efficient staff!
Definitely worth going.
Ordered the Hard Cider BBQ Gluten free pizza and it was the best gf crust I’ve had yet. The toppings were really fresh and tasty as well. Was ready for pickup in a timely manner. Staff was friendly.
Tonight we had the BBQ chicken pizza and the 54 salad- both were delicious! When I arrived to pick up our food, I noticed the specials board with the salad with fresh peaches and goat cheese- that is now a family favorite! Thank you guys for such delicious food!
Just moved to the area and York 54 came recommended from locals. We got the Greek salad, perfect 10 pizza and a GF Pesto pizza. The salad was exceptional - fresh, flavorful and distinct (olives, artichokes, feta dressing) The pizza was very good too. Good ingredients, unique flavors and good quality. We recommend and would definitely go again.
What a find! Never knew about this place but stopped in with a friend at her recommendation. Had the daily special ribs and a Thai chicken pizza. Both were outstanding, pizza especially unique and delicious. Can't wait to come back and try everything on the menu!
We went in last minute for pizza. The store is very small inside but clean and the staff was super friendly. Alot of people coming in for take out orders. Pizza was delicious, lots of variety to choose from. Will definitely order out again.
The best wings and the best taco pizza you will ever have. Also really great beer selection. Have been coming here for years. The only con would be the hours. Wish they were open longer.
Ordered takeout via online with no issues. Overall, the food was delicious (partner and I tried their hamburger quesadilla, personal sized salami and fig pizza, street corn, and house salad). Really loved the option for personal pizza, sometimes a small is just too much. I liked the flavors of the Genoa salami and the fig preserve along with the onions and brie. The next time I look forward to trying their summer garden and their wings. My fiancé enjoyed his quesadilla and I'm glad I took a risk on the corn - it was packed with flavor and as much as I love eating it off the cob I did appreciate the work already being done for me.
Good to know we have another solid choice for pizza.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in York
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes